Preparation of Carboxylic acids
Preparation of carboxylic acids uses three broad strategies: oxidation (of primary alcohols, aldehydes, alkylbenzenes, alkenes and alkynes), hydrolysis (of nitriles and acid derivatives such as esters, amides and acid chlorides), and new carbon-carbon bonds made with carbon dioxide (Grignard reagents). The fastest way to choose a method is to count carbons. Oxidation of primary alcohols and aldehydes keeps the carbon count, and so does hydrolysis of acid derivatives. The Grignard and nitrile routes add one carbon. Side-chain oxidation keeps only one carbon of each side chain, and oxidative cleavage splits the chain at the multiple bond. JEE Main, JEE Advanced and NEET questions on these methods ask for the products, often of a sequence of steps.
- ★ Must learn (same carbon count)
- (only -CHO is oxidised)
- ★ Must learn (the benzylic C needs an H, or is a C=O as in acetophenone)
- ★ Must learn (+1 carbon)
- ★ Must learn (+1 carbon)
- ★ Must learn (Z = Cl, OCOR, OR', )
- (chain splits)
- (mild conditions stop at the amide)
- (Jones reagent; same carbon count)
Overview: Methods at a Glance
Before memorising individual reactions, see how the routes connect. Each route either keeps, adds or removes carbon atoms, and that single idea solves most "convert A into B" questions.
1. Oxidation of Alcohols, Aldehydes and Ketones
Primary alcohols are oxidised by potassium permanganate () in neutral, acidic or alkaline solution. Acidified potassium dichromate (/) also works. So does chromium trioxide in aqueous sulphuric acid (), called Jones reagent. The alcohol is first oxidised to an aldehyde, which is oxidised further to the carboxylic acid with the same number of carbon atoms.
Alkaline permanganate gives the salt of the acid, so acid is added afterwards. Jones reagent gives the acid directly, as for hexan-1-ol.
Aldehydes are oxidised to carboxylic acids even by mild oxidising agents, such as Tollens' reagent, Fehling's solution or bromine water. The number of carbon atoms does not change. The Properties and Important Reactions of Aldehydes and Ketones page teaches these oxidations.
Selective oxidants.
Use a mild reagent when the molecule has a group you want to keep. PCC (pyridinium chlorochromate) oxidises a primary alcohol only as far as the aldehyde, and Tollens' or Fehling's reagent oxidises only -CHO. A C=C double bond survives both, while hot would cleave it.
Oxidation of ketones
Ketones resist mild oxidising agents. Strong oxidising agents with heat split a ketone next to its C=O and give a mixture of acids with fewer carbons. The Properties and Important Reactions of Aldehydes and Ketones page teaches this oxidation.
Propanoic acid has the same 3 carbons as propene, so oxidation of a primary alcohol is the right route. We need propan-1-ol, the anti-Markovnikov alcohol, which hydroboration-oxidation gives. Acidified permanganate then oxidises it to the acid.
Acid-catalysed hydration would give propan-2-ol instead, which oxidises only to acetone and cannot give propanoic acid.
PCC oxidises the primary group only as far as -CHO, and leaves the ring C=C untouched. A is cyclohex-1-ene-1-carbaldehyde.
Tollens' reagent oxidises only the aldehyde group; acidification releases the free acid. B is cyclohex-1-ene-1-carboxylic acid, with the double bond still intact.
Haloform reaction of methyl ketones
A methyl ketone, , gives the salt of an acid with one carbon fewer in the haloform reaction. The Properties and Important Reactions of Aldehydes and Ketones page teaches this reaction.
2. Oxidation of Alkylbenzenes
Although benzene and alkanes are quite unreactive towards the usual oxidising agents (, and so on), the benzene ring makes an aliphatic side chain quite susceptible to oxidation. The side chain is oxidised down to the ring, and only a carboxyl group (-COOH) remains to show the position of the original side chain. Acidic or alkaline potassium permanganate is generally used. Chromic acid (potassium dichromate in acid) or dilute nitric acid can also be used. Oxidation of a side chain is more difficult than oxidation of an alkene and needs prolonged treatment with hot .
Whatever the length of the side chain, the product is benzoic acid. The carbon attached to the ring is the benzylic carbon. It must carry at least one hydrogen, or already be oxidised, as the C=O of an acyl group. So primary and secondary alkyl groups are oxidised. A tertiary alkyl group, such as tert-butyl, is not oxidised to -COOH.
An acetyl group has no benzylic hydrogen, but its benzylic carbon is already a C=O. So acetophenone also gives benzoic acid.
Suitably substituted alkenes are oxidised by the same reagents. Styrene (phenylethene), , also gives benzoic acid.
This reaction is used for two purposes: (a) the synthesis of carboxylic acids and (b) the identification of alkylbenzenes, because the number and positions of -COOH groups in the product reveal the number and positions of the side chains.
Count -COOH groups in the product to count side chains: o-xylene gives phthalic acid (benzene-1,2-dicarboxylic acid), and p-xylene gives terephthalic acid (benzene-1,4-dicarboxylic acid).
What does isopropylbenzene (cumene) give with hot ?
Which side chain survives hot ?
What does p-xylene give?
3. Carbonation of Grignard Reagents
The Grignard synthesis of a carboxylic acid is carried out by bubbling gaseous into the ether solution of the Grignard reagent, or by pouring the Grignard reagent onto crushed dry ice (solid ). In the second method dry ice serves not only as the reagent but also as the cooling agent.
The Grignard reagent adds to the carbon-oxygen double bond of just as it does with aldehydes and ketones. The product is the magnesium salt of the carboxylic acid, from which the free acid is liberated by treatment with a mineral acid.
The Grignard reagent can be prepared from primary, secondary, tertiary or aromatic halides. The method is limited only by the presence of other reactive groups in the molecule. These groups are -OH, -NH, -COOH, C=O and . The following synthesis shows its use:
The product, 2,2-dimethylpropanoic acid, is commonly called trimethylacetic acid.
(i) The four ring hydrogens of 1,4-dimethylbenzene are all alike, so ring bromination gives only one product. A is 2-bromo-1,4-dimethylbenzene. B is its Grignard reagent, (2,5-dimethylphenyl)magnesium bromide. Carbon dioxide and then acid turn B into 2,5-dimethylbenzoic acid.
(ii) A is the Grignard reagent (4-propylphenyl)magnesium bromide. It adds to and gives B, the halomagnesium salt
Why not oxidise 1,4-dipropylbenzene instead? Hot would oxidise both propyl groups, because each has a benzylic H. It would give benzene-1,4-dicarboxylic acid. The Grignard route adds one -COOH and keeps the propyl group.
The product has one more carbon, attached where the bromine was, so use a Grignard reagent and carbon dioxide.
(C) gives with , so it is a carboxylic acid. It has one carbon more than (A), added by the Grignard route.
(B) shows geometrical isomerism, so it is but-2-ene, . Each C=C carbon carries two different groups, H and .
Check the four bromides . 1-Bromobutane gives but-1-ene. 1-Bromo-2-methylpropane and 2-bromo-2-methylpropane give 2-methylpropene. Only 2-bromobutane gives but-2-ene as the main product.
(A) is 2-bromobutane, , and (C) is 2-methylbutanoic acid, .
4. Hydrolysis of Nitriles
Aliphatic nitriles are prepared by treating alkyl halides with sodium cyanide in a solvent that dissolves both reactants. In dimethyl sulfoxide (DMSO), the reaction occurs rapidly and exothermically at room temperature. The resulting nitrile is then hydrolysed to the acid by boiling with aqueous acid or alkali.
The hydrolysis goes through the amide, . Acid () or base () catalyses each step. Under mild conditions the reaction stops at the amide.
Mechanism of acid hydrolysis of a nitrile
- Protonation: the nitrogen of takes up , making the carbon strongly electrophilic.
- Attack by water: a lone pair on water attacks the nitrile carbon, and a pi bond shifts onto nitrogen.
- Proton loss: the oxonium ion loses to give an imidic acid, .
- Tautomerism: the imidic acid rearranges to the more stable amide, .
- Amide hydrolysis: hot aqueous acid hydrolyses the amide to and .
(i) Cyanide displaces bromide: A is n-valeronitrile (pentanenitrile), . Refluxing with aqueous alcoholic NaOH gives B, the pentanoate ion (with ). Acidification gives C, n-valeric acid (pentanoic acid), .
(ii) A is phenylacetonitrile, , and acid hydrolysis gives B, phenylacetic acid, .
(A) ; then KCN; then , heat
(B) KCN; then , heat
(C) ; then KCN; then , heat
(D) ; then Mg in dry ether; then
Answer: (A). The product has one carbon more, joined where the -OH was. So -OH must first become a good leaving group, -Br. Cyanide then adds the extra carbon by . Hydrolysis turns -CN into -COOH.
In (B), cyanide cannot replace -OH. In (C), the alcohol is first oxidised to cyclopentanecarboxylic acid, with no extra carbon. In (D), water destroys the Grignard reagent and gives methylcyclopentane.
Both routes turn an alkyl halide into an acid with one carbon atom more. This step up the series is called ascending the series.
+1 carbon. Works for 1°, 2°, 3°, aryl and vinyl halides.
Fails if the molecule has -OH, -NH, -COOH, C=O or .
+1 carbon. Needs an halide: , 1°, benzyl.
Tolerates -OH elsewhere in the molecule.
5. Hydrolysis of Acid Derivatives
Acid chlorides, anhydrides, esters and amides are all hydrolysed to the parent carboxylic acid, with no change in the carbon skeleton. Esters and amides need dilute acid (or base followed by acidification) and heat.
Aqueous base hydrolyses an acid chloride even more readily. It gives the carboxylate ion, and acid then gives the carboxylic acid.
A mixed anhydride gives two different acids.
Which acid derivative is hydrolysed by water alone at room temperature?
What are the products of hydrolysing acetamide with dilute HCl?
6. Preparation Using Carbon Monoxide
(a) Use of alkoxides and methanol
These notes leave out the routes from carbon monoxide and alkoxides or methanol.
(b) Carbonylation of alkenes
These notes leave out the carbonylation of alkenes.
7. Oxidative Cleavage of Alkenes, Alkynes and Cycloalkenes
Strong oxidising agents break carbon-carbon double and triple bonds completely. At a double bond, a carbon gives -COOH, a carbon gives a ketone, and a carbon gives . In an alkyne, each carbon of the triple bond that carries an alkyl group gives -COOH.
A cycloalkene does not split into two molecules. Its ring opens instead, giving a single dicarboxylic acid: cyclobutene gives succinic acid.
Ozonolysis work-up decides the product.
Ozonide + Zn/ (reductive work-up) gives aldehydes and ketones. Ozonide + (oxidative work-up) turns every aldehyde piece into a carboxylic acid. Ketone pieces stay ketones in both.
The Mechanism of Some Important Reactions of Alkenes page teaches ozonolysis.
8. Choosing the Right Method
| Method | Starting material | Carbon change | Watch out for |
|---|---|---|---|
| Oxidation | 1° alcohol, aldehyde | Same | 2° alcohols give ketones, not acids |
| Side-chain oxidation | Alkylbenzene | Chain reduced to -COOH | Needs a benzylic H (or a benzylic C=O) |
| Grignard + | Alkyl or aryl halide | +1 | No -OH, -NH, -COOH, C=O or allowed |
| Nitrile hydrolysis | Methyl, 1° or benzyl halide | +1 | 3°, aryl and vinyl halides fail |
| Hydrolysis of derivatives | Ester, amide, anhydride, acid chloride | Same | Amides need long heating |
| Oxidative cleavage | Alkene, alkyne, cycloalkene | Chain splits | Terminal becomes |
The same choice as a flowchart: count the carbons first.
Start with E. Hot permanganate splits A at its C=C. A end gives , and a end gives an acid. So A is , and E is with four carbons.
E has a branched chain, so it is 2-methylpropanoic acid, . So R is , and A is 3-methylbut-1-ene, .
With a peroxide, HBr adds against Markovnikov's rule, so Br goes to the end carbon. B is 1-bromo-3-methylbutane, , a primary bromide.
Cyanide replaces Br by and adds one carbon. C is 4-methylpentanenitrile, . Hydrolysis gives D, 4-methylpentanoic acid, .
The Grignard route also adds one carbon at the C-Br carbon, so it gives the same D. The carbon count checks each step: A has 5 carbons, D has 6 and E has 4.
(i) Oxidise first. is ortho/para-directing, but -COOH is meta-directing, so chlorination must come after oxidation.
(ii) The acid has one carbon more than the alcohol, so use the Grignard route. First turn -OH into -Br. Bromocyclohexane is a secondary halide. The nitrile route works best with methyl, primary and benzyl halides, so the Grignard route suits it better.
Basic hydrolysis splits the ester into the salt of the acid and the alcohol. Acid then frees D from its salt B.
Jones reagent oxidises a primary alcohol to the acid with the same carbon chain. C gives D, so C and the acid part of A have the same chain. The six carbons of A are therefore split three and three.
C must be a primary alcohol with three carbons, so it is propan-1-ol. Propan-2-ol would give propanone, not an acid.
A = propyl propanoate, ; B = sodium propanoate, ; C = propan-1-ol, ; D = propanoic acid, .
(A) butylmagnesium bromide reacts with water
(B) methyl pentanoate is boiled with aqueous NaOH, and the solution is then acidified
(C) pentylbenzene is heated with alkaline , and the solution is then acidified
(D) pentan-2-ol is heated with acidified
Answer: (B). Basic hydrolysis of the ester gives sodium pentanoate and methanol. Acid then frees pentanoic acid, with the same five-carbon chain.
In (A), water destroys the Grignard reagent and gives butane. In (C), the whole side chain is oxidised to one -COOH, giving benzoic acid. In (D), a secondary alcohol is oxidised only to a ketone, pentan-2-one.
Summary mind map
Which two routes add one carbon?
Which routes can give an acid with fewer carbons than the starting compound?
What does cyclobutene give on oxidative cleavage?
9. Solved Examples: Exam Practice
(A) toluene
(B) ethylbenzene
(C) tert-butylbenzene
(D) isopropylbenzene
Answer: (C). Side-chain oxidation starts at a benzylic C-H. In tert-butylbenzene the benzylic carbon carries three methyl groups and no hydrogen, so the chain is not attacked.
(A) KCN, then
(B) aqueous KOH, then
(C) Mg/ether, then HCHO, then
(D) alcoholic KOH, then /
Answer: (A). Propanoic acid has one more carbon than bromoethane. Cyanide adds it (), and hydrolysis gives . Route (B) gives acetic acid (same carbons), (C) gives propan-1-ol, and (D) gives ethene and then formic acid and .
Hot alkaline oxidises both side chains. The ethyl group has a benzylic H. The acetyl group has none, but its benzylic carbon is already a C=O, so it is oxidised too. Each side chain becomes one carboxylate group.
A is dipotassium benzene-1,3-dicarboxylate, the salt formed in the alkaline solution. Acid frees B, benzene-1,3-dicarboxylic acid (isophthalic acid).
The starting compound, , has 10 carbons, and B, , has 8. Two carbons are lost as , one from each side chain.
Butanoic acid has one more carbon, added where the -OH was. Turn -OH into a leaving group, add cyanide by , then hydrolyse.
The Grignard route (Mg, then , then on the bromide) works equally well.
- What does p-xylene give with hot , then acid?Answer: terephthalic acid (benzene-1,4-dicarboxylic acid)
- + , then gives?Answer: propanoic acid,
- Hex-3-ene is heated with /. Name the product.Answer: propanoic acid (2 mol per mol of alkene)
- Benzonitrile is boiled with dilute acid. Give the products.Answer: benzoic acid and
- Cyclohexene with hot / gives?Answer: hexanedioic acid (adipic acid)
- Which of bromobenzene and benzyl bromide cannot be used in the nitrile route?Answer: bromobenzene (aryl halides do not undergo )
- Pent-1-ene is heated with /. Name the products.Answer: butanoic acid and (the end gives )
Common Mistakes to Avoid
- Forgetting the extra carbon. The Grignard and nitrile routes both give an acid with one more carbon than the alkyl halide.
- Making a Grignard reagent from a molecule that contains -OH, -NH, -COOH, C=O or . These groups destroy the reagent before is added.
- Using NaCN on a tertiary, aryl or vinyl halide. Tertiary halides eliminate and aryl or vinyl halides do not undergo ; use the Grignard route.
- Expecting tert-butylbenzene to give benzoic acid. With no benzylic hydrogen, the side chain is not oxidised.
- Thinking the side chain length is kept. Every oxidisable side chain, however long, ends up as a single -COOH on the ring.
- Oxidising a secondary alcohol and expecting an acid. Secondary alcohols give ketones; only primary alcohols and aldehydes give acids with the same carbon count.
- Writing aldehydes as the product of ozonolysis with . Oxidative work-up gives carboxylic acids; Zn/ gives aldehydes.
- Turning every carbon of a C=C into -COOH. A carbon gives a ketone, and a carbon gives .
- Chlorinating toluene before oxidising it when the meta product is required. Oxidise first so the -COOH group directs meta.
Frequently Asked Questions
What are the main methods for the preparation of carboxylic acids?
The main methods are oxidation of primary alcohols and aldehydes, side-chain oxidation of alkylbenzenes, carbonation of Grignard reagents, hydrolysis of nitriles, hydrolysis of acid derivatives such as esters and amides, and oxidative cleavage of alkenes and alkynes.
Which methods increase the number of carbon atoms in a carboxylic acid?
Carbonation of a Grignard reagent and hydrolysis of a nitrile made from an alkyl halide each add one carbon. Oxidation of primary alcohols or aldehydes and hydrolysis of esters, amides or acid chlorides keep the same count. Side-chain oxidation keeps only one carbon of each side chain, so a chain longer than methyl loses carbons. Oxidative cleavage of an open-chain alkene or alkyne also gives acids with fewer carbons.
Why is tert-butylbenzene not oxidised to benzoic acid by KMnO4?
Side-chain oxidation starts by removing a hydrogen from the benzylic carbon, the carbon joined to the ring. In tert-butylbenzene that carbon carries three methyl groups and no hydrogen, so the oxidation cannot begin and the side chain stays intact.
Why can't a Grignard reagent be used if the molecule has an -OH or -COOH group?
A Grignard reagent is a very strong base. It removes the acidic hydrogen of -OH, -NH or -COOH at once, turning R-MgX into the alkane R-H before it can react with carbon dioxide. It also adds to C=O groups and reacts with nitro groups, so such groups must be absent or protected.
What is the difference between acidic and basic hydrolysis of nitriles?
Acidic hydrolysis gives the free carboxylic acid and ammonium ion directly. Basic hydrolysis gives the carboxylate salt and ammonia gas, so the solution must be acidified afterwards to obtain the acid. Both pass through an amide intermediate.
Can ketones be oxidised to carboxylic acids?
Not with mild reagents such as Tollens' or Fehling's. Strong oxidising agents with heat break the carbon-carbon bonds next to the keto group, giving a mixture of acids with fewer carbons. The Properties and Important Reactions of Aldehydes and Ketones page teaches the oxidation of ketones.
Which preparation methods are most important for JEE Main and JEE Advanced?
Of six past JEE questions on these methods, nitrile hydrolysis appears in four and the Grignard route in three. Side-chain oxidation of alkylbenzenes and oxidation of aldehydes appear in two each. Jones oxidation of a primary alcohol and hydrolysis of acid derivatives appear once each, inside a sequence of steps. Keep a carbon-count check for every step.
Which preparation of carboxylic acids reactions are asked in NEET?
NEET follows NCERT: preparation from primary alcohols and aldehydes, alkylbenzenes, nitriles and amides, Grignard reagents, acyl halides and anhydrides, and esters. Its questions on these methods asked for the salt that a Grignard reagent forms with carbon dioxide, and used nitrile hydrolysis inside a sequence of steps.