Carboxylic Acid Derivatives
Carboxylic acid derivatives are compounds in which the -OH of the acid is replaced by Z = -Cl (acid chlorides), -OCOR (anhydrides), -OR' (esters) or (amides). All of them react by nucleophilic acyl substitution, and their reactivity falls in the order acid chloride > anhydride > ester > amide, which also decides which derivative can be made from which. JEE Main questions on these derivatives have asked for their order of reactivity and about the hydrolysis of amides. JEE Advanced questions have asked about the reduction of esters and the saponification of a fat.
- ★ Must learn Reactivity: RCOCl > > RCOOR' >
- ★ Must learn (amide from an acid chloride)
- (an anhydride transfers one acyl group)
- ★ Must learn (saponification, irreversible)
- (transesterification)
- ★ Must learn (hydrolysis of an amide)
- (3° alcohol)
- ★ Must learn (an ester gives two alcohols)
- (a fat gives soap and glycerol)
1. What are Carboxylic Acid Derivatives?
There are four carboxylic acid derivatives, generally represented as , where Z is a halogen (usually Cl), -OCOR', -OR' or (or -NHR', ). All of them contain the acyl group and are readily converted back into the acid by hydrolysis.
- Z = halogen (usually Cl): acid chlorides (acyl chlorides).
- Z = -OR': esters.
- Z = -OCOR': carboxylic acid anhydrides.
- Z = : amides; when Z is -NHR' or , they are N-substituted amides.
Carboxylic acid derivatives are prepared from carboxylic acids; those preparation methods appear under the chemical reactions of carboxylic acids. On hydrolysis each derivative gives the acid back. The other product shows what Z was, as the next example shows.
Hydrolysis replaces Z in by -OH. The second product is H-Z (or its ion), so it shows what Z was. Here R is every time.
A: HCl forms, so Z = Cl. A is 2-methylpropanoyl chloride, , an acid chloride.
B: a second molecule of the same acid forms, so Z = -OCOR. B is 2-methylpropanoic anhydride, , an acid anhydride.
C: methanol forms, so Z = . C is methyl 2-methylpropanoate, , an ester.
D: ammonia forms, and the acid turns it into , so Z = . D is 2-methylpropanamide, , an amide.
2. Relative Reactivity of Acid Derivatives
Reactivity towards nucleophilic acyl substitution follows the order RCOCl > > RCOOR' > . Substitution takes place in two steps: (a) the nucleophile adds to the electron-deficient carbonyl carbon, forming a tetrahedral intermediate, and (b) the intermediate eliminates the leaving group, regenerating the C=O. Step (a) is favoured by electron withdrawal and hindered by +I groups or bulky groups; step (b) depends on the leaving group. Two facts explain the order:
- Basicity of the leaving group: the weaker the base, the better it leaves. Basicity follows , so reactivity runs the other way, and , the weakest base, makes acid chlorides the most reactive.
- Resonance: the lone pair on the atom joined to the carbonyl carbon is delocalised into C=O, giving that bond partial double-bond character and stabilising the derivative. The more stabilisation, the lower the reactivity. Stabilisation is least for acid chlorides, because the large chlorine 3p orbital overlaps poorly with carbon's 2p orbital and chlorine's strong -I effect withdraws electrons; it is greatest for amides, where nitrogen donates strongly.
Alkyl halides are much less reactive than acyl halides in nucleophilic substitution. Attack on the tetrahedral carbon of RX goes through a hindered transition state, and a bond must be partly broken to let the nucleophile attach. In , the nucleophile attacks the flat carbonyl carbon through a relatively unhindered transition state, and the substitution happens in two steps: the first is like addition to a carbonyl compound, and the second is loss of chloride.
(a) Ammonia adds to the carbonyl carbon of pentanoyl chloride (step a). The tetrahedral intermediate carries and . The C=O bond then re-forms, and leaves (step b). A second takes a proton from nitrogen. This gives pentanamide and , which pairs with . That is why two moles of ammonia are used.
(b) Acid protonates the carbonyl oxygen of methyl butanoate. This makes the carbonyl carbon more electrophilic. Water adds to it and gives a tetrahedral intermediate. A proton then moves to the oxygen. Methanol leaves, and the C=O bond re-forms. Loss of gives butanoic acid and frees the catalyst. Every step is reversible: these are the steps of esterification, run backwards.
(a) ethyl ethanoate,
(b) ethyl chloroethanoate,
(c) ethyl dichloroethanoate,
(d) ethyl 2-methylpropanoate,
Answer: (c). Hydroxide attacks the carbonyl carbon in the first step. A group that withdraws electrons makes this carbon more positive and speeds the attack. Each Cl atom withdraws electrons by its -I effect, so two Cl atoms help more than one. The two methyl groups of (d) release electrons (+I) and crowd the carbon, so (d) reacts slowest. The order is (d) < (a) < (b) < (c).
The pKa ladder.
Rank the derivatives by the of the leaving group's conjugate acid: HCl (-7), RCOOH (4.8), R'OH (16), (38). The lower the pKa, the faster the reaction, and a derivative can be made only from one above it. Order: CAEA, "Cats Always Eat Apples" (Chloride, Anhydride, Ester, Amide).
Because conversions only run downhill, going uphill needs a detour through the acid:
3. Acyl Chlorides
Preparation
Acid chlorides are prepared from carboxylic acids with , or , often with pyridine to remove HCl.
Acylation reactions
Acyl chlorides are the most reactive acid derivatives, so they are often chosen as the starting material for preparing any other acid derivative. The acyl group is transferred to the nucleophile, and HCl (or a chloride salt) is released.
Acetylation of salicylic acid with acetyl chloride gives acetylsalicylic acid (aspirin): the phenolic -OH becomes .
Friedel-Crafts acylation
With anhydrous , an acyl chloride acylates benzene and gives an aromatic ketone. The Preparation of Aromatic Aldehydes and Ketones page teaches this Friedel-Crafts acylation.
Reaction with alkenes
With a Lewis acid catalyst, acetyl chloride adds to an alkene and gives a chloro ketone.
Reduction
With , hydride first gives the aldehyde, which is reduced further to the primary alcohol. Hydrogen over palladium poisoned with stops at the aldehyde (Rosenmund reduction). The General Methods of Preparation of Aliphatic Aldehydes and Ketones page teaches it.
Reactions with KCN, silver nitrate and diazomethane
Aliphatic acid chlorides are readily decomposed by water, so an aqueous solution gives a white precipitate of AgCl with .
These notes leave out the reactions of acyl chlorides with KCN and with diazomethane.
Water hydrolyses an acyl chloride at once. Butanoyl chloride gives butanoic acid and HCl. The chloride ions meet and give a white precipitate of AgCl.
1-Chlorobutane gives no precipitate at once. Water replaces its chlorine only very slowly, because attack at its tetrahedral carbon is hindered (Solved Example 2). So a white precipitate that appears at once shows an acyl chloride.
(A) 3-methylbutanal
(B) 3-methylbutan-1-ol
(C) 3-methylbutanoic acid
(D) 2-methylbutan-1-ol
Answer: (B). Hydride first gives the aldehyde. does not stop there, so the aldehyde is reduced on to the primary alcohol. The carbon chain does not change, so (D) is wrong.
Water gives two acids from each molecule of A: the carboxylic acid and HCl. So one mole of A uses two moles of NaOH.
Moles of NaOH = mol. So A is 0.0200 mol, and its molar mass is .
The -COCl group has mass . So R has mass , which is . A = propanoyl chloride, .
reduces A to the primary alcohol: B = propan-1-ol, . A then acylates B: C = propyl propanoate, .
What does an acyl chloride give with ?
Why does acetyl chloride fume in moist air?
What does an acyl chloride give with excess ammonia?
4. Acid Anhydrides
Preparation
Acid anhydrides are considered to be derived from two molecules of carboxylic acid by removal of one molecule of water.
In the second reaction the carboxylate ion acts as the nucleophile at the acyl carbon of the acid chloride. Cyclic anhydrides form simply by heating the dicarboxylic acid when a five- or six-membered ring results: succinic acid (300 °C) gives succinic anhydride and phthalic acid (230 °C) gives phthalic anhydride.
Reactions
Anhydrides are good acylating agents; their reactions are less vigorous than those of acyl chlorides. They are used to prepare esters and amides, and they are hydrolysed back to acids.
Succinic anhydride with ammonia gives ammonium succinamate, which acid converts into succinamic acid, a molecule that is both an amide and an acid.
(A)
(B)
(C)
(D)
Answer: (B). The propanoate ion attacks the carbonyl carbon of an acid chloride, and chloride leaves. The anhydride keeps the propanoyl group of the salt and gains the acyl group of the chloride. An ethanoyl group is needed, so X is ethanoyl chloride. (C) would give propanoic anhydride. (A) and (D) are acids with no -COCl group; they would only exchange a proton with the propanoate ion.
(C) has two -COOH groups, and on heating it loses water to give (A). So (A) is a cyclic anhydride. A ring of five or six atoms closes easily in this way.
Two dicarboxylic acids have the formula : butanedioic acid and methylpropanedioic acid. Only butanedioic acid can close a five-membered ring. (Methylpropanedioic acid would need a four-membered ring.)
C = butanedioic acid (succinic acid), . A = succinic anhydride.
Methanol opens the ring. One acyl group becomes a methyl ester, and the other becomes -COOH in the same molecule. So a single product forms, and it is both an ester and an acid.
B = 4-methoxy-4-oxobutanoic acid, .
5. Esters
Preparation
Esters are derivatives in which the -OH of the carboxyl group is replaced by -OR, where R may be an alkyl or aryl group.
Diazomethane in ether turns an acid into its methyl ester.
Many simple esters have pleasant, fruity smells. Esters of benzoic acid are used in perfumery.
A carboxylic acid also adds to 2-methylpropene with an acid catalyst and gives a tert-butyl ester.
Hydrolysis of esters
Acid-catalysed esterification is reversible. Following the esterification mechanism backwards gives the mechanism of acid-catalysed ester hydrolysis.
Base-promoted hydrolysis (saponification). Esters are also hydrolysed by base. The reaction is called saponification because most soaps are made this way. Refluxing an ester with aqueous NaOH gives an alcohol and the sodium salt of the acid.
Saponification is essentially irreversible, because the carboxylate ion is inert towards nucleophilic substitution.
Saponification equivalent: if an ester is hydrolysed with a known excess of base, the amount of base used up can be measured. It gives the saponification equivalent (equivalent weight) of the ester, the ester counterpart of the neutralisation equivalent of an acid. For an ester with one -COOR' group it equals the molar mass.
Catalytic acid; every step is an equilibrium.
Reversible: the reverse is Fischer esterification. Products RCOOH + R'OH.
One mole of base is used up.
Irreversible: the final proton transfer gives , which alcohol cannot attack.
Fats and soaps. Higher aliphatic carboxylic acids, with 12 to 18 carbon atoms, are called fatty acids. Natural fats and oils are esters of fatty acids with glycerol (propane-1,2,3-triol). Each glycerol carries three acyl groups, so a fat is a glyceryl triester.
Boiling a fat with aqueous NaOH saponifies it. This gives glycerol and the sodium salts of the fatty acids. These salts are soaps.
Hard water contains calcium and magnesium ions. They turn a sodium soap into an insoluble calcium or magnesium soap, which separates as scum. In soft water, soap cleans well. Each soap anion has a long hydrocarbon tail and an ionic head. The tails dissolve in grease, and the heads stay in the water. The grease is held in tiny clusters (micelles) and washed away.
Mechanistic pathways of ester hydrolysis
In most esters, hydrolysis breaks the bond between the acyl carbon and the oxygen of -OR' (acyl-oxygen cleavage). This is true in acid and in base.
- In acid: the ester is protonated on carbonyl oxygen, water attacks in the slow step, and ethanol is lost from the tetrahedral intermediate (ethyl acetate + ).
- In base: hydroxide adds to the carbonyl carbon, alkoxide leaves, and proton exchange gives carboxylate + alcohol (saponification).
Esters of tertiary alcohols can instead break the alkyl-oxygen bond in acid. tert-Butyl acetate gives the tert-butyl cation, which water captures.
Transesterification and ammonolysis
Esters can also be prepared by transesterification, where one alcohol displaces another from an ester. The mechanism is similar to esterification.
Transesterification is an equilibrium reaction. To shift it to the right, a large excess of the alcohol whose ester is wanted is used, or one product is removed from the reaction mixture. Esters also react with ammonia or amines (ammonolysis) to give amides.
Reduction of esters
Both catalytic hydrogenation and chemical reduction give two alcohols. reduces both groups of a keto ester:
likewise reduces phthalic anhydride to benzene-1,2-dimethanol.
Diisobutylaluminium hydride (DIBAL-H), used cold, reduces an ester only as far as the aldehyde. The General Methods of Preparation of Aliphatic Aldehydes and Ketones page teaches this reduction.
A lactone is a cyclic ester. opens its ring and gives a diol.
Reaction with Grignard reagents
The reaction of an ester with a Grignard reagent is a good method for preparing 3° alcohols. A ketone forms first, but ketones react readily with Grignard reagents, so the final product is a tertiary alcohol.
Saponification gives ethanoate, so E is an ethanoate ester and F is its alcohol part. F has the formula .
Hot turns each carbon side chain of a benzene ring into -COOH. F gives two -COOH groups para to each other, so it has two side chains in para positions. Its eight carbons leave one carbon for each chain. The O atom cannot sit on the ring, because the product has no -OH there. So the chains are and .
F = (4-methylphenyl)methanol, (para). E = (4-methylphenyl)methyl ethanoate,
A neutralisation equivalent of 60 fits ethanoic acid, (molar mass 60). The alcohol is then .
Four alcohols have this formula: butan-1-ol, butan-2-ol, 2-methylpropan-1-ol and 2-methylpropan-2-ol. Only butan-2-ol, , has a carbon with four different groups.
The ester is butan-2-yl ethanoate (sec-butyl acetate), .
Soda lime replaces -COONa by H. Only sodium benzoate gives benzene, so (A) and (C) are both benzoic acid, .
(B) is oxidised to benzoic acid with no change in carbon count. So (B) is a primary alcohol, phenylmethanol (benzyl alcohol), .
The ester is benzyl benzoate, . Check: .
(a)
(b)
(c)
(d)
Answer: (a). This is transesterification. Propan-1-ol replaces the ethoxy group, and the ethanoyl group stays. The large excess of propan-1-ol pushes the equilibrium to the right. (b) and (d) would need a new acyl group, which nothing here supplies. (c) would need water, which is not added.
Claisen condensation
An ester with -hydrogens condenses with itself when treated with sodium ethoxide. The product is a -keto ester: ethyl acetate gives ethyl acetoacetate. This is the Claisen condensation, and its ring-closing form is the Dieckmann condensation. The Named Reactions and Rearrangements of Aldehydes and Ketones page explains both.
Acyloin condensation and reaction of keto esters with ammonia
These notes leave out the acyloin condensation and the reaction of -keto esters with ammonia.
What does ethyl acetate give with excess , then ?
What does a fat give when boiled with aqueous NaOH?
6. Amides
Preparation
In the laboratory, amides are prepared by the reaction of ammonia with acid chlorides or acid anhydrides. Primary and secondary amines react in the same way; excess ammonia or amine neutralises the HCl formed.
The third route is ammonolysis of an ester, and the last is partial hydrolysis of a nitrile under controlled conditions.
Phthalic acid and ammonia give phthalamide on heating, and phthalimide, a cyclic imide, on strong heating. The Properties of Carboxylic Acids page shows the steps.
Physical properties
All amides except formamide are crystalline solids at room temperature. They have relatively high melting and boiling points because amide molecules are associated by intermolecular hydrogen bonds. The lone pair on nitrogen is delocalised into the carbonyl group, giving nitrogen a partial positive charge; this makes the N-H hydrogens better hydrogen-bond donors, increasing hydrogen bonding and raising the melting and boiling points above those of other acid derivatives.
Basic and acidic character
Amides are very feebly basic, because the lone pair on nitrogen is involved in resonance with the carbonyl group. They form unstable salts with strong inorganic acids, such as , in which the proton is held mainly on oxygen.
Hydrolysis, reduction and dehydration
Amides are hydrolysed when heated with aqueous acid or aqueous base.
A cyclic amide (a lactam) opens in the same way. Hot aqueous NaOH breaks the C-N bond of the ring, and acid then gives the amino acid.
reduces an amide to an amine. The Preparation of Amines page teaches this reduction. Sodium borohydride does not reduce an amide.
When heated with , amides are dehydrated to nitriles (cyanides). or also convert amides into nitriles.
With nitrous acid, amides lose nitrogen and give the carboxylic acid; the electrophile is , formed from .
(A) and
(B) and gas
(C) and
(D)
Answer: (A). Hot dilute acid hydrolyses the amide to butanoic acid and ammonia. The acid turns the ammonia into at once, so no ammonia gas escapes, and (B) is wrong. Butanoic acid is a weak acid, so in sulphuric acid it stays as RCOOH, not as the ion in (D). A nitrile (C) needs a dehydrating agent such as .
Soda lime replaces -COONa by H. Cyclohexane forms, so (C) is cyclohexanecarboxylic acid, .
(A) is an amide of (C). Replacing the -OH of (C) by gives exactly . So (A) is cyclohexanecarboxamide, , and the gas (B) is ammonia.
removes water from a primary amide and gives a nitrile. (E) is cyclohexanecarbonitrile, .
A = cyclohexanecarboxamide; B = ; C = cyclohexanecarboxylic acid; D = cyclohexane; E = cyclohexanecarbonitrile.
Hofmann bromamide rearrangement
An amide with no substituent on nitrogen reacts with in NaOH solution. It gives a primary amine with one carbon atom less. The Preparation of Amines page teaches this Hofmann bromamide reaction.
Hofmann hacks one carbon.
( C) → ( C). The Preparation of Amines page explains why.
7. Chapter Summary
Which derivative is the usual starting point for making the others, and why?
What does an anhydride give with an alcohol?
Which reagent dehydrates an amide to a nitrile?
8. Solved Examples: Exam Practice
(A) sodium
(B) dilute acidic permanganate
(C) 2,4-dinitrophenylhydrazine
(D) sodium ethoxide
Formic acid contains an aldehyde-like H-C=O unit and is oxidised to , decolourising acidified ; acetic acid is not oxidised. Both acids react with Na and sodium ethoxide, and neither forms a 2,4-DNP derivative. Answer: (B)
(A)
(B)
(C)
(D)
Answer: (A). Chloride is the weakest base of the four leaving groups and chlorine donates least into C=O, so acetyl chloride is hydrolysed instantly; the amide needs prolonged boiling.
(A) acetone
(B) 2-methylpropan-2-ol
(C) propan-2-ol
(D) butan-2-ol
Answer: (B). The first replaces to give acetone, which is more reactive than the ester and adds a second methyl group: . Ethanol is the by-product.
The fat is a triester, so each mole uses 3 mol NaOH. The products are sodium hexadecanoate (sodium palmitate), which is a soap, and glycerol (propane-1,2,3-triol).
Moles of NaOH = mol. For one -COOR group, moles of ester = 0.0100 mol, so the saponification equivalent (molar mass) is .
An ester with molar mass 88 has : . Possible structures: ethyl acetate, , or methyl propanoate, (also propyl or isopropyl formate).
- Complete: + →Answer: + HCl
- 4-Methylbenzoyl chloride is shaken with excess aqueous NaOH, and the solution is then acidified. What forms?Answer: 4-methylbenzoic acid (its sodium salt forms first, and the acid frees the carboxylic acid)
- Acetic anhydride + 2 →Answer: acetamide + ammonium acetate
- Ethyl benzoate is boiled with NaOH solution. Give the products.Answer: sodium benzoate and ethanol
- Acetamide is heated with . Name the product.Answer: ethanenitrile (acetonitrile),
- Pentanamide is boiled with aqueous NaOH. Name the gas given off and the salt left in solution.Answer: ammonia; sodium pentanoate
- Methyl propanoate with excess , then dilute acid, gives?Answer: 3-ethylpentan-3-ol, (and methanol)
Common Mistakes to Avoid
- Reversing the reactivity order. It is acid chloride > anhydride > ester > amide; an amide cannot be converted directly into an acid chloride or ester by simple substitution.
- Saying that leaves easily "because chlorine is electronegative" only. The key reasons are that is a very weak base and that Cl donates poorly into C=O.
- Using to make an aldehyde from an acid chloride. It goes on to the alcohol. Rosenmund reduction (, Pd/) stops at the aldehyde. The General Methods of Preparation of Aliphatic Aldehydes and Ketones page explains it.
- Calling saponification reversible. The carboxylate ion formed does not react with alcohol, so it is irreversible; acid hydrolysis is reversible.
- Counting one mole of Grignard reagent for an ester. Two moles add, giving a 3° alcohol with two identical groups.
- Mixing an ethyl ester with sodium methoxide, or with methanol and acid, and expecting it to stay an ethyl ester. The alkoxy group is exchanged (transesterification), and the methyl ester forms.
- Forgetting that only one acyl group of an anhydride is transferred; the other becomes the carboxylic acid or its salt.
- Keeping the carbon count in the Hofmann reaction. The amine has one carbon fewer than the amide, as the Preparation of Amines page explains.
- Using one mole of NaOH per mole of a fat. A fat is a triester of glycerol, so its saponification uses three moles of NaOH.
Frequently Asked Questions
Why are acid chlorides more reactive than esters and amides?
Chloride is a very weak base and therefore an excellent leaving group, and chlorine's lone pairs overlap poorly with the carbonyl carbon, so acid chlorides get little resonance stabilisation. Esters and amides have better-donating oxygen and nitrogen atoms and much poorer leaving groups, so they react more slowly.
What is nucleophilic acyl substitution?
It is the reaction type of all acid derivatives. A nucleophile first adds to the carbonyl carbon to form a tetrahedral intermediate, and then the leaving group is expelled as the carbonyl bond re-forms. The net result is replacement of the leaving group by the nucleophile.
Why is saponification irreversible but acid hydrolysis of esters reversible?
In saponification the acid formed is immediately deprotonated to a carboxylate ion, which is negatively charged and not attacked by the alcohol. In acid hydrolysis every step is an equilibrium, and the reverse reaction is simply Fischer esterification.
What is the difference between Claisen and Dieckmann condensation?
This is beyond the 2026 syllabus (JEE Main, JEE Advanced and NEET). Both join an ester enolate to an ester carbonyl to give a beta-keto ester. The Claisen condensation is intermolecular, such as two ethyl acetate molecules giving ethyl acetoacetate. The Dieckmann condensation is intramolecular and forms five- or six-membered cyclic beta-keto esters from diesters. The Named Reactions and Rearrangements of Aldehydes and Ketones page explains both.
How does the Hofmann bromamide reaction reduce the carbon chain?
Bromine and NaOH remove the carbonyl carbon of the amide as carbonate. So the amine has one carbon fewer than the amide. The Preparation of Amines page teaches the steps of this Hofmann bromamide reaction.
Why are amides so weakly basic compared with amines?
In an amide the nitrogen lone pair is delocalised into the carbonyl group by resonance, so it is not free to accept a proton. Amines have a localised lone pair. Amides therefore form only unstable salts with strong acids.
Which acid derivative reactions are important for JEE?
JEE Main questions on acid derivatives have asked for the order of reactivity towards hydrolysis, and about the hydrolysis of amides. JEE Advanced questions have asked about the reduction of esters, and about the saponification of a fat. Several of these come inside multi-step problems. Also learn esters with Grignard reagents and the dehydration of amides.
What should NEET students focus on in acid derivatives?
For NEET, learn how each derivative is made from the acid and hydrolysed back to it. Learn saponification of esters and fats, the reduction of esters with LiAlH4, and the dehydration of amides with P2O5.