Properties and Important Reactions of Aldehydes & Ketones
The properties and important reactions of aldehydes and ketones all come from one polar group, C=O. Its dipole explains boiling points and solubility. Its electrophilic carbon explains nucleophilic addition of HCN, Grignard reagents, bisulphite, alcohols and ammonia derivatives. Its acidic -hydrogens explain haloform and aldol reactions. This page covers the properties and important reactions of aldehydes and ketones exactly as tested in JEE Main, JEE Advanced and NEET: mechanisms, reactivity order, oxidation and reduction, distinguishing tests, aldol and Cannizzaro reactions.
- Cyanohydrin
- ★ Must learn Grignard
- Acetal
- Ammonia derivatives
- ★ Must learn Tollens' test
- ★ Must learn Haloform
- Clemmensen / Wolff-Kishner
- ★ Must learn Aldol
- ★ Must learn Cannizzaro
1. Physical Properties
Methanal is a gas at room temperature. Ethanal boils near room temperature (about 20 °C) and is handled as a volatile liquid. Other lower aldehydes and ketones are liquids; higher members are solids. Lower aldehydes have sharp, pungent smells, while many higher aldehydes and ketones smell pleasant and are used in perfumes and flavourings.
Boiling points
The polar carbonyl group creates dipole-dipole attractions between molecules, so aldehydes and ketones boil higher than hydrocarbons and ethers of similar molar mass. They have no O-H or N-H bond, however, so they cannot hydrogen bond with each other, and they boil lower than alcohols of similar mass.
Solubility
Although they cannot hydrogen bond with each other, aldehydes and ketones have lone pairs on oxygen and act as hydrogen-bond acceptors towards molecules with O-H or N-H bonds, such as water and alcohols. For the same reason they are good solvents for polar hydroxylic substances. Methanal, ethanal and propanone are miscible with water in all proportions. Aldehydes and ketones with up to about four carbons are appreciably soluble, and solubility falls as the hydrocarbon part grows. All aldehydes and ketones are fairly soluble in organic solvents such as benzene, ether, methanol and chloroform.
Methanal and ethanal in practice
Methanal is stored and used as formalin, about a 40% aqueous solution. Dry methanal is generated by heating one of its solid forms: 1,3,5-trioxane (cyclic trimer) or paraformaldehyde (linear polymer). These form spontaneously when a trace of acid is added to pure methanal.
Ethanal is also used as its cyclic trimer paraldehyde (bp about 125 °C, used in medicine as a sedative) and tetramer metaldehyde (used as bait and poison for snails and slugs). Both form under acid catalysis, and heating either one gives dry ethanal.
Similar molar masses give similar dispersion forces, so the polar groups decide. Non-polar butane has only weak dispersion forces. The polar C=O of propanal adds dipole-dipole attraction, but with no O-H it cannot hydrogen bond with itself. Propan-1-ol forms hydrogen bonds, which are stronger.
Weakly polar methoxyethane sits just above butane; propanone, like propanal, has C=O dipoles. Order: butane < methoxyethane < propanal < propanone < propan-1-ol.
2. Reactivity of the Carbonyl Group
Because oxygen is more electronegative than carbon, it takes the greater share of the double-bond electrons. The partial positive carbonyl carbon is attacked by nucleophiles. Aldehydes are more reactive than ketones for two reasons.
- Electronic: alkyl groups donate electrons compared with hydrogen, so an aldehyde carbon carries a larger than a ketone carbon. Aromatic aldehydes and ketones are less reactive still, because the ring donates electrons by resonance.
- Steric: hydrogen is smaller than an alkyl group, so the carbonyl carbon of an aldehyde is more accessible. For the same reason, ketones with small alkyl groups react faster than ketones with bulky ones.
To rank carbonyl compounds for nucleophilic addition, look first at the groups on C=O (H beats an alkyl group, an alkyl group beats a benzene ring), then at ring substituents: electron-withdrawing groups such as raise the reactivity and electron-donating groups such as lower it.
Two more orders follow the same two effects. For simple aldehydes and ketones: butanone < propanone < propanal < ethanal. For aromatic compounds: acetophenone < p-tolualdehyde < benzaldehyde < p-nitrobenzaldehyde. Acetophenone is a ketone, so it comes last; a methyl group on the ring pushes electrons towards the carbonyl carbon and lowers its , while a nitro group withdraws electrons and raises it. Benzaldehyde is less reactive than propanal for the same reason: resonance with the ring lowers the on its carbonyl carbon.
Compared with carboxylic acid derivatives
Aldehydes and ketones are less reactive towards nucleophiles than acyl halides and acid anhydrides, but more reactive than esters, carboxylic acids and amides:
In an acid derivative RCOY, the atom Y attached to the carbonyl group has a lone pair that it can donate by resonance, placing some positive charge on Y and less on carbon. The weaker the base , the less it donates and the better it withdraws electrons inductively, so the more reactive the carbonyl group. is a very weak base in acyl halides and anhydrides and a stronger base in esters, acids and amides.
There is also a difference in what happens next. In acid derivatives, Y can leave, so they undergo nucleophilic substitution. In aldehydes and ketones, the group on the carbonyl carbon is H or R, and and are far too basic to leave. Aldehydes and ketones therefore undergo nucleophilic addition.
Substitution at the carbonyl group of acid derivatives is taught on the Carboxylic Acid Derivatives page.
3. Nucleophilic Addition: The General Mechanism
- Good nucleophile: it attacks the carbonyl carbon directly, giving a tetrahedral alkoxide. The alkoxide is then protonated by the solvent or added acid.
- Poor nucleophile: an acid catalyst first protonates the carbonyl oxygen, which makes the carbon much more open to attack, and the weak nucleophile then adds.
- Nucleophile with a spare lone pair and H (such as an amine): after addition, water is eliminated. This is nucleophilic addition-elimination.
For the first path, the steps are these. In step 1 (slow) the nucleophile approaches the carbonyl carbon from a direction roughly perpendicular to the plane of its orbitals. The carbon changes from to , and a tetrahedral alkoxide forms. In step 2 (fast) the alkoxide takes a proton from the reaction medium, so the net result is addition of and across C=O. Alkenes, by contrast, add electrophiles.
4. Addition of Carbon Nucleophiles
Grignard reagents
Addition of a Grignard reagent to C=O forms a new C-C bond. Because both the carbonyl compound and the Grignard reagent can be varied, many alcohols can be made. Methanal gives a primary alcohol, other aldehydes give secondary alcohols, and ketones give tertiary alcohols. With carbon dioxide, a Grignard reagent gives a carboxylic acid with one more carbon (taught on the Preparation of Carboxylic Acids page).
(a) propanone
(b) 1,1,1,3,3,3-hexafluoropropan-2-one
(c) 1-phenylethan-1-one
(d) 3,3-dimethylbutan-2-one
Hexafluoropropanone adds water almost completely, giving the gem-diol . Its six F atoms withdraw electrons strongly and put a large on the carbonyl carbon, which destabilises the C=O compound and favours the hydrate.
In the other ketones alkyl or aryl groups donate electrons and stabilise C=O, so very little hydrate forms (0.2% for propanone). Answer: (b).
(a) 3-methylpentanal
(b) hex-4-en-3-ol
(c) hexan-3-ol
(d) 3-methylpentan-1-ol
A Grignard reagent is a very reactive nucleophile, and it adds directly to the carbonyl carbon of an ,-unsaturated aldehyde (1,2-addition). (a) would need 1,4-addition, and (c) and (d) would need a reduction.
Work-up gives , with the C=C intact. Answer: (b) hex-4-en-3-ol.
Acetylide ions
A terminal alkyne is converted into an acetylide ion by a strong base such as in liquid . The acetylide ion is another carbon nucleophile. It adds to aldehydes and ketones, and acid is added at the end to protonate the alkoxide.
The trichloromethyl anion from chloroform and KOH adds to propanone in the same way, giving chloretone; this is beyond the JEE Main and NEET syllabus and is taught on the Polyhalogen Compounds page.
Hydrogen cyanide: cyanohydrins
HCN adds to aldehydes and ketones to form cyanohydrins, increasing the carbon count by one. The cyanide ion attacks the carbonyl carbon, and the oxyanion then takes a proton from an undissociated HCN molecule. HCN itself is a weak acid, so a trace of base is added to supply .
Cyanide is a much weaker base than other carbon nucleophiles ( of HCN 9.2, of ethyne 25, of ethane about 50), so the cyano group is also the easiest to eliminate from the addition product. A neutral cyanohydrin is stable, but in basic solution the OH group loses its proton and is expelled, regenerating the carbonyl compound.
Crowding near the carbonyl group lowers the yield. Cyclohexanone gives its cyanohydrin in good yield, but 2,2,6,6-tetramethylcyclohexanone, with two methyl groups on each side of the C=O, gives almost none.
Cyanohydrins are useful because of what they can become. Acid-catalysed hydrolysis gives an -hydroxy carboxylic acid, and catalytic hydrogenation gives a primary amine with an OH group on the -carbon.
Heated with concentrated , the cyanohydrin of a ketone that has an -hydrogen also loses water, and its CN group is hydrolysed, giving an ,-unsaturated acid. Propanone cyanohydrin gives 2-methylpropenoic acid, .
HCN adds to C=O, and acid hydrolyses -CN to -COOH:
2-Hydroxy-2-methylbutanoic acid, an -hydroxy acid.
5. Addition of Sulphur Nucleophiles
Sodium hydrogensulphite (bisulphite)
Sodium hydrogensulphite adds to aldehydes and ketones to form bisulphite addition products. The reaction is reversible. The equilibrium lies to the right for most aldehydes and to the left for most ketones, for steric reasons; small ketones such as methyl ketones and unhindered cyclic ketones react to some extent. The addition product is water-soluble, and dilute mineral acid or alkali turns it back into the carbonyl compound, so the reaction is used to separate and purify aldehydes.
Bisulphite addition is reversible, and the bulky ion makes the carbonyl carbon tetrahedral. The equilibrium lies to the right for most aldehydes but to the left for most ketones, for steric reasons; only methyl ketones and small cyclic ketones give enough adduct.
In the other two ketones, branched groups on both sides of C=O block attack. Steric hindrance keeps the equilibrium far to the left.
Thiols: thioacetals and desulphurisation
Aldehydes and ketones react with thiols, with an acid or catalyst, to give thioacetals. Ethane-1,2-dithiol gives cyclic thioacetals. Raney nickel removes the sulphur and adds hydrogen, so thioacetal formation followed by desulphurisation converts C=O into .
6. Addition of Oxygen Nucleophiles
Water: hydrates (gem-diols)
Water adds to aldehydes and ketones to form hydrates, which have two OH groups on the same carbon. Water is a poor nucleophile, so the reaction is slow unless catalysed by acid or base. A catalyst changes the rate at which equilibrium is reached, not its position.
The extent of hydration varies enormously: only 0.2% of propanone is hydrated at equilibrium, but 99.9% of methanal is. Alkyl groups stabilise the carbonyl compound by electron donation, making it less reactive, and they destabilise the hydrate. In the carbonyl compound the groups are 120° apart, but in the tetrahedral hydrate they are pushed to about 109.5° and crowd each other. Most hydrates cannot be isolated and exist only in solution.
Even when the hydrate is too small to detect, labelling proves the reaction happens. A ketone left in water enriched with is recovered with in its carbonyl group, which is only possible through the hydrate.
- adds to the ester C=O: (A) = , the magnesium salt of a hemiacetal.
- (A) re-forms C=O and expels methoxide as (methanol after work-up): (B) 1-phenylpropan-1-one.
- (C) = ; acid then gives (D).
A ketone is more reactive than an ester, so (B) is attacked by the excess Grignard reagent as soon as it forms. (D) = 3-phenylpentan-3-ol.
Alcohols: hemiacetals and acetals
Dissolving an aldehyde or ketone in an alcohol sets up an equilibrium with a hemiacetal, which has an -OH and an -OR group on the same carbon. The same name is now used for the product from ketones, which was formerly called a hemiketal. Open-chain hemiacetals are usually too unstable to isolate, but cyclic hemiacetals with five- or six-membered rings are much more stable. Hemiacetal formation is catalysed by both acids and bases.
A cyclic hemiacetal stays in equilibrium with a little of its open-chain hydroxy aldehyde, so it still reduces Tollens' reagent. Glucose is the best-known case (see the Carbohydrates notes in Biomolecules).
With dry HCl gas as catalyst, the hemiacetal reacts with a second molecule of alcohol to give an acetal, which has two -OR groups on the same carbon. Dry HCl protonates the carbonyl oxygen, which makes the carbonyl carbon more open to attack by the alcohol. In aqueous mineral acid every step reverses, and acetals and ketals are hydrolysed back to the aldehyde or ketone. Acetal formation is not favoured for ketones with simple alcohols, but cyclic acetals, called ethylene glycol ketals, form readily when a ketone is treated with excess ethane-1,2-diol (ethylene glycol) and dry acid.
Acetals as protecting groups
Acetals are stable in basic solution and towards nucleophiles and hydride reagents, because they are really gem-diethers. To react one group in a molecule while leaving a carbonyl group untouched, convert the carbonyl group into an acetal, carry out the reaction, and then hydrolyse the acetal with aqueous acid.
For example, a keto group is reduced more easily than an ester group, so cannot reduce only the ester of ethyl 3-oxocyclopentanecarboxylate. Protecting the ketone as a cyclic acetal with ethane-1,2-diol first lets reduce the ester to . Acid hydrolysis then gives back the ketone.
Dilute acid also hydrolyses a vinyl (enol) ether. The proton adds to the end of the C=C, giving the same kind of oxocarbenium ion as in acetal hydrolysis; water adds, and the hemiacetal breaks into a carbonyl compound and an alcohol: .
(a) Syn addition gives (A) cis-4,4-dimethylcyclopentane-1,2-diol. Its two OH groups, on one face, both bond to the carbonyl carbon of pentan-3-one with loss of water: (B) is the cyclic acetal, its O-C-O ring fused to the cyclopentane ring. Check: + − = . Acetals resist base but not acid.
(b) In the trans diol the OH groups point to opposite faces of the rigid five-membered ring and cannot both reach one carbon; a trans-fused ring would be too strained. (Flexible trans-cyclohexane-1,2-diol does form such acetals.) The trans cyclopentane diol forms no cyclic acetal.
A Grignard reagent would attack a free CHO group, so protect it first.
- Ethane-1,2-diol, : the cyclic acetal, 2-(4-bromophenyl)-1,3-dioxolane.
- Mg, dry ether: the aryl Grignard reagent. The acetal is stable to this strong base.
- Dry ice (): the magnesium carboxylate.
- Dilute acid gives COOH and hydrolyses the acetal: 4-formylbenzoic acid.
7. Addition of Nitrogen Nucleophiles
Aldehydes and ketones react with ammonia, primary amines and other ammonia derivatives to form compounds with a C=N double bond. The reaction is reversible and catalysed by acid; the product is favoured because the addition product loses water rapidly. The tetrahedral addition product still has a lone pair on nitrogen, so it is not stable: it loses water, and loss of a proton gives the neutral product. Overall this is nucleophilic addition-elimination.
| Reagent | Name | Product | Product type |
|---|---|---|---|
| ammonia | imine | ||
| primary amine | substituted imine (Schiff's base) | ||
| hydroxylamine | oxime | ||
| hydrazine | hydrazone | ||
| phenylhydrazine | phenylhydrazone | ||
| 2,4-dinitrophenylhydrazine (2,4-DNP, Brady's reagent) | 2,4-DNP derivative: yellow, orange or red solid | ||
| semicarbazide | semicarbazone |
In semicarbazide only the farthest from the C=O group reacts. The other and the NH have their lone pairs delocalised into the carbonyl group, like an amide.
Why the pH must be controlled
There must be enough acid to protonate the OH of the tetrahedral intermediate so that water, not the much more basic , is the leaving group. Too much acid, however, protonates the amine, and protonated amines are not nucleophiles.
For acetone with hydroxylamine, the rate is highest at about pH 4.5. Below this, more and more hydroxylamine is protonated. Above it, less and less of the intermediate is in its reactive protonated form. The of protonated hydroxylamine is about 6.0, so at pH 4.5 most of the amine is protonated. The small free fraction is enough, while there is still plenty of acid to catalyse the loss of water.
Imine formation is reversible: in aqueous acid, imines are hydrolysed back to the carbonyl compound and the amine, which is protonated and so cannot take part in the reverse reaction.
Semicarbazone formation is reversible.
(a) Addition turns the ring carbon of cyclohexanone from sp2 to sp3, relieving eclipsing strain, while the aldehyde's C=O is conjugated with the ring (smaller ) and loses this on addition. Mainly cyclohexanone semicarbazone: kinetic control.
(b) In time, it reverts and the aldehyde captures the semicarbazide; its C=N is conjugated with the furan ring. Mainly furan-2-carbaldehyde semicarbazone: thermodynamic control.
Which is more reactive towards HCN, propanal or propanone, and why?
What does a cyanohydrin give with and heat?
Which way does the bisulphite equilibrium lie for most ketones?
Why is dry HCl, not aqueous acid, used to make an acetal?
What is the product of a ketone with hydroxylamine?
8. Oxidation
Aldehydes are oxidised to carboxylic acids very easily, because they have a hydrogen on the carbonyl carbon. Strong oxidants (, , ) work, and so do very mild ones, which makes these tests for aldehydes. Ketones are not oxidised by mild reagents, so the same tests distinguish aldehydes from ketones.
Tollens' test
Tollens' reagent is freshly prepared ammoniacal silver nitrate, . Warming it with an aldehyde oxidises the aldehyde and reduces silver ions to metallic silver, which forms a silver mirror on the glass. The reaction occurs in alkaline medium, and the aldehyde is oxidised to its carboxylate anion. It does not attack C=C bonds, so it converts ,-unsaturated aldehydes (made by aldol condensation and dehydration) into ,-unsaturated acids.
Fehling's and Benedict's solutions
Fehling's reagent is made of two solutions mixed in equal amounts before the test. Fehling's solution A is aqueous copper(II) sulphate, and Fehling's solution B is alkaline sodium potassium tartrate (Rochelle salt), which holds the copper(II) ions in solution as a complex. Benedict's solution uses citrate instead. Warming either with an aldehyde gives a red-brown precipitate of . Both are weak oxidants: they oxidise aliphatic aldehydes but not aromatic aldehydes such as benzaldehyde.
α-Hydroxy ketones such as fructose also reduce Tollens' reagent and Fehling's solution, because in base they change into aldehydes (see the Carbohydrates notes in Biomolecules).
Schiff's reagent
Schiff's reagent is a solution of the magenta dye rosaniline hydrochloride that has been decolourised with . Aldehydes restore the pink-magenta colour; ketones generally do not.
Only the aldehyde reacts, and 1 mol of propanal gives 1 mol of . Propanal = 0.400 × 1.45 = 0.580 g; M = 3(12) + 6(1) + 16 = 58, so it is 0.580/58 = 0.0100 mol.
M() = 2(63.5) + 16 = 143, so the mass is 0.0100 × 143 = 1.43 g. About 1.43 g of red forms.
Oxidation of ketones
Ketones are oxidised only by strong oxidising agents at high temperature. The reaction breaks C-C bonds next to the carbonyl group, giving a mixture of carboxylic acids with fewer carbons than the ketone. Butanone, for example, can break on either side of its carbonyl group: breaking C1-C2 gives propanoic acid (and carbon dioxide), and breaking C2-C3 gives ethanoic acid.
9. Reduction
To alcohols
Addition of hydride ion from or gives an oxyanion that is protonated when water or dilute acid is added afterwards. The overall result is addition of to C=O. Aldehydes give primary alcohols and ketones give secondary alcohols. Catalytic hydrogenation over Ni, Pt or Pd does the same, but it also reduces C=C bonds.
With , the carbonyl oxygen complexes with boron while a hydride moves to the carbonyl carbon. All four hydrogens are transferred, one to each of four carbonyl molecules, and hydrolysis of the tetraalkoxyborate releases the alcohol.
To hydrocarbons: Clemmensen and Wolff-Kishner
Clemmensen reduction converts C=O into by refluxing with zinc amalgam and concentrated HCl. It is especially useful for ketones carrying phenolic or carboxylic groups, which survive. It fails with acid-sensitive and high molecular mass substrates, and ,-unsaturated ketones lose both the C=C and the C=O.
The mechanism is thought to involve the protonated carbonyl group receiving electrons from the zinc surface.
Wolff-Kishner reduction heats the carbonyl compound with hydrazine and KOH (usually in ethylene glycol). The hydrazone forms first. Heat and hydroxide then remove the N-H protons in turn, and loss of gas drives the reaction to the hydrocarbon. It suits compounds that are sensitive to acid.
Zn(Hg) and conc. HCl, reflux. Acid conditions: use it when the rest of the molecule survives acid.
and KOH in ethylene glycol, heat. Basic conditions: use it when the rest of the molecule is sensitive to acid.
Phosphorus pentachloride also replaces the carbonyl oxygen, here by two chlorine atoms, giving a gem-dichloride: . A strong base such as then removes two HCl and gives an alkyne (taught on the Preparation of Alkynes page).
10. Reactions Involving the -Hydrogen
Acidity of -hydrogens
A C-H bond next to a carbonyl group is unusually easy to break. The electron-withdrawing carbonyl group pulls electron density from the C-H bond, and the anion formed, the enolate ion, is stabilised by resonance, with the negative charge shared between carbon and oxygen. The of propanone is about 19, compared with about 50 for an alkane.
A -hydrogen gains nothing like this. The inductive effect falls off quickly with distance, and an anion on the -carbon would be insulated from the carbonyl group by a saturated carbon, so it gets no resonance stabilisation. or CH groups next to a carbonyl group (or another strongly electron-attracting group) are called active methylene or active methyne groups. A flanked by two carbonyl groups, as in pentane-2,4-dione ( about 9), is especially acidic.
Halogenation and the haloform reaction
Chlorine or bromine replaces one or more -hydrogens. Propanone can be monobrominated in glacial acetic acid:
Halogenation is catalysed by both acids and bases. In alkaline solution a second and third halogen go in faster than the first, because each halogen makes the remaining -H more acidic, so tribromoacetone and bromoform are isolated.
Aldehydes and ketones with -hydrogens also react with sulphuryl chloride at room temperature, without a catalyst, replacing only the -hydrogens: gives .
A methyl ketone (or ethanal) in excess halogen and base is trihalogenated on the methyl group. Hydroxide then cleaves the group off as haloform, . With iodine this is the iodoform test: a yellow precipitate of . Alcohols of the type , including ethanol, also give it, because the reagent first oxidises them to methyl ketones.
The hypohalite does not attack a C=C bond, and the acid formed has one carbon fewer than the ketone. For example, 3-methylpent-3-en-2-one with sodium hypochlorite gives chloroform and sodium 2-methylbut-2-enoate. Sodium hypochlorite with potassium iodide gives potassium hypoiodite, ; KOI is the oxidising agent of the iodoform test, so an ,-unsaturated methyl ketone still gives iodoform with its C=C untouched.
(a) Acid-catalysed bromination goes through the enol: P = 2-bromocyclopentan-1-one. Loss of HBr gives the conjugated Q = cyclopent-2-en-1-one. Ozonolysis turns each alkene carbon into CHO: R = 2-oxopentanedial, .
(b) The group is triiodinated and cleaved: T = sodium cyclohexanecarboxylate; acid gives U = cyclohexanecarboxylic acid; soda lime replaces COOH by H: V = cyclohexane.
Iodoform shows , so A is pentan-2-one or 3-methylbutan-2-one. Pentan-2-one would give pent-2-ene and two aldehydes (ethanal and propanal). 3-Methylbutan-2-one gives 2-methylbut-2-ene, which splits into ethanal and the ketone propanone. This fits.
A = 3-methylbutan-2-one; B = 3-methylbutan-2-ol; C = 2-methylbut-2-ene; D = 3,3,5-trimethyl-1,2,4-trioxolane (the ozonide).
Aldol reaction
Two molecules of an aldehyde or ketone with at least one -hydrogen combine in the presence of dilute base to give a -hydroxy aldehyde or -hydroxy ketone, called an aldol (from an aldehyde) or a ketol (from a ketone). Ethanal gives acetaldol (3-hydroxybutanal). Aldehydes and ketones without -hydrogens cannot form the enolate and do not undergo this reaction.
- Enolate formation (slow). Base removes an -hydrogen.
- Addition (fast). The enolate carbon attacks the carbonyl carbon of a second molecule.
- Protonation. The alkoxide takes a proton from water, giving the aldol and regenerating .
Dehydration. Aldols lose water easily, giving ,-unsaturated carbonyl compounds. In acid, the protonated OH leaves as water. With strong bases such as alkoxide or hydroxide, an enolate forms first and then expels . An aldol followed by dehydration is called aldol condensation.
Crossed aldol and Claisen-Schmidt reactions
A crossed aldol between two different carbonyl compounds that both have -hydrogens gives a mixture of four products, two crossed and two self-condensed. For example, ethanal and propanal give 3-hydroxy-2-methylbutanal, 3-hydroxypentanal, 3-hydroxybutanal and 3-hydroxy-2-methylpentanal. On heating they lose water to give, in the same order, 2-methylbut-2-enal, pent-2-enal, but-2-enal and 2-methylpent-2-enal. A crossed aldol is synthetically useful only when one partner has no -hydrogen (such as methanal or benzaldehyde) and so cannot form an enolate. Propanone and methanal give 4-hydroxybutan-2-one.
The Claisen-Schmidt reaction is a crossed aldol condensation between an aromatic aldehyde and an aliphatic aldehyde or ketone that has -hydrogens, in dilute alkali. It gives an ,-unsaturated carbonyl compound conjugated with the ring.
Benzaldehyde and acetophenone in dilute alkali at 293 K give 1,3-diphenylprop-2-en-1-one (benzalacetophenone) as the major product. With two molecules of benzaldehyde, propanone condenses at both methyl groups and gives dibenzalacetone (1,5-diphenylpenta-1,4-dien-3-one).
Ketones give aldols less readily than aldehydes. With barium hydroxide, , as the base, propanone gives the ketol diacetone alcohol (4-hydroxy-4-methylpentan-2-one), which on heating loses water to give mesityl oxide (4-methylpent-3-en-2-one).
Both form enolates, and each enolate can attack either compound.
- Ethanal + ethanal: 3-hydroxybutanal → but-2-enal.
- Ketone + ketone: 2-(1-hydroxycyclopentyl)cyclopentan-1-one → 2-cyclopentylidenecyclopentan-1-one.
- Ketone enolate + ethanal: 2-(1-hydroxyethyl)cyclopentan-1-one → 2-ethylidenecyclopentan-1-one.
- Ethanal enolate + ketone: 2-(1-hydroxycyclopentyl)ethanal → 2-cyclopentylideneethanal.
- removes an -H from C-3, next to the C-2 carbonyl group: an enolate.
- C-3 attacks the C-7 carbonyl carbon; the ring C-3 to C-7 is five-membered.
- The alkoxide takes from water: 1-(2-hydroxy-2-methylcyclopentyl)ethan-1-one.
- Base removes the -H on the ring carbon carrying the acetyl group, and is expelled (dehydration).
The C-1 methyl enolate would have to close a seven-membered ring. Five- and six-membered rings have little strain and close easily, and as every step is reversible the stable enone accumulates: 1-(2-methylcyclopent-1-en-1-yl)ethan-1-one.
In an intramolecular aldol the new ring is almost always five- or six-membered. Every step is reversible in base, so when more than one enolate could close such a ring, the more stable product wins: a ketone enolate attacks an aldehyde group rather than the reverse, and between two ketone enolates the product usually comes from the more stable, more substituted enolate.
The enolate (C-2) of one butanal adds to the C=O of another, giving the aldol A; dehydration gives the conjugated enal . Excess /Ni reduces both the C=C and the C=O; reduces only the C=O (1,2-reduction) and leaves the C=C.
A = 2-ethyl-3-hydroxyhexanal; B = 2-ethylhex-2-enal; C = 2-ethylhexan-1-ol; D = 2-ethylhex-2-en-1-ol.
11. Cannizzaro Reaction
Aldehydes without -hydrogen (such as methanal, benzaldehyde and 2,2-dimethylpropanal) undergo self oxidation-reduction when heated with concentrated alkali. One molecule is oxidised to the carboxylate salt and the other is reduced to the alcohol. Aldehydes with -hydrogens give aldol reactions instead, because enolate formation is faster.
When the reaction is run in , the alcohol has no carbon-bound deuterium. The hydrogen therefore moves directly from one aldehyde molecule to the other, as a hydride ion. Hydroxide first adds to one aldehyde, and that anion then transfers hydride to the carbonyl carbon of a second aldehyde in the slow step.
Crossed Cannizzaro reaction. Two different aldehydes would give all possible products, but when one of them is methanal, only formate and the alcohol of the other aldehyde form. Methanal is the most reactive aldehyde, so it adds hydroxide first and then gives up its hydrogen as hydride to the less reactive aldehyde.
Pentaerythritol. Ethanal with excess methanal and base undergoes three aldol additions at its -carbon, giving . That aldehyde has no -hydrogen left, so a crossed Cannizzaro reaction with methanal reduces it to pentaerythritol, .
Intramolecular Cannizzaro reaction. A 1,2-dicarbonyl compound that has a CHO group and no -hydrogen (glyoxal, phenylglyoxal) can do the same inside one molecule: hydroxide adds to the CHO group, and hydride moves from that carbon to the other carbonyl carbon. Ethanedial (glyoxal) with concentrated alkali gives the glycolate (hydroxyethanoate) ion: .
Neither has -H: a crossed Cannizzaro reaction. Methanal, the more reactive, is oxidised and gives hydride to the other aldehyde.
(4-Chlorophenyl)methanol and sodium methanoate.
Base and an aldehyde: first look for an -hydrogen. With one, dilute alkali gives an aldol. With none (methanal, benzaldehyde, 2,2-dimethylpropanal), concentrated alkali gives the Cannizzaro products, an alcohol and a carboxylate salt; with methanal as a partner, methanal is the one oxidised.
12. Electrophilic Substitution in Aromatic Aldehydes and Ketones
The -CHO and -COR groups withdraw electrons from a benzene ring, so they are deactivating and meta-directing in electrophilic substitution. Benzaldehyde is nitrated at the meta position:
Trace : it catalyses enolisation, and the enol reacts with at the -carbon: X = 2-bromo-1-phenylpropan-1-one, .
Excess : one mole binds to every carbonyl oxygen, so the ketone can no longer enolise. Free polarises , which attacks the ring, and the complexed acyl group is strongly deactivating and meta-directing: Y = 1-(3-bromophenyl)propan-1-one.
Benzaldehyde is warmed with Tollens' reagent and, separately, with Fehling's solution. Which one reacts?
Name the products of benzaldehyde with concentrated NaOH.
Which reductions turn C=O into ?
What does propanone give with ?
Where does nitration put the nitro group in benzaldehyde?
13. Distinguishing Tests
| Test | Aldehydes | Ketones | Remarks |
|---|---|---|---|
| Tollens' reagent | Silver mirror | No reaction | Aliphatic and aromatic aldehydes; also HCOOH |
| Fehling's or Benedict's solution | Red-brown | No reaction | Aliphatic aldehydes only; benzaldehyde does not react |
| Schiff's reagent | Pink-magenta colour | No colour (generally) | Colour of decolourised dye restored |
| Iodoform test (/NaOH) | Only ethanal | Methyl ketones | Also alcohols and ethanol |
| Addition product (equilibrium lies to the right) | Equilibrium lies to the left for most ketones | Used to separate and purify aldehydes | |
| 2,4-DNP | Yellow-orange precipitate | Yellow-orange precipitate | Shows a C=O group; does not distinguish |
Iodoform needs - joined to C or H (methyl ketones and ethanal), or - joined to C or H (ethanol and alcohols that oxidise to methyl ketones). Ethanoic acid, its esters and its amide carry - joined to O or N and give no iodoform.
14. Uses of Aldehydes and Ketones
- Methanal: as formalin (about 40% solution) to preserve biological specimens; to make Bakelite (phenol-formaldehyde) and urea-formaldehyde resins.
- Ethanal: starting material for ethanoic acid, ethyl ethanoate, vinyl acetate, polymers and drugs. Paraldehyde is a sedative, and metaldehyde is slug bait.
- Benzaldehyde: in perfumes, flavourings and dye manufacture.
- Propanone and butanone: common industrial solvents.
- Odours and flavours: many aldehydes and ketones, such as butyraldehyde (butanal), vanillin, acetophenone and camphor, are known for their odours and flavours.
Practice Questions
Try each one before opening the answer.
Properties, reactivity and nucleophilic addition
- (a) 4-Oxocyclohexane-1-carboxylic acid is treated with (i) ethane-1,2-diol, ; (ii) 1 equivalent of ; (iii) dilute acid; (iv) . Give the final product. (b) And 4-acetylbenzaldehyde with 1 equivalent of ethane-1,2-diol/, then , then dilute acid?
Show answer
(a) 4-Hydroxycyclohexane-1-carboxylic acid. With the ketone protected, only deprotonates COOH (giving ); acid removes the acetal, and reduces the ketone, not the acid. (b) 4-(1-Hydroxyethyl)benzaldehyde: the more reactive CHO is protected.
- Arrange in increasing reactivity towards HCN: (a) 4-chlorobenzaldehyde, 1-phenylpropan-1-one, 3-nitrobenzaldehyde, 4-methoxybenzaldehyde; (b) butanal, 2,2-dichlorobutanal, but-2-enal.
Show answer
(a) 1-phenylpropan-1-one < 4-methoxy- < 4-chloro- < 3-nitrobenzaldehyde. (b) but-2-enal < butanal < 2,2-dichlorobutanal. Alkyl groups, conjugation, ring and donation lower on carbon; Cl and raise it.
- Give reasons: (a) adds to the C=O of propanal but not to the C=C of propene; (b) propanal reduces Tollens' reagent but propanone does not; (c) HCl gives no stable adduct with propanal; (d) propanone oxime is a stronger acid than hydroxylamine.
Show answer
(a) C=O is polar, and the added charge ends on oxygen; non-polar C=C attracts electrophiles. (b) The aldehyde C-H is easily oxidised to C-OH; a ketone would need a C-C bond broken. (c) The adduct, 1-chloropropan-1-ol, has Cl and OH on the same carbon; is a good leaving group, so it loses HCl at once and the equilibrium lies on the aldehyde side. (d) The oximate ion is stabilised by resonance through C=N ().
- (a) Which is protonated more easily on oxygen: 4-(dimethylamino)benzaldehyde or 4-nitrobenzaldehyde? (b) Why is cyclohepta-2,4,6-trien-1-one unusually basic for a ketone?
Show answer
(a) 4-(Dimethylamino)benzaldehyde: the N lone pair spreads the positive charge through the ring, while destabilises the cation. (b) Its conjugate acid is an aromatic six--electron (tropylium-type) ion.
- (a) Which has the most acidic H: butanone, 3-methylbut-1-ene, 1,3-diphenylpropane-1,3-dione or propanal? (b) Why is an -H of butanal acidic but a -H is not?
Show answer
(a) 1,3-Diphenylpropane-1,3-dione: its enolate spreads the charge over two oxygens. (b) Loss of an -H gives an enolate, whose negative charge is shared with the carbonyl oxygen by resonance. An anion on the -carbon is cut off from C=O by a saturated carbon, so it has no resonance and only a weak inductive pull.
- (a) Which give a C=N product with butanone: methanamine, N-methylmethanamine, N,N-dimethylmethanamine, semicarbazide? (b) Why is oxime formation fastest near pH 4.5? (c) Which two compounds condense to 2,3-dimethyl-5,6-dihydropyrazine?
Show answer
(a) Methanamine and semicarbazide: they have two N-H, so they can lose water and form C=N. (b) Acid helps water leave, but too much acid protonates the amine. (c) Ethane-1,2-diamine and butane-2,3-dione, forming two C=N bonds and losing two .
- (a) Give two Grignard reagent + ketone pairs that give 2-phenylbutan-2-ol. (b) What does butanone give with sodium ethynide and then dilute acid?
Show answer
(a) + 1-phenylethan-1-one; + butanone (or + 1-phenylpropan-1-one). (b) The acetylide adds to C=O: 3-methylpent-1-yn-3-ol.
- The cyanohydrin of pentan-3-one is (a) reduced by ; (b) boiled with dilute acid; (c) heated with conc. . Name each product.
Show answer
(a) 1-Amino-2-ethylbutan-2-ol (CN to ). (b) 2-Ethyl-2-hydroxybutanoic acid. (c) Dehydration and hydrolysis: 2-ethylbut-2-enoic acid, an ,-unsaturated acid.
Oxidation, tests and structure identification
- (a) What do Fehling's A and B contain? (b) Which give red with Fehling's solution: 2-methylpropanal, 3-hydroxybutan-2-one, 4-methylbenzaldehyde, pentan-3-one? (c) Which reagent oxidises hex-2-enal to hex-2-enoic acid without touching the C=C?
Show answer
(a) A: aqueous copper(II) sulphate; B: sodium potassium tartrate in NaOH. (b) 2-Methylpropanal and 3-hydroxybutan-2-one: aliphatic aldehydes and -hydroxy ketones reduce it, aromatic aldehydes and simple ketones do not. (c) Tollens' reagent.
- (a) PCC oxidises hexan-2-ol to Q, . Name Q and its products with /NaOH. (b) What does 1-(2-methylcyclopentyl)ethan-1-one give with NaOBr, then acid?
Show answer
(a) Q = hexan-2-one, a methyl ketone, which gives and sodium pentanoate. (b) The group is tribrominated and cleaved: and 2-methylcyclopentane-1-carboxylic acid (after acidifying its sodium salt).
- X, , gives 2,4-DNP and iodoform tests but not Tollens'. Hot gives , which forms an anhydride on heating. Identify X. Which monosubstituted benzene isomer of X with a C=O group gives neither Tollens' nor iodoform test?
Show answer
X = 1-(2-methylphenyl)ethan-1-one: its ortho side chains become phthalic acid, whose two adjacent COOH groups close a five-membered anhydride ring. The isomer is 1-phenylpropan-1-one, a ketone without .
- KI with NaOCl can replace /NaOH in the iodoform test. What does NaOCl do? Which give iodoform: 4-phenylbut-3-en-2-one, butan-2-ol, pentan-3-ol, methanol? What anion forms from the first?
Show answer
NaOCl oxidises to (KOI), which iodinates and oxidises . 4-Phenylbut-3-en-2-one and butan-2-ol react; the first gives 3-phenylprop-2-enoate, its C=C intact.
- (a) Which gives an iodoform-positive product after : butanal, butanone or methyl butanoate? (b) Propene with HBr, then aqueous KOH, then /NaOH gives what? (c) Give a test to tell 1-(4-ethylphenyl)ethan-1-one from 1-(4-methylphenyl)propan-1-one.
Show answer
(a) Butanone, which gives butan-2-ol. (b) , via 2-bromopropane and propan-2-ol. (c) Iodoform test: only the methyl ketone, 1-(4-ethylphenyl)ethan-1-one, gives yellow .
- Isomers P and Q (71.95% C, 12.08% H, rest O; vapour density 50) give 2,4-DNP derivatives but not Fehling's test. Only P gives iodoform. Clemmensen reduction gives 3-methylpentane from P and hexane from Q. Identify them.
Show answer
C : H : O = 71.95/12 : 12.08/1 : 15.97/16 = 6 : 12 : 1, and M = 2 × 50 = 100, so both are ketones. P = 3-methylpentan-2-one; Q = hexan-3-one.
- (a) Ketone A, , gives no iodoform, and Clemmensen reduction gives 2-methylhexane. , then hot conc. , then ozonolysis gives propanone and butanal. Identify A. (b) F, , forms a dioxime and gives Tollens' and iodoform tests; Wolff-Kishner reduction gives hexane. Identify F.
Show answer
(a) 2-Methylhexan-3-one: its alcohol dehydrates to 2-methylhex-2-ene, which splits into propanone and butanal. (b) 5-Oxohexanal, .
- A, , forms an oxime, decolourises bromine water and gives a silver mirror. Vigorous oxidation gives propanone and 3-methylhexanedioic acid. Identify A and its Tollens' product.
Show answer
A = 3,7-dimethyloct-6-enal: propanone marks a end, and the diacid holds the rest, one COOH from CHO. Tollens' gives 3,7-dimethyloct-6-enoic acid.
- Explain: (a) 2-methoxyprop-1-ene in dilute acid gives propanone and methanol; (b) oxan-2-ol, a cyclic hemiacetal, gives a silver mirror; (c) propan-2-ol gives a yellow precipitate with and NaOH but propan-1-ol does not.
Show answer
(a) adds to the carbon of the C=C, giving the oxocarbenium ion ; water adds, and the hemiacetal, 2-methoxypropan-2-ol, breaks into propanone and methanol. (b) It is in equilibrium with open-chain 5-hydroxypentanal, which Tollens' reagent oxidises. (c) Propan-2-ol, a alcohol, is oxidised to propanone, a methyl ketone, which gives ; propan-1-ol gives propanal, with no .
Aldol, Cannizzaro and multi-step sequences
- Cycloheptanone with , then acid, gives A; hot conc. gives alkene B; ozonolysis (Zn, ) gives C; hot NaOH turns C into D, . B with HBr gives E. Identify B to E.
Show answer
B = 1-methylcyclohept-1-ene; C = 7-oxooctanal; E = 1-bromo-1-methylcycloheptane. In C the ketone enolate attacks the more electrophilic CHO, closing a six-membered ring: D = 1-(cyclohex-1-en-1-yl)ethan-1-one.
- (a) Hexane-2,5-dione, from ozonolysis of 1,2-dimethylcyclobut-1-ene, gives which enone with hot NaOH? (b) Which gives 2-methylcyclopent-2-en-1-one with base: 4-oxohexanal, 5-oxohexanal or hexanedial?
Show answer
(a) 3-Methylcyclopent-2-en-1-one: the enolate (C-1) attacks C-5 and closes a five-membered ring; the enolate (C-3) could only close a three-membered ring. (b) 4-Oxohexanal: its C-5 enolate (the of the ethyl group) attacks the CHO carbon, C-1, and closes a five-membered ring with the ring C=O next to the carbon; loss of water gives the 2-methyl enone. Hexanedial also closes a five-membered ring but gives cyclopent-1-ene-1-carbaldehyde, and 5-oxohexanal closes a six-membered ring to give cyclohex-2-en-1-one.
- Give the final product: (a) 1-ethylcyclopent-1-ene, (i) (ii) Zn, , then hot NaOH; (b) cyclopentanone, sodium ethynide, then /dilute , then dehydration, then (i) (ii) Zn, .
Show answer
(a) Ozonolysis gives 5-oxoheptanal; the enolate at the ethyl CH2 attacks the CHO, closing a six-membered ring: 2-methylcyclohex-2-en-1-one. (b) Via 1-ethynylcyclopentan-1-ol and 1-(cyclopent-1-en-1-yl)ethan-1-one: 5,6-dioxoheptanal.
- 2,3-Dibromobutane with alcoholic KOH, then , gives A, . With /dilute , A gives B; B with /NaOH gives a yellow solid and salt C; C with soda lime gives gas D. Trimerised, A gives . Identify A to D and the trimer.
Show answer
A = but-2-yne; B = butanone; C = sodium propanoate; D = ethane; the trimer is hexamethylbenzene.
- (a) Give one reagent for: (i) alkyne to cis-alkene; (ii) ketone to alcohol, ester untouched; (iii) RCN to RCHO; (iv) RCOCl to RCHO; (v) C=O to in base; (vi) the same in acid. (b) Convert methylbenzene into 4-phenylbut-3-en-2-one in two steps.
Show answer
(a) (i) , Lindlar's catalyst; (ii) ; (iii) /HCl, then ; (iv) , Pd/; (v) , KOH; (vi) Zn(Hg), HCl. (b) , then (Etard reaction), gives benzaldehyde; propanone and dilute NaOH then give 4-phenylbut-3-en-2-one.
- (a) Name from propanone and two equivalents of benzaldehyde in dilute NaOH. (b) Which aldehyde and ketone give 3-(4-methoxyphenyl)-1-phenylprop-2-en-1-one in dilute NaOH? (c) Cyclopentanone and benzaldehyde (1:1, base), then , then acid and heat give a conjugated diene. Name it.
Show answer
(a) 1,5-Diphenylpenta-1,4-dien-3-one (dibenzalacetone). (b) 4-Methoxybenzaldehyde and 1-phenylethan-1-one. (c) Via 2-benzylidenecyclopentan-1-ol: 3-benzylidenecyclopent-1-ene, the ring C=C taking locants 1,2.
- (a) Which aldols form from benzaldehyde and propanal in dilute NaOH? (b) Name the aldol condensation product of cycloheptanone. (c) 2,2-Dimethylpropanal has no -H, yet with propanal in dilute NaOH it gives . Explain and name it. (d) Name from benzaldehyde and 1-phenylpropan-1-one in dilute NaOH.
Show answer
(a) 3-Hydroxy-2-methyl-3-phenylpropanal and 3-hydroxy-2-methylpentanal. (b) 2-Cycloheptylidenecycloheptan-1-one. (c) A crossed aldol: the enolate of propanal attacks the CHO of 2,2-dimethylpropanal, and dehydration gives 2,4,4-trimethylpent-2-enal. (d) A Claisen-Schmidt condensation: 2-methyl-1,3-diphenylprop-2-en-1-one.
- (a) Isomers A and B, , reduce Tollens' reagent. Concentrated NaOH turns A into 2-ethyl-2-methylbutan-1-ol and a salt; dilute NaOH turns B into 3-hydroxy-2-pentylnonanal. Identify A and B. (b) Propanal with NaOH and heat gives D, ; excess /Ni gives E (M = 102). Identify D and E.
Show answer
(a) A = 2-ethyl-2-methylbutanal (no -H: Cannizzaro); B = heptanal (aldol). (b) D = 2-methylpent-2-enal; E = 2-methylpentan-1-ol, M = 72 + 14 + 16 = 102.
- (a) What is from ethanedial, hot conc. NaOH, then acid? (b) Products of furan-2-carbaldehyde, methanal and conc. KOH? (c) What does methanal give with 50% KOH? (d) What mass of silver does 0.360 g of butanal give with excess Tollens' reagent? (C = 12, H = 1, O = 16, Ag = 108)
Show answer
(a) Hydroxyethanoic acid (intramolecular Cannizzaro). (b) Furan-2-ylmethanol and potassium methanoate. (c) Methanol and potassium methanoate. (d) RCHO gives 2 Ag: 0.360/72 = 0.00500 mol butanal, so Ag = 0.0100 × 108 = 1.08 g.
Common Mistakes to Avoid
- Saying aldehydes and ketones hydrogen bond with each other. They only accept H-bonds from water or alcohols.
- Putting ketones above aldehydes in reactivity. The order is HCHO > RCHO > RCOR, and aromatic compounds are below aliphatic ones.
- Using Fehling's solution to detect benzaldehyde. Only Tollens' reagent oxidises aromatic aldehydes.
- Expecting iodoform from every ketone. Only methyl ketones and ethanal (- joined to C or H) and - alcohols give it; ethanoic acid, its esters and its amide do not. Methanol and pentan-3-one do not; ethanal and ethanol do.
- Writing Cannizzaro for aldehydes with -H. Ethanal gives an aldol; Cannizzaro needs no -H.
- Using Clemmensen on acid-sensitive compounds or Wolff-Kishner on base-sensitive ones. Choose by the rest of the molecule.
- Forgetting that is mild. It reduces aldehydes and ketones but not esters or acids; reduces all of them.
- Running imine formation in strong acid. The amine is protonated and stops being a nucleophile; the best pH is mildly acidic.
- Calling the self-aldol of propanone "Claisen-Schmidt". Claisen-Schmidt is a crossed aldol of an aromatic aldehyde.
Frequently Asked Questions
Why do aldehydes and ketones have lower boiling points than alcohols?
Aldehydes and ketones are held together by dipole-dipole attraction between polar C=O groups, but they have no O-H bond and cannot hydrogen bond with each other. Alcohols of similar molar mass form hydrogen bonds, which are stronger, so alcohols boil higher. Aldehydes and ketones still boil higher than alkanes and ethers.
Why are aldehydes more reactive than ketones towards nucleophilic addition?
Two reasons. Electronically, a ketone has two electron-donating alkyl groups that reduce the positive charge on the carbonyl carbon. Sterically, the hydrogen of an aldehyde is much smaller than an alkyl group, so nucleophiles reach the aldehyde carbon more easily. Methanal is the most reactive of all.
What is the difference between Tollens' and Fehling's tests?
Both detect aldehydes by oxidising them. Tollens' reagent, ammoniacal silver nitrate, gives a silver mirror with aliphatic and aromatic aldehydes. Fehling's solution, alkaline copper(II) tartrate, gives a red Cu2O precipitate only with aliphatic aldehydes. Ketones give neither test.
Which compounds give the iodoform test?
Compounds containing a CH3CO group, meaning methyl ketones and ethanal, and alcohols that can be oxidised to them, meaning ethanol and CH3CH(OH)R secondary alcohols. With iodine and sodium hydroxide they give a yellow precipitate of iodoform, CHI3. Methanol, methanal and ketones without a methyl group next to C=O do not.
What is the difference between aldol and Cannizzaro reactions?
The aldol reaction needs an alpha hydrogen: dilute base forms an enolate that adds to a second carbonyl molecule, giving a beta-hydroxy aldehyde or ketone. The Cannizzaro reaction happens only in aldehydes without alpha hydrogen: concentrated alkali makes one molecule transfer hydride to another, giving an alcohol and a carboxylate salt.
When should Clemmensen or Wolff-Kishner reduction be used?
Both convert C=O into CH2. Clemmensen reduction uses zinc amalgam and concentrated HCl, so it suits compounds stable to acid but sensitive to base. Wolff-Kishner reduction uses hydrazine and KOH at high temperature, so it suits compounds stable to base but sensitive to acid.
Which reactions of aldehydes and ketones are most important for JEE Main and JEE Advanced?
JEE focuses on mechanisms and selectivity: nucleophilic addition order, cyanohydrin and Grignard products, acetals as protecting groups, imine formation and its pH dependence, haloform, aldol (including intramolecular and crossed), Cannizzaro and crossed Cannizzaro, and structure-identification problems using Tollens', iodoform and 2,4-DNP tests.
What should NEET students focus on in reactions of aldehydes and ketones?
NEET follows NCERT: reactivity order, addition of HCN, NaHSO3, Grignard reagents, alcohols and ammonia derivatives, reduction by NaBH4, Clemmensen and Wolff-Kishner, oxidation tests (Tollens', Fehling's), haloform, aldol, cross aldol, Cannizzaro, electrophilic substitution of benzaldehyde, and uses.