Properties of Carboxylic acids
Properties of carboxylic acids come from the -COOH group. Strong intermolecular hydrogen bonding makes them form dimers and boil higher than alcohols, while resonance stabilisation of the carboxylate ion makes them the most acidic common organic compounds ( to 5). Chemically, carboxylic acids react at the O-H bond (salts, fizzing with ), at the C-OH bond (acid chlorides, esters, amides, anhydrides), at the carboxyl carbon (reduction, decarboxylation) and at the -carbon (HVZ reaction). In JEE Main, two kinds of question on these properties are the most common. They ask for the order of acid strength, or about the reaction with . NEET has also asked for the order of acid strength.
- , ,
- ★ Must learn Acidity: RCOOH > > > > ROH > HC≡CH > > RH
- ★ Must learn Electron-withdrawing groups raise acidity: > > >
- ★ Must learn (test for -COOH)
- ★ Must learn
- ( does not reduce -COOH)
- (one carbon less)
- (Kolbe electrolysis)
- ★ Must learn (HVZ, needs an -H)
1. Physical Properties of Carboxylic Acids
Aliphatic carboxylic acids with up to nine carbon atoms are colourless liquids with unpleasant smells. The higher acids are wax-like solids. They are almost odourless, because they hardly evaporate. Acids with 12 to 18 carbon atoms are called fatty acids. They occur in natural fats as esters of glycerol.
Solubility
Carboxylic acids are polar and form hydrogen bonds with water, so the lower members (up to about four carbons) are miscible with water. As the size of the alkyl group increases, the solubility of the acid decreases because the non-polar part grows and the overall polarity is reduced. Benzoic acid is almost insoluble in cold water.
Carboxylic acids also dissolve in less polar organic solvents, such as benzene, ether, alcohol and chloroform.
Boiling points
Because of intermolecular hydrogen bonding, carboxylic acid molecules pair up into dimers, so the boiling point of a carboxylic acid is higher than expected. The effective molecular mass of the dimer is double the actual mass, and the hydrogen bonds in acids are stronger than in alcohols. Hence carboxylic acids have higher boiling points than alcohols of comparable molecular mass.
They also boil higher than aldehydes and ketones of similar mass. The hydrogen bonds are not broken completely even in the vapour. Most carboxylic acids exist as dimers in the vapour phase and in aprotic solvents (solvents with no O-H or N-H bond, such as benzene).
Melting points
The melting points of aliphatic carboxylic acids do not show a regular pattern. The first ten members show an alternation effect: the melting point of an acid with an even number of carbon atoms is higher than those of the next lower and next higher homologues with an odd number of carbon atoms.
In even-carbon acids, the terminal methyl group and the carboxyl group lie on opposite sides of the zig-zag carbon chain, so the molecules fit better in the crystal lattice and intermolecular forces are stronger. In odd-carbon acids, both groups lie on the same side, the molecules fit poorly and the melting point is relatively lower.
Aromatic carboxylic acids have higher melting and boiling points than aliphatic acids of comparable molecular mass, because the planar benzene ring lets the molecules pack closely in the crystal.
2. How Carboxylic Acids React
The characteristic chemical behaviour of carboxylic acids is determined by the carboxyl group, -COOH, which is made up of a carbonyl group (C=O) and a hydroxyl group (-OH). It is the -OH that actually undergoes nearly every reaction, by loss of or by replacement with another group, but it does so in a way that is possible only because of the effect of the C=O.
- (a) Removal of : the O-H bond breaks when the acid reacts with a base.
- (b) C-O bond cleavage: -OH is replaced by -Cl or using , , or .
- (c) Nucleophilic attack at the carboxyl carbon: as in ester formation. Replacement of -OH by or -Cl is a substitution at this carbon.
- (d) Halogenation at the -carbon: with P/ (Hell-Volhard-Zelinsky reaction).
The main reactions are summarised in the map below and explained section by section.
3. Acidity of Carboxylic Acids
The acidity of a carboxylic acid is due to the resonance stabilisation of its anion. Both the acid and its anion are stabilised by resonance, but the stabilisation is far greater for the anion, because the anion has two identical resonating structures while the acid's structures are not equivalent. Because of this resonance, both carbon-oxygen bonds in the carboxylate anion have identical bond lengths; in the carboxylic acid they are not identical.
The strength of an acid is shown by its acid dissociation constant, , or more simply by . The smaller the , the stronger the acid.
Some values: HCl ; 0.23 (the strongest carboxylic acid); 4.19; 4.76.
Bands of : strong acids below 1; moderately strong acids 1 to 5; weak acids 5 to 15; extremely weak acids above 15.
So carboxylic acids are weaker than mineral acids such as HCl. They are stronger than alcohols ( about 16 for ethanol) and than most simple phenols (about 10 for phenol).
Why are they stronger than phenols? The carboxylate ion has two equivalent resonance structures, and in both the negative charge sits on an oxygen atom. The phenoxide ion has non-equivalent structures, and in most of them the charge sits on a ring carbon, which is less electronegative. So the carboxylate ion spreads its charge over two oxygen atoms, while the phenoxide ion spreads it less well. The carboxylate ion is the more stable ion, and the carboxylic acid is the stronger acid.
Effect of substituents on acidity
The acidity of a carboxylic acid depends strongly on the substituent attached to the -COOH group. Since acidity comes from resonance stabilisation of the anion, any substituent that stabilises the anion increases acidity, and any substituent that destabilises it decreases acidity. An electron-withdrawing group ( effect) disperses the negative charge of the anion and makes it more stable, increasing acidity. An electron-releasing group ( effect) intensifies the negative charge, makes the anion less stable and decreases acidity. On this basis:
- Number of halogens: more halogen atoms on the -carbon give a stronger acid: > > > .
- Distance of halogen: the inductive effect decreases with distance, so 2-chlorobutanoic acid > 3-chlorobutanoic acid > 4-chlorobutanoic acid.
- Electronegativity of halogen: > > > .
- Electron-releasing alkyl groups: acidity falls as the effect grows: > > .
- Hybridisation of the carbon joined to -COOH: an sp carbon is the most electronegative, then sp, then sp: ( 1.84) > (4.25) > (4.88). A phenyl or vinyl group joined directly to -COOH therefore raises acidity. This is the opposite of what its resonance with the C=O group would suggest.
Groups raise acid strength in this increasing order. The acids below are ranked by their values:
Effect of the group: Ph < I < Br < Cl < F < CN < <
Acid strength, strongest first: > > > > > > > > HCOOH > > > > >
Groups on the ring of benzoic acid work the same way. An electron-withdrawing group raises acidity, and an electron-donating group lowers it. In increasing acid strength: 4-methoxybenzoic acid ( 4.46) < benzoic acid (4.19) < 4-nitrobenzoic acid (3.41).
Rank acids in 10 seconds.
Ask three questions in order: (1) Is there a group, and how many? (2) How close is it to -COOH ( beats beats )? (3) How electronegative is it (F > Cl > Br > I)? Alkyl groups work the opposite way and weaken the acid.
(A)
(B)
(C)
(D)
Answer: (B). The strongest acid ionises the most. Compare the groups by position, nature and number.
Position: in (C) the F atom is on the carbon farthest from -COOH. The effect fades with distance, so (C) is the weakest acid.
Nature: (A) and (D) each have one halogen on the -carbon. F is more electronegative than Br, so (D) is stronger than (A).
Number: (B) has two F atoms on the -carbon. Two strong groups spread the negative charge of the anion best.
Order of acid strength: (C) < (A) < (D) < (B). So (B), 2,2-difluoropentanoic acid, ionises the most.
(i) < HCOOH < (the methyl group is ; Cl is )
(ii) < < (more alkyl groups, more )
(iii) < < (more chlorines)
(iv) < < < <
(v) < < < <
A group that spreads the negative charge of the carboxylate ion makes the acid stronger. A group that pushes more negative charge towards it makes the acid weaker.
(a) The -CN group withdraws electrons in two ways. Its effect pulls electrons through the bonds. Its effect pulls electrons out of the ring towards the N atom.
At the para position, the effect puts a partial positive charge on the ring carbon that carries . This positive charge attracts the negative charge of and stabilises the anion. So 4-cyanobenzoic acid is the stronger acid.
(b) N is more electronegative than C, so has a small effect. But the lone pair on N is pushed into the ring: the effect.
At the para position, the effect puts extra negative charge on the ring carbon that carries . More negative charge near destabilises the anion. The effect is much larger than the effect, so 4-aminobenzoic acid is the weaker acid.
(A) About 99% of the acid is ionised in X and about 1% in Y.
(B) About 50% of the acid is ionised in both.
(C) The acid is fully ionised in both, because it is an acid.
(D) About 1% of the acid is ionised in X and about 99% in Y.
Answer: (D). Write formic acid as HA and the formate ion as . Rearrange the expression for :
In X, the pH is 2 units below the . The ratio is , so only 1 molecule in 101 is ionised (about 1%). The high concentration pushes the equilibrium back towards HA.
In Y, the pH is 2 units above the . The ratio is , so 100 molecules in 101 are ionised (about 99%).
Below its , an acid stays mostly unionised. Above its , it is mostly present as the anion.
Ortho effect in aromatic acids
An ortho-substituted benzoic acid is a stronger acid than its meta and para isomers, whether the substituent is electron-withdrawing or electron-releasing. This is called the ortho effect. It comes from the joint action of steric effects and intramolecular hydrogen bonding, which stabilise the carboxylate anion because the substituent is so close. Groups such as -OH, -Cl and give extra stabilisation through direct interaction, such as intramolecular hydrogen bonding in the salicylate ion.
Maleic acid and fumaric acid
Hydrogen bonding that involves the acidic hydrogen weakens an acid, while hydrogen bonding in the conjugate base strengthens it. Both effects appear in the two isomeric butenedioic acids.
Both dicarboxylic acids have two ionisable hydrogen atoms. Consider the second ionisation step. In the maleate monoanion, the remaining ionisable hydrogen takes part in an intramolecular hydrogen bond with the neighbouring group. More energy is needed to remove this hydrogen because the hydrogen bond must be broken, so the maleate monoanion is the weaker acid. The fumarate monoanion (trans) cannot form this hydrogen bond, so its is larger.
After the first ionisation of the cis acid, the anion is stabilised by an intramolecular hydrogen bond from the second -COOH group, which lies on the same side as . The anion from the trans acid cannot be stabilised this way, because its -COOH group is on the opposite side. A more stable anion means easier ionisation, so (maleic) > (fumaric).
The ranking rules as a flowchart:
4. Salt Formation
Carboxylic acids are weak acids, and their carboxylate anions are weak conjugate bases. Solutions of their salts are slightly alkaline because the carboxylate anion is hydrolysed. Compared with other species, the orders of acidity and of basicity of the corresponding conjugate bases are:
Acidity: RCOOH > HOH > ROH > HC≡CH > > RH
Basicity: < < < < <
Carboxylic acids react with active metals to liberate hydrogen, and they dissolve in both NaOH and solutions.
Here zinc acetate and sodium laurate (from lauric acid) are formed. Benzoic acid similarly gives sodium benzoate with . Carboxylic acids also react with basic oxides and carbonates:
A mineral acid is stronger than a carboxylic acid, so it frees the carboxylic acid from its salt. Sodium acetate warmed with dilute gives acetic acid. Its vapour smells of vinegar and turns blue litmus red.
(i) Fizzing with shows a -COOH group, so A is . Four acids fit: pentanoic, 2-methylbutanoic, 3-methylbutanoic and 2,2-dimethylpropanoic acid.
(ii) Soda lime replaces -COONa by H, so the alkane is . Only pentanoic acid and 2-methylbutanoic acid give butane, . The other two give 2-methylpropane.
(iii) With excess bromine, the HVZ reaction replaces every -hydrogen. Pentanoic acid has two -H atoms, so it would take up two Br atoms. 2-Methylbutanoic acid has only one -H.
A is 2-methylbutanoic acid, . Its HVZ product is 2-bromo-2-methylbutanoic acid.
Which of phenol and benzoic acid gives effervescence with ?
Why is a solution of sodium acetate slightly alkaline?
5. Conversion into Functional Derivatives
The -OH of a carboxylic acid can be replaced by Z = -Cl, -OR' or to give acid chlorides, esters and amides; removing water between two acid molecules gives an anhydride.
(a) Conversion into acid chlorides
Carboxylic acids react with thionyl chloride, phosphorus trichloride or phosphorus pentachloride to give acid chlorides.
Why is preferred.
With both by-products, and HCl, are gases that escape, so the acid chloride is obtained pure without separating or .
(A) ,
(B)
(C)
(D) ,
Replacing -OH by -Cl needs a reagent such as , or . Chlorine alone cannot convert -COOH into -COCl. Answer: (C)
(b) Conversion into esters (esterification)
A carboxylic acid reacts with an alcohol to give an ester. It needs an acid catalyst (conc. or dry HCl gas). Phenols react too, though less readily. The reaction is known as esterification.
This reaction is reversible, and the same catalyst () that catalyses esterification necessarily catalyses the reverse reaction, hydrolysis. The equilibrium is particularly unfavourable when phenols (ArOH) are used instead of alcohols; yet if water is removed during the reaction, phenolic esters (RCOOAr) are obtained in high yield. A bulky group near the site of reaction, in either the alcohol or the acid, slows down esterification (and its reverse, hydrolysis).
Reactivity of alcohols: > 1° > 2° > 3°
Reactivity of acids: HCOOH > > > >
Mechanism. The steps for forming an ester from an acid and an alcohol are the reverse of the steps for acid-catalysed hydrolysis of an ester, so the reaction can go either way depending on the conditions. A carboxylic acid does not react with an alcohol unless a strong acid is used as a catalyst: protonation makes the carbonyl group more electrophilic and lets it react with the alcohol, which is a weak nucleophile.
- Protonation of the carbonyl oxygen of the acid.
- Nucleophilic attack of the alcohol on the carbonyl carbon, giving a tetrahedral intermediate.
- Proton transfer to one of the -OH groups, turning it into , a good leaving group.
- Loss of water, giving the protonated ester.
- Loss of , giving the ester and regenerating the catalyst.
These give methyl benzoate, benzyl acetate and ethyl trimethylacetate. For a crowded acid such as trimethylacetic acid, the acid chloride route avoids the slow direct esterification.
With excess methanol and acid catalyst, both -COOH groups are esterified. A is the diester
In esterification, the acid loses its whole -OH group, and the alcohol loses only the H of its -OH.
Follow the steps. protonates the C=O oxygen of the acid. The O atom of ethanol attacks the carbonyl carbon, giving a tetrahedral intermediate. After a proton shift, that carbon carries two groups and one group.
A proton moves onto one group, which is lost as . The other becomes the C=O oxygen of the ester.
So each molecule of the ester, ethyl propanoate, holds one , in its C=O group. The water formed holds the other . The oxygen of the ester's group comes from ethanol.
RCOOH + R'OH with , heat.
Reversible: use excess alcohol or remove water. Slow for crowded acids and 3° alcohols.
RCOOH + , then R'OH with pyridine.
Fast and not reversible. Suits crowded acids such as 2,2-dimethylpropanoic acid.
Diazomethane. RCOOH + in ether gives only methyl esters. The reaction is fast, and it cannot reverse because escapes.
Isotope labelling proves acyl-oxygen cleavage. When acetic acid is esterified with methanol labelled with oxygen-18, the label ends up in the ester, and the water formed contains ordinary oxygen:
+ +
So the acid loses its -OH and the alcohol loses only its H, exactly as the tetrahedral-intermediate mechanism predicts.
Esters of tertiary alcohols can instead break the alkyl-oxygen bond through a carbocation.
(c) Conversion into amides
Amides are usually made through the acid chloride, which reacts readily with ammonia.
Here phenylacetic acid gives phenylacetyl chloride and then phenylacetamide. An acid can also be heated with ammonia or an amine: the ammonium salt forms first and loses water on strong heating.
Phthalic acid reacts with ammonia in the same way. Ammonium phthalate loses water on heating and gives phthalamide. Strong heating then removes ammonia and gives phthalimide, a cyclic imide. Phthalimide is the reagent of the Gabriel synthesis on the Preparation of Amines page.
Both kinds of compound react first in the same way. The nucleophile adds to the carbonyl carbon, and the electrons of C=O move onto oxygen. A tetrahedral intermediate with a negatively charged oxygen forms.
The next step depends on the other groups on that carbon. In an aldehyde or ketone, these are H atoms or alkyl groups. and are very strong bases, so they are very poor leaving groups.
The negatively charged oxygen therefore takes up a proton. The tetrahedral product stays, and the overall change is nucleophilic addition.
In an acyl compound, the carbonyl carbon also carries -Cl, -OCOR, -OR' or . The first three are lost as , or , much weaker bases than or . The group is lost as , after it takes up a proton.
The oxygen uses its lone pair to form the C=O bond again, and the group is lost. The nucleophile now sits in its place, so the overall change is substitution.
Acyl substitution is therefore addition followed by elimination. It happens only because the acyl compound carries a group that can be lost.
(d) Conversion into anhydrides
A carboxylic acid heated with a mineral acid such as conc. , or with , loses a water molecule between two acid molecules to form an anhydride. Dicarboxylic acids that can form five- or six-membered rings give cyclic anhydrides simply on heating.
(A) hexanoic acid
(B) pentanoic acid
(C) propanoic acid
(D) 2-methylpentanedioic acid
Answer: (C). removes one molecule of water from two molecules of a monocarboxylic acid. So the anhydride formula is twice the acid formula, minus .
For , the two acid molecules together are . One acid molecule is , which is propanoic acid. The product is propanoic anhydride.
Hexanoic acid gives , and pentanoic acid gives . 2-Methylpentanedioic acid, , loses one within one molecule, giving .
6. Reduction of Carboxylic Acids
Lithium aluminium hydride reduces carboxylic acids to primary alcohols. Diborane () does it even better.
Hydrolysis of the aluminium alkoxide then gives neopentyl alcohol, (2,2-dimethylpropan-1-ol). In the same way, m-toluic acid is reduced to m-methylbenzyl alcohol.
Diborane does not easily reduce an ester, nitro or halo group. So in a molecule that carries both -COOH and an ester, diborane reduces only the -COOH. would reduce both groups.
and diborane () reduce -COOH to . does not reduce carboxylic acids, so it can reduce a ketone in the same molecule while leaving -COOH untouched.
Route 1:
Route 2:
Identify X and Y. Which of P, X and Y give with ?
Diborane reduces -COOH to , but it does not easily reduce an ester group. So only the acid group of P changes.
X is methyl 4-(hydroxymethyl)benzoate.
is a stronger reducing agent. It reduces -COOH to . It also reduces the ester to two alcohols: a second on the ring, and .
Y is [4-(hydroxymethyl)phenyl]methanol.
Only P has a -COOH group, so only P gives with . X and Y have no -COOH group. does not reduce -COOH, so it could not have given X.
Which reagents reduce -COOH to ?
What does give with ?
7. Reactions Involving Loss of the -COOH Group
(a) Decarboxylation with soda lime
Sodium salts of carboxylic acids are heated with soda lime (NaOH and CaO in the ratio 3 : 1). They give hydrocarbons with one carbon atom less than the parent acid.
For example, sodium benzoate, , gives benzene, , on heating with soda lime.
The disodium salt of a dicarboxylic acid loses both carboxyl groups in the same way. Disodium butanedioate (sodium succinate) gives ethane.
A is and D is . Identify A to D. Why does D have the same number of carbon atoms as the starting bromide?
Cyanide replaces Br in an reaction, adding one carbon. A is cyclohexylacetonitrile, .
Acid hydrolysis turns -CN into -COOH. B is cyclohexylacetic acid, .
NaOH gives the salt. C is sodium cyclohexylacetate, .
Soda lime removes the carboxyl carbon as and puts H in its place. D is methylcyclohexane, .
The cyanide step adds one carbon, and soda lime removes one carbon. So D has seven carbons, like the bromide: overall, the Br atom has been replaced by H.
(b) Hunsdiecker reaction
The silver salt of a carboxylic acid heated with bromine in gives an alkyl bromide with one carbon less. The reaction proceeds by a free-radical chain mechanism.
(c) Schmidt reaction
A carboxylic acid reacts with hydrazoic acid () in conc. to give a primary amine with one carbon less. The Preparation of Amines page explains this Schmidt reaction.
(d) Reaction with organometallic compounds
A Grignard reagent only removes the acidic proton, giving the salt and an alkane.
D gives back B with dilute acid. What volume of C, at STP, forms from 1.02 g of B? Take 22.4 L as the volume of 1 mol of gas at STP.
A is the Grignard reagent butylmagnesium bromide, .
A adds to , and acid then gives a carboxylic acid with one more carbon. B is pentanoic acid, .
A Grignard reagent is a very strong base. With a carboxylic acid, it only removes the acidic H of -COOH. The methyl group takes this H, so the gas C is methane.
D is the salt . Even excess does not attack this carboxylate ion, so dilute acid simply gives back B.
Numerical: the molar mass of B, , is 102 . Moles of B = 1.02/102 = 0.0100 mol. Each -COOH gives one , so 0.0100 mol of methane forms.
(e) Easy decarboxylation of -keto acids
The loss of from a carboxylic acid is favoured by the stability of carbon dioxide, but it is usually slow. Some groups make it rapid. Acids with a carbonyl group on the -carbon (-keto acids) decarboxylate readily when heated to 100 to 150 °C.
Two facts explain the ease. First, when the carboxylate ion decarboxylates, it forms a resonance-stabilised enolate anion, much more stable than the anion formed from an ordinary carboxylate. Second, the free acid can decarboxylate through a six-membered cyclic transition state. The same happens for when Y = OH (malonic acid) or H (-aldehydo acid).
(f) Kolbe electrolysis
Electrolysis of a concentrated aqueous solution of the sodium or potassium salt of a carboxylic acid also removes -COOH, but the alkyl radicals formed at the anode pair up. The hydrocarbon has twice the number of carbon atoms in the alkyl group of the acid.
At the anode: , then and . Hydrogen and NaOH form at the cathode. Sodium acetate gives ethane:
RCOONa + NaOH (CaO), heat.
Product R-H: one carbon fewer than the acid.
Aqueous RCOONa, electrolysis.
Product R-R: twice the carbons of R (acetate gives ethane).
(A) 3-methylpentane
(B) sodium 3-methylbutanoate
(C) 2-methylpropane
(D) butane
Answer: (C). Soda lime replaces each -COONa group by H. With excess soda lime, both groups are removed, as two .
The six-carbon salt loses two carbons, giving the four-carbon branched alkane 2-methylpropane. Option (B) has lost only one group. Option (A) keeps all six carbons, and option (D) has an unbranched chain.
(A) Decane and form at the anode; forms at the cathode.
(B) Decane forms at the cathode; and form at the anode.
(C) Pentane and form at the anode; forms at the cathode.
(D) Dodecane and form at the anode; forms at the cathode.
Answer: (A). At the anode, each hexanoate ion loses an electron. The radical formed loses and gives a pentyl radical, . Two pentyl radicals join to give decane.
At the cathode, water takes up electrons: . So NaOH stays in the solution.
The alkane has twice the five carbons of the alkyl group. Pentane, with one carbon fewer than the acid, is the soda-lime product. Dodecane wrongly doubles all six carbons of the acid.
8. Substitution in the Alkyl Chain
Hell-Volhard-Zelinsky (HVZ) reaction
In the presence of phosphorus, aliphatic carboxylic acids react smoothly with chlorine or bromine to give a compound in which an -hydrogen has been replaced by halogen. The reaction does not stop at monosubstitution; with excess halogen, all -hydrogens are replaced.
The function of phosphorus is to convert a little of the acid into the acid halide, and it is the acid halide, not the acid itself, that is halogenated. The acid halide enolises much more readily than the acid, and the enol attacks the halogen.
The halogen of these halogenated acids undergoes nucleophilic displacement and elimination just as it does in simple alkyl halides. Halogenation is therefore the first step in converting a carboxylic acid into many important substituted acids.
The first two equations give an -amino acid and an -hydroxy acid; the last converts isovaleric acid into -bromoisovaleric acid.
(A) 2,2-dimethylpropanoic acid
(B) propanoic acid
(C) acetic acid
(D) 2-methylpropanoic acid
The HVZ reaction replaces an -hydrogen. 2,2-Dimethylpropanoic acid, , has no hydrogen on its -carbon. Answer: (A)
(A) cyclohexanecarboxylic acid,
(B) 2-chloropropanoic acid,
(C) 2-phenylpropanoic acid,
(D) 2,2-dichloropropanoic acid,
Answer: (D). The HVZ reaction replaces a hydrogen on the -carbon, the carbon joined to -COOH. So the acid needs at least one -H.
In (A), the ring carbon joined to -COOH carries one H. In (B), the -carbon still carries one H beside its Cl. In (C), the -carbon carries one H beside and . All three react.
In (D), the -carbon carries two Cl atoms and a group, and no H. The H atoms of are on the -carbon, which the HVZ reaction does not touch.
(A) acetyl chloride
(B) methyl chloride
(C) trichloroacetic acid
(D) chloral hydrate
Red phosphorus turns a little of the acid into acetyl chloride. Its enol form reacts with chlorine at the -carbon. The -hydrogens are replaced one after another. With excess chlorine all three are replaced, giving . Answer: (C)
The HVZ reaction puts one Br atom on the -carbon of A. B has no chiral carbon, so its -carbon must carry two identical groups besides Br and -COOH.
So A has the form with two identical R groups. The rest of the formula, , makes up the two R groups, so each R is ethyl.
Each of the other seven acids gives a chiral B, or no B at all. (2,2-Dimethylbutanoic acid has no -H.)
A = 2-ethylbutanoic acid, . B = 2-bromo-2-ethylbutanoic acid, .
Alcoholic KOH removes HBr by E2: a -H on one is lost together with Br. The two ethyl groups are alike, so only one alkene forms.
Acid then frees the carboxylic acid. C = 2-ethylbut-2-enoic acid, .
One carbon of the C=C carries H and ; the other carries and -COOH. Each carbon has two different groups, so C shows geometrical isomerism.
(a) Name A and B. (b) Why is excess ammonia used? (c) Is the leucine made this way optically active?
(a) The HVZ reaction puts Br on the -carbon. Ammonia then replaces the Br by . So A is leucine without its group.
A = 4-methylpentanoic acid, . B = 2-bromo-4-methylpentanoic acid, .
(b) Each substitution uses a second to take up the HBr, as . A large excess also makes each bromo acid more likely to meet than an amino acid already formed. So the main product stays the -amino acid.
(c) No. The -carbon of B becomes chiral in the HVZ step, with nothing to favour one form. So B is a 50:50 mixture of its two mirror-image forms (racemic). The leucine made from it is racemic too, so it is optically inactive.
Oxidation at the - and -carbon
These notes leave out the reagents that oxidise an acid at its - or -carbon.
9. Ring Substitution in Aromatic Acids
The -COOH group deactivates the benzene ring and directs an incoming electrophile to the meta position, so nitration of benzoic acid gives m-nitrobenzoic acid.
Bromination with and likewise gives m-bromobenzoic acid.
Aromatic carboxylic acids do not undergo the Friedel-Crafts reaction. The -COOH group deactivates the ring, and the Lewis acid catalyst () binds to the carboxyl oxygen instead of generating the electrophile.
Hot alkaline oxidises the whole side chain of an alkylbenzene to -COOH. This needs an H (or a C=O) on the carbon joined to the ring, and ethylbenzene has two H atoms there. The extra carbon leaves as . Acidifying frees the acid from its salt. A is benzoic acid, .
The -COOH group pulls electrons out of the ring. Its resonance puts a partial positive charge on the ortho and para carbons. The meta carbons are the least electron-poor, so the electrophile attacks there. B is 3-bromobenzoic acid (m-bromobenzoic acid).
Soda lime replaces -COONa by H. C is bromobenzene, .
10. Effect of Heat on Dicarboxylic, Hydroxy and Halo Acids
| Dicarboxylic acid | On heating |
|---|---|
| Oxalic acid, HOOC-COOH | HCOOH + ; with conc. : CO + + |
| Malonic acid, | + (-carbonyl decarboxylation; beyond the JEE Main and NEET syllabus) |
| Succinic acid, | Succinic anhydride (5-membered ring) + |
| Glutaric acid, | Glutaric anhydride (6-membered ring) + |
Hydroxy acids behave according to the distance between -OH and -COOH, as the figure below shows. A -hydroxy acid, or its ester, closes a five-membered ring, a lactone.
With aqueous NaOH, an -halo acid gives the -hydroxy acid (as its anion), as in the HVZ section.
Halo acids with the halogen further from -COOH react in other ways. The product depends on the substrate. In simple cases, a -halo acid undergoes elimination (E2) and gives the -unsaturated acid (as its anion). A -halo acid closes a ring: its carboxylate ion displaces the halide ion () and gives a -lactone.
(i) 2-methylbutanedioic acid,
(ii) 2-methylpentanedioic acid,
(iii) benzene-1,4-dicarboxylic acid (terephthalic acid)
Which of them give a cyclic anhydride? Give the ring size of each anhydride, and explain.
A cyclic anhydride forms when the two -COOH groups of one molecule lose a water molecule between them. The ring holds both carbonyl carbons, the oxygen between them and the carbons that join them.
(i) Two carbons join the -COOH groups, so the ring has 2 + 2 + 1 = 5 atoms. A five-membered ring has little strain and closes easily. The product is 3-methyloxolane-2,5-dione (methylsuccinic anhydride).
(ii) Three carbons join the -COOH groups, so the ring has 6 atoms. A six-membered ring also closes easily, giving 3-methyloxane-2,6-dione (2-methylglutaric anhydride), .
(iii) No cyclic anhydride forms. The two -COOH groups sit at opposite ends of the flat, rigid benzene ring. They are too far apart to meet, so no small ring can close.
(a) 6-methyloxan-2-one (six-membered lactone with next to the ring O)
(b) 4-methyloxan-2-one
(c) oxan-2-one
(d) 5-hydroxyhexanal
reduces only the keto group, giving 5-hydroxyhexanoic acid,
11. Abnormal Behaviour of Formic Acid
Formic acid, H-CO-OH, behaves differently from other carboxylic acids because its carboxyl carbon also carries a hydrogen, so it contains an aldehyde-like H-C=O unit. It therefore acts as a reducing agent, unlike acetic acid and most other carboxylic acids. It gives a silver mirror with Tollens' reagent and a red precipitate of with Fehling's solution.
Concentrated removes water from formic acid and gives carbon monoxide. Oxalic acid gives carbon monoxide, carbon dioxide and water in the same way.
(a) Conc. removes water from both acids. The water stays in the sulphuric acid, so only CO and come off as gases.
(b) Moles of HCOOH = 1.84/46 = 0.0400 mol. Moles of oxalic acid = 1.80/90 = 0.0200 mol.
CO = 0.0400 + 0.0200 = 0.0600 mol. = 0.0200 mol. Total gas = 0.0800 mol.
(c) KOH absorbs the acidic gas : . CO is a neutral gas, so it passes through.
Formic or acetic acid?
Both fizz with , but only formic acid gives a silver mirror with Tollens' reagent, a red precipitate with Fehling's solution, and decolourises acidified . Use any of these to tell them apart.
Summary mind map
Which acid does not undergo the HVZ reaction: propanoic or 2,2-dimethylpropanoic acid?
What does formic acid give with conc. ?
Which acid reduces Tollens' reagent?
12. Solved Examples: Exam Practice
(A) ethane
(B) propane
(C) butane
(D) hexane
Answer: (C). The alkyl group of propanoate is ethyl, . Two ethyl radicals join: , butane.
(A)
(B)
(C)
(D)
Answer: (B). The carboxyl group of propynoic acid is joined to an sp carbon, the most electronegative, which stabilises the anion ( 1.84 against 4.25 for acrylic, 4.76 for acetic and 4.88 for propanoic acid).
For a weak acid, .
pH . Degree of ionisation , so only about 1.3% of the molecules are ionised.
Each -COOH releases one ; the alcoholic -OH does not react. Citric acid has three -COOH groups, so 3 mol of are released.
- Arrange in increasing acidity: , , .Answer: (4.76) < (4.19) < (3.75)
- Complete: + →Answer: + + HCl
- What is formed when sodium butanoate is heated with soda lime?Answer: propane
- with /red P, then water, gives?Answer: 2-bromopropanoic acid
- Name the product of nitrating benzoic acid.Answer: 3-nitrobenzoic acid (m-nitrobenzoic acid)
- What does malonic acid give on heating? (Beyond the JEE Main and NEET syllabus.)Answer: acetic acid and
- Which hydrocarbon forms at the anode in the Kolbe electrolysis of sodium acetate?Answer: ethane (with ); hydrogen forms at the cathode
- Arrange in increasing order of acid strength: 4-chlorobenzoic acid, 4-hydroxybenzoic acid, benzoic acid, 4-ethylbenzoic acid.Answer: 4-hydroxybenzoic acid (4.58) < 4-ethylbenzoic acid (4.35) < benzoic acid (4.19) < 4-chlorobenzoic acid (3.99), in brackets. -OH releases electrons strongly by , and ethyl releases them weakly by . Cl withdraws more by than it releases by .
13. Uses of Carboxylic Acids
- Methanoic acid: used in the rubber, textile, dyeing, leather and electroplating industries.
- Ethanoic acid: used as a solvent, and as vinegar in the food industry.
- Hexanedioic acid (adipic acid): used to make nylon-6,6.
- Esters of benzoic acid: used in perfumery.
- Sodium benzoate: used as a food preservative.
- Higher fatty acids: used to make soaps and detergents.
Common Mistakes to Avoid
- Saying carboxylic acid dimers are held by intramolecular hydrogen bonds. The dimer uses two intermolecular hydrogen bonds.
- Calling carboxylate ions strong bases. Because RCOOH is a fairly strong organic acid, is a weak conjugate base.
- Expecting phenol to fizz with . Phenol ( 10) is weaker than carbonic acid; only carboxylic acids (and stronger acids) release .
- Assuming p-hydroxybenzoic acid is stronger than benzoic acid. The +R effect of para -OH makes it weaker ( 4.58 against 4.19). The ortho isomer (2.97) is stronger. The meta isomer (4.08) is also slightly stronger, because there -OH acts only by its -I effect.
- Using to reduce -COOH. It does not work; use or .
- Forgetting the carbon loss. Soda-lime decarboxylation of a monocarboxylic acid gives a product with one carbon fewer. Kolbe electrolysis gives twice the carbons of the alkyl group.
- Applying HVZ to acids with no -hydrogen, such as HCOOH, , and .
- Mixing up heating products: -hydroxy acids give lactides, -hydroxy acids give -unsaturated acids, -hydroxy acids give -lactones (beyond the JEE Main and NEET syllabus).
- Expecting a Grignard reagent to add to a carboxylic acid. RMgX only removes the acidic proton, giving an alkane and the salt.
Frequently Asked Questions
Why do carboxylic acids have higher boiling points than alcohols of similar mass?
Carboxylic acids form cyclic dimers held by two intermolecular hydrogen bonds, and these hydrogen bonds are stronger than those in alcohols. The dimer behaves like a molecule of double mass, so more energy is needed to boil the acid. Acetic acid boils at 118 °C, propan-1-ol at 97 °C.
Why are carboxylic acids more acidic than alcohols and phenols?
The carboxylate ion has two identical resonance structures that share the negative charge equally between two oxygen atoms. An alkoxide ion has no resonance, and in the phenoxide ion the charge spreads onto less electronegative ring carbons. The better-stabilised carboxylate makes the acid stronger.
How does a chlorine atom affect the acidity of acetic acid?
Chlorine withdraws electrons by the inductive effect, dispersing the negative charge of the carboxylate ion and stabilising it. The pKa falls from 4.76 for acetic acid to 2.86 for chloroacetic acid, and further with each extra chlorine. The effect weakens quickly as the chlorine moves away from -COOH.
What is the ortho effect in benzoic acids?
Almost any substituent in the ortho position makes a benzoic acid more acidic than its meta and para isomers. Steric crowding twists the -COOH out of the ring plane, and groups such as -OH can hydrogen bond to the carboxylate. Salicylic acid (pKa 2.97) is therefore far stronger than benzoic acid.
What is the Hell-Volhard-Zelinsky reaction?
It is the alpha-halogenation of a carboxylic acid with chlorine or bromine in the presence of red phosphorus. Phosphorus forms a little acyl halide, which enolises and reacts with the halogen at the alpha carbon. The acid must have at least one alpha hydrogen.
Why do beta-keto acids lose carbon dioxide so easily?
This is beyond the JEE Main and NEET syllabus. The carboxyl hydrogen is hydrogen bonded to the beta carbonyl oxygen, allowing a six-membered cyclic transition state in which carbon dioxide leaves and an enol forms. The enol quickly tautomerises to a ketone. Acetoacetic acid gives acetone on gentle warming.
Which reactions of carboxylic acids are most important for JEE?
In JEE questions on these properties, two tasks are the most common. One is ranking acids by strength. The other is the reaction with NaHCO3 (the CO2 test and the amount of gas). The HVZ reaction and soda-lime decarboxylation also appear inside multi-step problems.
What properties of carboxylic acids are asked in NEET?
NEET follows NCERT. Its questions on this topic have asked about hydrogen bonding and boiling points, and the order of acid strength. They have also asked what formic acid, oxalic acid and an acetate give with sulphuric acid. Also learn the NaHCO3 test and the formation of acid chlorides, esters, amides and anhydrides. Learn reduction with LiAlH4, decarboxylation, the HVZ reaction and meta substitution in benzoic acid.