FundamentholLog inStart lesson 1 freeBack to app

JEE Main 2025 Jan 29 Shift 2, Chemistry Q5: Resonance & Mesomeric Effect

JEE Main2025Jan 29, Shift 2Chemistry

Learn this concept: Resonance & Mesomeric Effect →

Q.

Which among the following halides will generate the most stable carbocation in Nucleophillic substitution reaction ?

  1. A

    1

  2. B

    2

  3. C

    3

  4. D

    4

Solution
Given
  • Four bromides: allyl bromide (A), benzyl bromide (B), 3-bromocyclohexene (C) and triphenylmethyl bromide (D)
  • Loss of gives a carbocation
IdeaA carbocation is more stable when its positive charge is spread over more atoms by resonance. Each extra conjugated system adds delocalisation.

Steps

  1. Option A: allyl cation

    Allyl bromide gives a primary allyl cation. The charge is shared over two carbons through one C=C bond.

  2. Option B: benzyl cation

    Benzyl bromide gives a benzyl cation. The charge spreads into one benzene ring (the benzylic carbon and the ortho and para positions).

  3. Option C: cyclohexenyl cation

    3-bromocyclohexene gives the cyclohexenyl cation, a secondary allylic cation. The charge is shared between C1 and C3 through the adjacent C=C bond, with some extra help from the ring alkyl groups. It is still delocalised over only one bond.

  4. Option D: trityl cation

    Triphenylmethyl bromide gives the trityl cation. The charge is delocalised into all three benzene rings, giving many resonance structures (ten in total).

  5. Compare the stabilities

    The trityl cation has by far the widest delocalisation of the positive charge, so it is the most stable: is more stable than the benzyl and cyclohexenyl cations, and the primary allyl cation is the least stable of the set.

    Stability order: trityl, benzyl, cyclohexenyl, allyl cations
AnswerOption D: triphenylmethyl bromide
TrapStudents often remember the benzyl cation as the standard example of the most stable carbocation, or think the three phenyl groups make the trityl centre too crowded to ionise. Either belief leads them to benzyl bromide, Option B.

Concept behind this question

Resonance & Mesomeric EffectNotes, formulas and examples →

More previous year questions on Resonance & Mesomeric Effect

Practice more Chemistry

Concept-wise practice with instant solutions on Fundamenthol.

Start practicing →