FundamentholLog inStart lesson 1 freeBack to app

JEE Main 2025 Jan 22 Shift 2, Chemistry Q13: Resonance & Mesomeric Effect

JEE Main2025Jan 22, Shift 2Chemistry

Learn this concept: Resonance & Mesomeric Effect →

Q.

The most stable carbocation from the following is :

  1. A

    1

  2. B

    2

  3. C

    3

  4. D

    4

Solution
Given
  • Four benzyl cations: p-methoxy (A), m-methoxy (B), p-methyl (C) and unsubstituted benzyl (D).
IdeaA ring substituent that pushes electron density onto the benzylic carbon stabilises the cation. Resonance donation (+M) reaches the benzylic carbon only from the ortho or para position.

Steps

  1. Para methoxy donates strongly

    Option A: para is a strong +M donor. The oxygen lone pair delocalises through the ring onto the benzylic carbon, giving an extra resonance form in which every atom has an octet. This strongly stabilises the cation.

  2. Para methyl donates weakly

    Option C: para donates only weakly, by hyperconjugation and +I. It stabilises the cation, but less than para .

  3. Plain benzyl has ring resonance only

    Option D: the plain benzyl cation has only ring resonance, with no extra help from a substituent.

  4. Meta methoxy destabilises

    Option B: only the electron-withdrawing effect of oxygen operates, so this cation is destabilised.

    Key stepFrom the meta position, the oxygen lone pair cannot delocalise onto the benzylic carbon.
  5. Stability order

    Stability order:

    Stability order of the four benzyl cations with +M, +H and -I labels
AnswerOption A: the p-methoxybenzyl cation is the most stable
TrapTreating the electronegative oxygen of as only electron-withdrawing (), so that para methyl, with hyperconjugation, looks like the best donor, leads to Option C. At the para position the donation of the oxygen lone pair far outweighs its effect.

Concept behind this question

Resonance & Mesomeric EffectNotes, formulas and examples →

More previous year questions on Resonance & Mesomeric Effect

Practice more Chemistry

Concept-wise practice with instant solutions on Fundamenthol.

Start practicing →