General Methods of Preparation of Aliphatic Aldehydes & Ketones
ChemistryAldehydes And Ketones
For JEE aspirants
The general methods of preparation of aliphatic aldehydes and ketones start from functional groups you already know: alcohols, acyl chlorides, esters, nitriles, alkenes, alkynes and gem-dihalides. The central idea is control. Oxidation or reduction must stop exactly at the carbonyl level, not one step short or one step beyond. This page covers these methods, a topic in the JEE Main, JEE Advanced and NEET syllabuses, and the reagents that make each reaction stop there (PCC, DIBAL-H, poisoned palladium, dialkylcadmium). Aromatic methods such as the Etard and Gattermann-Koch reactions are on the Preparation of Aromatic Aldehydes and Ketones page.
On this page1Big picture2From alcohols3Partial reduction4Organometallic reagents5Alkenes and alkynes6gem-Dihalides and calcium salts7Choosing a method8Practice
Key reactions: quick reference
★ Must learn1° alcohol, PCC
RCH2OHPCCCH2Cl2RCHO
2° alcohol, dichromate
RCH(OH)R′K2Cr2O7, H+RCOR′
Dehydrogenation
RCH2OHCu (573 K) or AgRCHO+H2
★ Must learnRosenmund reduction
RCOCl+H2Pd/BaSO4RCHO+HCl
★ Must learnStephen reduction
RC≡N(i) SnCl2, HCl(ii) H3O+RCHO
★ Must learnDIBAL-H
RCOOR′ or RC≡N(i) DIBAL-H, −78∘C(ii) H2ORCHO
Nitrile + Grignard
RC≡N(i) R’MgBr(ii) H3O+RCOR′
★ Must learnDialkylcadmium
2R′COCl+R2Cd→2R′COR+CdCl2
Ozonolysis
R2C=CHR′(i) O3(ii) Zn, H2OR2CO+R′CHO
Hydration of ethyne
HC≡CH+H2OHgSO4, H2SO4333 KCH3CHO
1. The Big Picture
An aldehyde or ketone sits at a middle oxidation level: above an alcohol, below a carboxylic acid. Most methods on this page belong to one of four families.
Controlled oxidation of alcohols, or their dehydrogenation over copper or silver.
Controlled reduction of acid derivatives (acyl chlorides, esters, nitriles), stopping before the alcohol.
Carbon-carbon bond formation with organometallic reagents (Grignard, dialkylcadmium) to make ketones.
Addition or cleavage of multiple bonds: hydration of alkynes, ozonolysis of alkenes.
Two methods fit none of these families. Hydrolysis of a gem-dihalide replaces both halogens by -OH groups, and the gem-diol then loses water. Dry distillation of calcium salts (beyond the JEE Main and NEET syllabus) turns two carboxylate groups into one carbonyl compound and calcium carbonate.
Figure 1: Eight starting points for the preparation of aldehydes and ketones: alcohols, acyl chlorides, esters, nitriles, alkenes, alkynes, gem-dihalides and calcium salts of carboxylic acids.
2. From Alcohols
Oxidation of primary alcohols to aldehydes
A primary alcohol is oxidised first to an aldehyde and then to a carboxylic acid:
RCH2OH[O]RCHO[O]RCOOH
The aldehyde is only a halfway stage, and ordinary oxidants such as acidified K2Cr2O7 or KMnO4 carry it on to the acid. To stop at the aldehyde, use pyridinium chlorochromate (PCC), C5H5NH+CrO3Cl−, in dichloromethane:
RCH2OHC5H5NH+CrO3Cl−(PCC)CH2Cl2RCHO
PCC works in the absence of water. Chromium(VI) oxidises an aldehyde to an acid through its hydrate, RCH(OH)2, and without water that hydrate cannot form, so oxidation stops. With acidified dichromate, a low-boiling aldehyde such as ethanal can also be saved by distilling it out as soon as it forms.
PCC leaves a C=C bond untouched, so an unsaturated primary alcohol gives an unsaturated aldehyde. Prop-2-en-1-ol (allyl alcohol) gives propenal: CH2=CHCH2OHPCCCH2=CHCHO.
Oxidation of secondary alcohols to ketones
Secondary alcohols are oxidised to ketones by chromic acid (H2CrO4), acidified K2Cr2O7 or PCC:
RCH(OH)R′H2CrO4RCOR′
Anhydrous chromium trioxide, CrO3, also oxidises secondary alcohols to ketones: cyclohexanol gives cyclohexanone.
The reaction usually stops at the ketone, because oxidising it further would require breaking a C-C bond. Tertiary alcohols have no hydrogen on the carbinol carbon and are not oxidised under these conditions.
Figure 2: Oxidation of alcohols: PCC stops a primary alcohol at the aldehyde, while excess acidified K2Cr2O7 continues to the acid; a secondary alcohol stops at the ketone.
PCC in CH2Cl2
No water, so no aldehyde hydrate forms. A 1° alcohol stops at the aldehyde, and a C=C elsewhere is left alone.
Acidified K2Cr2O7
Water is present, so the aldehyde hydrate forms and is oxidised. A 1° alcohol goes on to the acid unless the aldehyde is distilled out; a 2° alcohol stops at the ketone.
Solved Example 1
Give the main organic product: (a) butan-1-ol with PCC in CH2Cl2; (b) butan-1-ol heated with excess acidified K2Cr2O7; (c) pentan-2-ol with acidified K2Cr2O7.
Solution:
(a) PCC works without water and stops at the aldehyde. Butanal, CH3CH2CH2CHO.
(b) Excess aqueous Cr(VI) with heating oxidises the aldehyde further. Butanoic acid, CH3CH2CH2COOH.
(c) A secondary alcohol stops at the ketone, because further oxidation would break a C-C bond. Pentan-2-one, CH3COCH2CH2CH3.
Dehydrogenation of alcohols
This method suits volatile alcohols. When the alcohol vapour is passed over a heated heavy metal catalyst, copper at 573 K or silver, hydrogen is removed instead of being oxidised away. The method is used industrially.
A tertiary alcohol has no hydrogen on the carbinol carbon to lose, so under the same conditions it is dehydrated to an alkene.
Figure 3: Dehydrogenation of alcohols over copper at 573 K: 1° alcohols give aldehydes, 2° alcohols give ketones, and 3° alcohols are dehydrated to alkenes.
Solved Example 2
The vapours of three isomeric C4H10O alcohols are each passed over copper at 573 K: butan-1-ol, butan-2-ol and 2-methylpropan-2-ol. Name the product in each case.
Solution:
Butan-1-ol is a 1° alcohol, so it loses H2 to give butanal.
Butan-2-ol is a 2° alcohol, so it loses H2 to give butan-2-one.
2-Methylpropan-2-ol is a 3° alcohol with no hydrogen on the carbinol carbon, so it cannot be dehydrogenated. It loses water instead, giving 2-methylpropene.
Key idea
A secondary alcohol stops at the ketone without help, because going further would break a C-C bond. A primary alcohol stops at the aldehyde only when water is kept out (PCC), when the aldehyde is distilled off as it forms, or when hydrogen is removed instead of oxygen being added (Cu or Ag).
3. From Acid Derivatives by Partial Reduction
In principle, reducing a carboxylic acid should give an aldehyde. In practice the usual reagent, LiAlH4, reduces the acid all the way to a primary alcohol. LiAlH4 is a powerful reducing agent and aldehydes are reduced very easily, so any aldehyde that forms is immediately reduced further:
RCOOHLiAlH4[RCHO]LiAlH4RCH2OH
The solution has two parts. First, start from an acid derivative that is more easily reduced than the acid itself: an acyl chloride, an ester or a nitrile. Second, use an aluminium hydride that is less reactive than LiAlH4. The two standard reagents, lithium tri-tert-butoxyaluminium hydride (JEE Advanced) and diisobutylaluminium hydride (DIBAL-H), each carry only one hydride. Both are sterically hindered, so they transfer hydride with more difficulty.
Figure 4: Hydride reagents compared: LiAlH4 over-reduces, while bulky LiAlH(OCMe3)3 and DIBAL-H stop at the aldehyde.Figure 5: Partial reduction to aldehydes: acyl chlorides with LiAlH(OCMe3)3, and esters and nitriles with DIBAL-H, at low temperature.
Acyl chlorides with LiAlH(OCMe3)3
JEE Advanced
Acyl chlorides are reduced to aldehydes by lithium tri-tert-butoxyaluminium hydride, LiAlH[OC(CH3)3]3, in ether at −78∘C. The carboxylic acid is first converted into the acyl chloride with thionyl chloride:
For example, 4-bromobenzoyl chloride gives 4-bromobenzaldehyde under these conditions, so the method works for aromatic acid chlorides too.
Hydride adds. The single Al-H hydride attacks the carbonyl carbon, and the π electrons move onto oxygen.
Chloride leaves. The alkoxide re-forms the carbonyl bond and expels Cl−, a good leaving group. Lithium chloride is the by-product.
Reduction stops. At −78∘C the bulky reagent reacts with the aldehyde only slowly, so it survives.
Figure 6: Mechanism of acyl chloride reduction by lithium tri-tert-butoxyaluminium hydride: hydride addition, then loss of chloride.
Rosenmund reduction
Rosenmund reduction: an acyl chloride is hydrogenated over palladium supported on barium sulphate, with the catalyst partially poisoned by sulphur or quinoline. The C-Cl bond is reduced to C-H, giving the aldehyde.
RCOCl+H2Pd/BaSO4S or quinolineRCHO+HCl
The partial deactivation of the catalyst is essential. A fully active palladium catalyst would also reduce the aldehyde to a primary alcohol. Formaldehyde cannot be made by this method because formyl chloride (HCOCl) is unstable.
Figure 7: Rosenmund reduction: H2 over Pd/BaSO4 poisoned with sulphur or quinoline reduces an acyl chloride to an aldehyde without over-reduction.
Esters with DIBAL-H
Esters are reduced to aldehydes by DIBAL-H in toluene at −78∘C, followed by water. The amount of reagent must be carefully controlled (one equivalent), and the low temperature is essential to avoid over-reduction.
Ethyl undecanoate, for example, gives undecanal: CH3(CH2)9COOC2H5(i) DIBAL-H(ii) H2OCH3(CH2)9CHO+C2H5OH.
Coordination. Aluminium in DIBAL-H is electron-deficient (a Lewis acid) and binds the carbonyl oxygen.
Hydride transfer. The hydride moves from aluminium to the carbonyl carbon, giving a tetrahedral aluminium intermediate.
Work-up. This intermediate is relatively stable at −78∘C and does not expel R′O− while cold. Hydrolysis at the end liberates the aldehyde and R'OH.
Figure 8: Mechanism of DIBAL-H reduction of an ester. At −78∘C the hydride adds and the Al-bound intermediate holds; at work-up, water removes Al (and destroys leftover DIBAL-H), and the freed O− pushes out R′O− to give the aldehyde.
Nitriles with DIBAL-H or SnCl2/HCl (Stephen reduction)
DIBAL-H adds one hydride to the carbon of the C≡N group, giving an N-aluminium imine that is stable until hydrolysis:
RC≡NDIBAL-H, tolueneRCH=NAl(Bui)2H2ORCHO
The reduction is selective: DIBAL-H leaves a C=C elsewhere in the molecule untouched. Hex-4-enenitrile gives hex-4-enal:
The Stephen reduction achieves the same result with stannous chloride and hydrogen chloride. The nitrile is reduced to an aldimine, isolated as its hydrochloride, which is hydrolysed to the aldehyde:
RC≡NSnCl2, HClRCH=NH⋅HClH3O+RCHO+NH4Cl
Figure 9: Nitriles to aldehydes. DIBAL-H adds one hydride (Route 1) and Stephen reduction with SnCl2/HCl gives the imine salt directly (Route 2); both meet at the iminium ion, which water hydrolyses to the aldehyde and NH4+.
Exam Trick
An aldehyde from an acid derivative: acyl chloride, H2 over poisoned Pd/BaSO4 (Rosenmund); ester, DIBAL-H at low temperature, then water; nitrile, SnCl2 and HCl, then water (Stephen), or DIBAL-H, then water. LiAlH4 never stops at the aldehyde: it gives the alcohol, or the amine from a nitrile.
Solved Example 3
Suggest reagents for each conversion and explain why LiAlH4 is not suitable: (a) ethyl butanoate to butanal; (b) butanoyl chloride to butanal; (c) pentanenitrile to pentanal.
Solution:
(a) DIBAL-H in toluene at −78∘C, then H2O. The tetrahedral intermediate survives while cold and gives the aldehyde on work-up.
(b) H2 over poisoned Pd/BaSO4 (Rosenmund), or LiAlH(OCMe3)3 at −78∘C (JEE Advanced).
(c) SnCl2/HCl, then H3O+ (Stephen), or DIBAL-H followed by water.
LiAlH4 is unsuitable because it reduces the aldehyde as soon as it forms. It would give butan-1-ol in (a) and (b), and pentan-1-amine in (c).
Solved Example 4
(a) Why is the palladium catalyst poisoned in Rosenmund reduction? (b) Why can methanal not be prepared by this method?
Solution:
(a) Fully active palladium would also hydrogenate the aldehyde to a primary alcohol. Barium sulphate lowers the activity, and sulphur or quinoline blocks the most active sites, so only the more reactive C-Cl bond of the acyl chloride is reduced. Poisoning stops the reaction at the aldehyde.
(b) Methanal would need formyl chloride, HCOCl, as the starting material. Formyl chloride is unstable and decomposes to CO and HCl, so it cannot be used.
Quick Recall: tap to checkWhy does PCC stop a primary alcohol at the aldehyde?
It is used without water, so the aldehyde hydrate, which Cr(VI) would oxidise, cannot form.
Which catalysts dehydrogenate alcohol vapour, and which alcohols suit the method?
Heated copper (573 K) or silver; volatile alcohols. 1° alcohols give aldehydes and 2° alcohols give ketones.
Why is the palladium poisoned in the Rosenmund reduction?
So that it reduces the C-Cl bond of the acyl chloride but not the aldehyde that forms.
What does DIBAL-H do to a C=C elsewhere in a nitrile?
Nothing: it reduces only the C≡N group, so hex-4-enenitrile gives hex-4-enal.
Name the reagents of the Stephen reaction.
SnCl2 and HCl give the aldimine salt, which water hydrolyses to the aldehyde.
4. Ketones Using Organometallic Reagents
Nitriles with Grignard reagents
A Grignard reagent adds once to the carbon of a nitrile. The product is the magnesium salt of an imine, which acid hydrolysis converts into a ketone. The imine carbon cannot be attacked a second time, so the reaction does not go on to an alcohol.
RC≡N+R′MgBretherRR′C=NMgBrH3O+RCOR′
An aromatic Grignard reagent reacts in the same way: propanenitrile and phenylmagnesium bromide give propiophenone (1-phenylpropan-1-one).
A dialkylcadmium is prepared from a Grignard reagent and cadmium chloride. It reacts with an acyl chloride to give a ketone:
2RMgBr+CdCl2→R2Cd+2MgBrCl
2R′COCl+R2Cd→2R′COR+CdCl2
A Grignard reagent cannot be used here because it attacks the ketone as fast as it forms, giving a tertiary alcohol. Dialkylcadmium is much less reactive, so it attacks the reactive acyl chloride but leaves the ketone alone.
Figure 10: Ketones from nitriles with Grignard reagents, and from acyl chlorides with dialkylcadmium. The C=N−MgBr salt and the mild R2Cd both stop at one addition, so the product is a ketone, not a 3∘ alcohol.
For (b), also name a second nitrile and Grignard reagent that give B, and say why HCN cannot be used with a Grignard reagent to make an aldehyde.
Solution:
(a) PBr3 replaces the OH group by Br: A = 1-bromo-2-methylpropane, (CH3)2CHCH2Br. With magnesium in dry ether it gives B = (2-methylpropyl)magnesium bromide, (CH3)2CHCH2MgBr.
B adds once to the nitrile carbon of ethanenitrile: C = the imine saltCH3C(=NMgBr)CH2CH(CH3)2. Hydrolysis gives the ketone D = 4-methylpentan-2-one, CH3COCH2CH(CH3)2.
(b) A = the imine saltC6H5C(=NMgBr)CH2CH2CH3, and hydrolysis gives B = 1-phenylbutan-1-one, C6H5COCH2CH2CH3. The nitrile carbon becomes the carbonyl carbon, so either group on it can come from the nitrile: butanenitrile with phenylmagnesium bromide gives the same ketone.
HCN cannot be used. Its hydrogen is acidic (pKa about 9.2), so it protonates the Grignard reagent at once and gives the alkane RH; no addition to the C≡N group takes place.
(a) The Grignard reagent adds to the nitrile carbon: A = the imine salt(CH3)3CC(=NMgBr)CH2CH3. Hydrolysis gives B = 2,2-dimethylpentan-3-one, (CH3)3CCOCH2CH3.
(b) HBr adds to the C=C: A = bromocyclopentane. With magnesium it gives B = cyclopentylmagnesium bromide. Addition to propanenitrile and hydrolysis give C = 1-cyclopentylpropan-1-one, C5H9COCH2CH3.
Solved Example 7
Butan-2-one is to be made from acetyl chloride. A student uses ethylmagnesium bromide and gets 3-methylpentan-3-ol instead. Explain, and give a better reagent.
Solution:
Ethylmagnesium bromide does convert acetyl chloride into butan-2-one, but a Grignard reagent attacks ketones readily. A second molecule adds to the ketone at once, and hydrolysis gives the tertiary alcohol 3-methylpentan-3-ol.
The better reagent is diethylcadmium, made from C2H5MgBr and CdCl2. It is reactive enough for the acyl chloride but not for the ketone:
2CH3COCl+(C2H5)2Cd→2CH3COC2H5+CdCl2
Key idea
The reductions of Section 3 and the organometallic routes of Section 4 stop at the carbonyl compound for one of two reasons. Either the reagent is too mild to attack the aldehyde or ketone it makes (poisoned Pd, LiAlH(OCMe3)3 in the cold, R2Cd), or the first product is held in a form that cannot react again until work-up (the cold DIBAL-H adduct, the imine salts of the Stephen and Grignard routes).
5. From Alkenes: Ozonolysis
Ozone adds across a C=C bond to form an ozonide. Treating the ozonide with zinc dust and water (reductive work-up) cleaves it into two carbonyl compounds. Zinc destroys the hydrogen peroxide formed, which would otherwise oxidise any aldehyde to an acid.
R2C=CHR′O3ozonideZn, H2OR2C=O+R′CHO
To predict the products, erase the double bond and attach an oxygen to each of its two carbons. A carbon that carried a hydrogen becomes an aldehyde group; a carbon carrying two alkyl groups becomes a ketone.
Figure 11: Reductive ozonolysis of 2-methylbut-2-ene gives ethanal and propanone, with a shortcut for predicting ozonolysis products.
Exam Trick
To work back from ozonolysis products to the alkene, write the carbonyl compounds with their C=O groups facing each other, delete the oxygens and join the two carbons by a double bond. A product with two C=O groups is joined at both ends. If it sat between two C=C bonds, in a chain or a ring, each C=O joins another fragment (OHC−CHO from a =CH−CH= unit); if it came from a ring with only one C=C, its two C=O carbons join each other (cyclohexene gives hexanedial, OHC(CH2)4CHO).
Solved Example 8
(a) Give the products of reductive ozonolysis of pent-2-ene. (b) Which alkene of formula C6H12 gives only propanone on ozonolysis with Zn/H2O?
Solution:
(a) CH3CH=CHCH2CH3: cut the double bond and add O to each carbon. The products are ethanal(CH3CHO) and propanal(CH3CH2CHO).
(b) Only propanone means both double-bond carbons carry two methyl groups, and the molecule is symmetrical: (CH3)2C=C(CH3)2, 2,3-dimethylbut-2-ene.
Solved Example 9
A hydrocarbon A, C7H12, takes up two moles of H2 over nickel to give B, C7H16. Ozonolysis of A followed by zinc and water gives three compounds: C, C3H6O, which does not reduce Tollens' reagent; D, C2H4O, which does; and E, C2H2O2, which forms a dioxime. Identify A to E.
Solution:
C7H12 is four hydrogens short of the alkane C7H16, and A takes up exactly two H2, so A has no ring. Ozonolysis gives three carbonyl compounds, so A is a diene.
C is a three-carbon ketone, propanone, so one end of A is (CH3)2C=. D is ethanal, so the other end is =CHCH3. E has a CHO group at each end, ethanedial (glyoxal), OHC-CHO; it comes from a =CH−CH= unit that sits between the two double bonds, so they are conjugated.
A = 2-methylhexa-2,4-diene, (CH3)2C=CH−CH=CHCH3; B = 2-methylhexane; C = propanone; D = ethanal; E = ethanedial.
Check: 3 + 2 + 2 = 7 carbons, as in A. Had C been propanal, A would be hepta-2,4-diene, but propanal would reduce Tollens' reagent.
6. From Alkynes
Hydration with mercuric sulphate
Water adds to alkynes only with the catalytic help of both acid and mercury(II) ions: dilute H2SO4 with HgSO4 at about 333 K. Ethyne gives ethanal; every other alkyne gives a ketone, because water adds by Markovnikov's rule.
HC≡CH+H2OHgSO4, dil. H2SO4333 KCH3CHO
CH3C≡CH+H2OHgSO4, dil. H2SO4CH3COCH3
Exam Trick
Hydration of alkynes: ethyne is the only alkyne that gives an aldehyde. A terminal alkyne gives a methyl ketone, a symmetrical internal alkyne gives one ketone, and an unsymmetrical internal alkyne gives a mixture of two ketones.
π-complex.Hg2+ forms a complex with the triple bond, making it open to attack by water.
Water attacks. Loss of H+ gives a mercury-substituted enol.
H+ replaces Hg2+. This gives the enol and regenerates the catalyst.
Tautomerism. The enol rearranges to the far more stable keto form.
Figure 12: Mechanism of mercury(II)-catalysed hydration of ethyne: π-complex, mercury-substituted enol, enol, and keto-enol tautomerism to ethanal.
Hydroboration-oxidation of terminal alkynes
JEE Main and Advanced
A bulky dialkylborane (R2BH) adds once, with boron going to the terminal carbon. Treating the vinylborane with alkaline hydrogen peroxide gives an enol with the -OH on the end carbon, which tautomerises to an aldehyde.
Hydration and hydroboration-oxidation therefore put the oxygen on opposite ends of a terminal alkyne.
Figure 13: Hydration of but-1-yne gives butan-2-one (Markovnikov), while hydroboration-oxidation gives butanal (anti-Markovnikov).
H2O, Hg2+, H+
Markovnikov: the oxygen goes to the inner carbon of a terminal alkyne, giving a methyl ketone (but-1-yne gives butan-2-one).
R2BH, then H2O2, OH−
Anti-Markovnikov: the oxygen goes to the end carbon, giving an aldehyde (but-1-yne gives butanal).
Solved Example 10
Propyne is treated separately with (a) HgSO4/dil. H2SO4 and (b) a bulky R2BH, then H2O2/NaOH. Give the products and explain the difference.
Solution:
(a) Markovnikov hydration puts -OH on C-2. The enol CH3C(OH)=CH2 tautomerises to propanone, CH3COCH3.
(b) Boron adds to the less hindered terminal carbon, and oxidation replaces it with -OH on C-1. The enol CH3CH=CHOH tautomerises to propanal, CH3CH2CHO.
The two methods place the oxygen on opposite ends of the triple bond.
Key idea
Where the C=O ends up is set by the starting multiple bond: ozonolysis puts an oxygen on each carbon of the C=C, hydration puts it where Markovnikov's rule sends the OH, and hydroboration-oxidation puts it on the end carbon of a terminal alkyne.
7. Hydrolysis of gem-Dihalides
A gem-dihalide has both halogens on the same carbon. Boiling it with aqueous alkali replaces both halogens by -OH groups. The resulting gem-diol is unstable and loses water to give a carbonyl compound. A terminal gem-dihalide (RCHX2) gives an aldehyde; a non-terminal one (RCX2R′) gives a ketone.
The same reaction is a commercial method for benzaldehyde: side-chain chlorination of toluene gives benzal chloride, C6H5CHCl2, which water hydrolyses at 373 K (taught on the Preparation of Aromatic Aldehydes and Ketones page).
Figure 14: Hydrolysis of gem-dihalides through unstable gem-diols: a terminal gem-dihalide gives an aldehyde and a non-terminal one gives a ketone.
Solved Example 11
Give the product when 1,1-dichloropropane is boiled with aqueous alkali.
Solution:
Both chlorines are on the same terminal carbon. Aqueous KOH replaces them with -OH groups, giving the unstable gem-diol CH3CH2CH(OH)2, which loses water.
Quick Recall: tap to checkWhy does a Grignard reagent not stop at the ketone with an acyl chloride, while R2Cd does?
RMgX attacks the ketone as fast as it forms, giving a 3° alcohol; R2Cd is too mild to attack the ketone.
What does a nitrile give with a Grignard reagent, then H3O+?
A ketone: the imine salt formed first cannot take a second Grignard molecule.
What does reductive ozonolysis of 2-methylbut-2-ene give?
Propanone and ethanal.
Which alkyne gives an aldehyde with HgSO4 and dil. H2SO4?
Only ethyne (giving ethanal); every other alkyne gives a ketone.
What does 2,2-dichloropropane give when boiled with aqueous KOH?
Propanone, through the unstable gem-diol.
8. Dry Distillation of Calcium Salts
Beyond the JEE Main and NEET syllabus
Heating the calcium salt of a fatty acid gives a ketone and calcium carbonate:
(CH3COO)2CaΔCH3COCH3+CaCO3
Aldehydes are obtained by heating the calcium salt of an acid together with calcium formate, to about 675 K:
(CH3COO)2Ca+(HCOO)2Ca675 K2CH3CHO+2CaCO3
Note: when two different calcium salts are heated together, the carboxylate groups pair up in every possible way. The mixture of calcium acetate and calcium formate therefore also gives some methanal (from two formates) and propanone (from two acetates). This makes the method less useful for pure products.
Solved Example 12
What is formed on dry distillation of (a) calcium propanoate alone; (b) a mixture of calcium acetate and calcium formate?
Solution:
(a) Two propanoate groups join, losing CaCO3:
(CH3CH2COO)2CaΔCH3CH2COCH2CH3+CaCO3
Product: pentan-3-one.
(b) An acetate paired with a formate gives ethanal, the intended product. Two acetates give propanone and two formates give methanal, so these form as by-products.
9. Choosing the Right Method
Starting material
Reagent
Product
Watch for
1° alcohol
PCC, CH2Cl2
Aldehyde
Aqueous Cr(VI) goes on to the acid
2° alcohol
K2Cr2O7/H+ or PCC; Cu (573 K) or Ag
Ketone
3° alcohols do not give carbonyls
Acyl chloride
H2, Pd/BaSO4 (poisoned) or LiAlH(OCMe3)3 (JEE Advanced)
Aldehyde
Not for HCHO; active Pd over-reduces
Acyl chloride
R2Cd
Ketone
RMgX would give a 3° alcohol
Ester
DIBAL-H, −78∘C, then H2O
Aldehyde
Warm conditions over-reduce
Nitrile
SnCl2/HCl or DIBAL-H, then H3O+
Aldehyde
Hydrolysis step is essential
Nitrile
R'MgX, then H3O+
Ketone
Adds one new C-C bond
Alkene
O3, then Zn/H2O
Aldehydes and/or ketones
Without Zn, aldehydes become acids
Terminal alkyne
HgSO4/H2SO4
Methyl ketone (ethanal from ethyne)
Markovnikov
Terminal alkyne
R2BH, then H2O2/OH−
Aldehyde
Anti-Markovnikov
gem-Dihalide
aq. KOH
Aldehyde or ketone
Terminal vs non-terminal
Figure 15: Flowchart: choosing a route to an aldehyde or a ketone from the starting compound.Figure 16: Mind map: preparation of aldehydes and ketones.
Practice Questions
Try each one before opening the answer.
Compound (A), C6H14O, is refluxed with K2Cr2O7 and dil. H2SO4 and gives (B), C6H12O. (B) forms a 2,4-dinitrophenylhydrazone but gives no iodoform test, and Clemmensen reduction of (B) gives 2-methylpentane. Identify (A) and (B).Show answer
(B) reacts with 2,4-DNP, so it is a carbonyl compound, and it survives refluxing dichromate, so it is a ketone. On the 2-methylpentane chain a ketone C=O can sit only at C-3 or C-4. At C-4 it would be 4-methylpentan-2-one, a methyl ketone that gives iodoform. So (B) = 2-methylpentan-3-one, (CH3)2CHCOCH2CH3, and (A) = 2-methylpentan-3-ol.
An organic compound (A) contains C = 64.82%, H = 13.60% and O = 21.58%. When vaporised, 0.111 g of (A) displaces 33.6 mL of air, measured at 273 K and 1 atm. (A) gives hydrogen with sodium, and on mild oxidation gives (B), which forms a semicarbazone and gives the iodoform test. Identify (A) and (B).Show answer
Molar mass = 0.111 × 22400 / 33.6 = 74 g mol−1. C : H : O = 64.82/12 : 13.60/1 : 21.58/16 = 5.40 : 13.60 : 1.35 = 4 : 10 : 1, so (A) is C4H10O (M = 74). Hydrogen with sodium shows an -OH group. (B) is a methyl ketone (semicarbazone and iodoform), so it is butanone. (A) = butan-2-ol, CH3CH(OH)CH2CH3; (B) = butanone.
Two isomeric gem-dibromides, C6H12Br2, are boiled with aqueous KOH and give two isomeric compounds, C6H12O. Both form oximes, neither reduces Tollens' reagent, and Clemmensen reduction of each gives hexane. Only one of them gives the iodoform test. Identify the two dibromides and the two carbonyl compounds.Show answer
Both products are ketones (oximes, but no Tollens' test) on an unbranched six-carbon chain (hexane after Clemmensen), so the C=O is at C-2 or C-3. 2,2-Dibromohexane gives hexan-2-one, a methyl ketone, which gives iodoform. 3,3-Dibromohexane gives hexan-3-one, which does not.
Compound (A), C7H15Br, forms a Grignard reagent that gives heptane with dilute acid. With aqueous KOH, (A) gives (B), C7H16O, which turns Lucas reagent cloudy within a few minutes at room temperature, but not at once. (B) with K2Cr2O7/dil. H2SO4 gives (C), a ketone with two identical alkyl groups. Identify (A), (B) and (C).Show answer
Heptane from the Grignard reagent means an unbranched chain. Cloudiness within minutes, not at once, marks a 2° alcohol. A ketone with two identical alkyl groups on a seven-carbon chain has its C=O at C-4. (A) = 4-bromoheptane, (B) = heptan-4-ol, (C) = heptan-4-one, CH3CH2CH2COCH2CH2CH3.
Convert pent-1-yne into octan-4-one in not more than three steps.Show answer
Step 1:NaNH2 in liquid NH3 gives sodium pent-1-ynide, CH3CH2CH2C≡CNa.
Oct-4-yne is symmetrical, so water gives the same ketone whichever way it adds. An unsymmetrical internal alkyne would give a mixture of two ketones.
Common Mistakes to Avoid
Watch out
Using excess acidified K2Cr2O7 to make an aldehyde. The aldehyde goes on to the carboxylic acid. Use PCC, or distil the aldehyde out as it forms.
Using LiAlH4 on acyl chlorides, esters or nitriles to make aldehydes. It over-reduces to alcohols (or amines from nitriles).
Forgetting the low temperature for DIBAL-H with esters. The tetrahedral intermediate is only stable when cold.
Writing Rosenmund reduction for methanal, or using unpoisoned palladium.
Using a Grignard reagent with an acyl chloride to make a ketone. The ketone reacts further to a tertiary alcohol; use dialkylcadmium.
Doing ozonolysis without zinc. Oxidative work-up turns aldehyde fragments into carboxylic acids.
Expecting an aldehyde from hydration of a terminal alkyne. Only ethyne gives an aldehyde; other terminal alkynes give methyl ketones. Use hydroboration-oxidation for the aldehyde.
Expecting a carbonyl compound from a tertiary alcohol. It resists mild oxidation and dehydrates to an alkene over hot copper.
Frequently Asked Questions
What are the general methods of preparation of aldehydes and ketones?
Aldehydes and ketones are prepared by oxidation or dehydrogenation of alcohols, partial reduction of acyl chlorides, esters and nitriles (Rosenmund, Stephen, DIBAL-H), reaction of nitriles with Grignard reagents or acyl chlorides with dialkylcadmium, ozonolysis of alkenes, hydration of alkynes, hydrolysis of gem-dihalides, and dry distillation of calcium salts (beyond the JEE Main and NEET syllabus).
Why does PCC stop the oxidation of a primary alcohol at the aldehyde?
PCC (pyridinium chlorochromate) is used in dry dichloromethane. Chromium(VI) oxidises an aldehyde to a carboxylic acid through the aldehyde hydrate, RCH(OH)2, which forms only when water is present. Without water the hydrate cannot form, so oxidation stops cleanly at the aldehyde.
What is Rosenmund reduction and why is the catalyst poisoned?
Rosenmund reduction converts an acyl chloride into an aldehyde using hydrogen over palladium on barium sulphate. The catalyst is partially poisoned with sulphur or quinoline so it reduces only the C-Cl bond. An active catalyst would reduce the aldehyde further to a primary alcohol. It cannot make methanal.
What is the Stephen reaction?
In the Stephen reaction, a nitrile is reduced by stannous chloride and hydrogen chloride to an aldimine, which separates as its hydrochloride. Hydrolysis of this imine salt with water gives the aldehyde. For example, ethanenitrile gives ethanal. It is a standard method for making aldehydes from nitriles.
How does DIBAL-H convert an ester into an aldehyde?
DIBAL-H (diisobutylaluminium hydride) has one hydride and a Lewis acidic aluminium. It binds the ester carbonyl oxygen and delivers one hydride, forming a tetrahedral intermediate that is stable at −78 °C. When water is added at the end, this intermediate breaks down to the aldehyde and an alcohol.
Why is dialkylcadmium used instead of a Grignard reagent to make ketones from acyl chlorides?
A Grignard reagent attacks the ketone as soon as it forms, giving a tertiary alcohol. Dialkylcadmium, R2Cd, is far less reactive: it reacts with the highly reactive acyl chloride but not with the ketone product. The ketone therefore survives and can be isolated.
Which preparation methods of aldehydes and ketones are most important for JEE Main and JEE Advanced?
JEE questions on these methods match reagents to named reductions (Rosenmund, Stephen, DIBAL-H) and ask for the products of ozonolysis and of alkyne hydration. Learn each method with its reagent, its conditions and the product it gives.
Which methods of preparing aldehydes and ketones should NEET students know?
NEET follows NCERT, which covers oxidation and dehydrogenation of alcohols, ozonolysis of alkenes, hydration of alkynes, Rosenmund reduction, Stephen reaction, DIBAL-H reduction of nitriles and esters, and ketones from acyl chlorides with dialkylcadmium or from nitriles with Grignard reagents. Learn the exact reagents and conditions.