Analysis of Amines
The analysis of amines answers two questions in the laboratory: is the nitrogen there at all, and is the amine primary, secondary or tertiary? The carbylamine test picks out primary amines, and the Hinsberg test sorts all three classes by solubility. The azo dye test then tells an aromatic primary amine from an aliphatic one. This page covers these tests, the separation of a mixture of amines and the percentage of nitrogen in an amine.
- ★ Must learn Hinsberg: 1° gives (soluble in KOH), 2° gives (insoluble), 3° gives no reaction
- ★ Must learn Carbylamine (1° only):
- ★ Must learn Nitrous acid: 1° aliphatic gives the alcohol and ; 1° aromatic gives at 273-278 K. 2° gives , 3° aromatic a green p-nitroso compound and 3° aliphatic no visible change (beyond the JEE Main and NEET syllabus)
- ★ Must learn Azo dye test (1° aromatic only): with alkaline -naphthol gives an orange-red dye
- Liebermann (2° only): nitrosamine + phenol + conc. gives a blue-green colour, red on dilution (beyond the JEE Main and NEET syllabus)
- Mustard oil test (1° only): , then (beyond the JEE Main and NEET syllabus)
- Tosyl chloride: -toluenesulphonyl chloride, , now replaces benzenesulphonyl chloride and tells 1°, 2° and 3° amines apart in the same way
- Sulphonamide hydrolysis: boiling conc. HCl gives the amine salt, and NaOH then frees the amine
- Aliphatic and simple aryl amines dissolve in dilute HCl as their salts; this shows basic nitrogen
- ★ Must learn Percentage of nitrogen: , for N atoms and molar mass . Lassaigne's test and the estimation of nitrogen are on the Qualitative and Quantitative Analysis page
1. First: Is There Nitrogen?
Before any class test, nitrogen itself is detected by Lassaigne's test, which the Qualitative and Quantitative Analysis page explains.
Aliphatic and simple aryl amines also dissolve in dilute HCl, because they are bases and form soluble salts. A compound that dissolves in acid but not in water, and gives no reaction with , is very likely an amine.
2. Sorting the Classes with Nitrous Acid
Nitrous acid is made in the flask from and HCl, in the cold (273-278 K). The table shows what each class gives. The Properties of Amines page gives the equations.
| Class | What you see | Product |
|---|---|---|
| 1° aliphatic | brisk effervescence of a colourless gas | alcohol + |
| 1° aromatic | clear solution; couples with -naphthol to a dye | |
| 2° (alkyl or aryl)* | a yellow oily layer separates | |
| 3° aliphatic* | no gas, no oil; a clear solution | an ammonium nitrite salt |
| 3° aromatic* | a green solid | p-nitroso compound |
* Beyond the JEE Main and NEET syllabus.
3. The Hinsberg Test
Hinsberg's reagent is benzenesulphonyl chloride, , used with aqueous KOH (or NaOH). It replaces a hydrogen on nitrogen, so the result depends on how many N-H bonds the amine has (Figure 1).
3.1 Primary Amine
One N-H is left on nitrogen. Because two S=O groups pull electron density away, that hydrogen is acidic, so the sulphonamide dissolves in KOH as its potassium salt (Figure 2). Acidifying the clear solution brings the sulphonamide back as a precipitate. For example, ethanamine gives N-ethylbenzenesulphonamide, which is soluble in alkali.
3.2 Secondary Amine
A 2° amine has only one N-H, and the reagent replaces it. So the sulphonamide has no H on nitrogen, and no acidic N-H remains. The sulphonamide is an insoluble solid that does not dissolve in KOH. With N-ethylethanamine, for example, the product is N,N-diethylbenzenesulphonamide.
3.3 Tertiary Amine
There is no N-H at all, so no sulphonamide forms. The amine stays as an insoluble layer or solid and dissolves only when the mixture is acidified, because then it forms its ammonium salt.
| Amine | With + KOH | On acidifying |
|---|---|---|
| 1° | dissolves: clear solution | white precipitate of |
| 2° | insoluble solid separates | no change |
| 3° | no reaction; amine insoluble | dissolves as the ammonium salt |
Hinsberg counts N-H bonds. One N-H left in the product means the amine was 1° (soluble in alkali); no N-H left means it was 2° (insoluble); no product at all means 3°. Hinsberg's reagent is benzenesulphonyl chloride, not benzoyl chloride, a wrong option to watch for.
These days, p-toluenesulphonyl chloride (tosyl chloride) is used in place of benzenesulphonyl chloride. It reacts in the same way, so it also tells 1°, 2° and 3° amines apart, and its products crystallise well. The test has limits. Sulphonamides of 1° amines with long chains dissolve only slowly in alkali. A 3° amine gives no sulphonamide, but it can react slowly with the reagent to give an unstable quaternary salt.
4. The Carbylamine (Isocyanide) Test
Warming an amine with chloroform and alcoholic KOH gives an isocyanide with an extremely unpleasant smell. Only primary amines, aliphatic or aromatic, respond, so this is the quickest test for a 1° amine.
The reactive intermediate is dichlorocarbene, formed from chloroform by -elimination. The amine nitrogen attacks it, and two molecules of HCl are then lost, which is why two N-H bonds are needed (Figure 3).
Benzylamine gives benzyl isocyanide by this reaction. Benzyl bromide and AgCN also give it, as the Properties of Alkyl Halides (Halo Alkanes) & Aryl Halides (Halo Arenes) page explains.
What is Hinsberg's reagent?
Why does the sulphonamide of a 1° amine dissolve in KOH?
What does N-ethylethanamine give with Hinsberg's reagent?
What happens to a 3° amine in the Hinsberg test?
Which amines give the carbylamine test, and why?
5. Colour Tests
5.1 Liebermann Nitroso Reaction: Secondary Amines
A 2° amine gives a yellow oily N-nitrosamine with nitrous acid. Warmed with phenol and conc. , the nitrosamine gives a brown-red colour that turns blue, then green. Water turns it red again, and alkali turns it greenish blue or violet. Primary and tertiary amines do not give this sequence.
5.2 Mustard Oil Test: Primary Amines
A 1° amine and carbon disulphide give a dithiocarbamic acid. Mercuric chloride converts it to an isothiocyanate, which has the pungent smell of mustard oil. Secondary and tertiary amines give no such smell.
5.3 Azo Dye Test: Aromatic Primary Amines
The azo dye test tells an aromatic primary amine from an aliphatic one. The amine is diazotised with and HCl at 273-278 K. Its cold diazonium solution, poured into alkaline -naphthol, gives a brilliant orange-red dye, which no other class gives. An aliphatic amine has already lost its nitrogen as gas, so it gives no dye. The Diazonium Salt page explains the coupling.
and ethanolic KOH, heated.
Every 1° amine, aliphatic or aromatic, gives a foul-smelling isocyanide.
and HCl at 273-278 K, then alkaline -naphthol.
Only a 1° aromatic amine gives the orange-red dye.
6. All the Tests at a Glance
| Test and reagent | What each class gives |
|---|---|
| Nitrous acid /HCl, 273-278 K | 1°: gas (aliphatic) or diazonium salt (aromatic). 2°*: yellow oily nitrosamine. 3°*: no visible change (green solid for 3° aromatic) |
| Carbylamine + alc. KOH | 1°: foul-smelling isocyanide. 2°, 3°: no reaction |
| Hinsberg + KOH | 1°: dissolves; precipitate on acidifying. 2°: insoluble sulphonamide. 3°: no reaction |
| Liebermann* , then phenol and conc. | 1°: no colour. 2°: blue-green, red on dilution. 3°: no colour |
| Mustard oil* , then | 1°: pungent mustard smell. 2°, 3°: no smell |
| Azo dye /HCl, then -naphthol/ | 1°: orange-red dye (aromatic only). 2°, 3°: no dye |
* Beyond the JEE Main and NEET syllabus.
Two tests sort every class. The carbylamine test catches only 1° amines. The Hinsberg test tells all three classes apart in one experiment. Then, to tell an aromatic 1° amine from an aliphatic one, use the azo dye test.
7. Separating a Mixture of Amines
Fractional distillation works when the boiling points are far enough apart, but the usual laboratory method turns each class into a different kind of derivative first (Figure 8).
7.1 Hinsberg Method
The mixture is shaken with benzenesulphonyl chloride and aqueous KOH. The 1° amine dissolves as the potassium salt of its sulphonamide, the 2° amine gives an insoluble sulphonamide that is filtered off, and the 3° amine remains as an unreacted layer. Boiling each sulphonamide with conc. HCl gives the amine as its salt, and NaOH then frees the pure amine.
7.2 Hofmann Method with Diethyl Oxalate
Hofmann's method warms the mixture with diethyl oxalate. A 1° amine gives a solid oxamide, a 2° amine a liquid oxamic ester, and a 3° amine does not react.
How does the azo dye test tell aniline from benzylamine?
Which test tells 1°, 2° and 3° amines apart in one experiment?
In the Hinsberg separation, how is each amine got back?
Do all amines dissolve in dilute HCl?
What is the percentage of nitrogen in aniline, (C 12, H 1, N 14)?
8. Solved Examples
(A) phenyl isocyanide
(B) benzenesulphonyl chloride
(C) p-toluenesulphonic acid
(D) o-dichlorobenzene
Answer: (B). Benzenesulphonyl chloride, , used with aqueous KOH. It is easy to confuse with benzoyl chloride , which acylates amines but does not separate the classes, and with tosyl chloride, the methyl-substituted version that behaves in the same way.
(A) (ii) and (iv)
(B) (ii) and (iii)
(C) (i), (ii) and (iv)
(D) (ii), (iii) and (iv)
Answer: (A). Only primary amines respond, and the class is decided by the nitrogen, not by the ring.
- (i) N,N-dimethylaniline: nitrogen carries two methyl groups and the ring, so it is 3°: no reaction.
- (ii) 2,4-dimethylaniline: the two methyls are on the ring, so the amine is 1° aromatic: positive.
- (iii) N,2-dimethylaniline: one methyl is on nitrogen, so it is 2°: no reaction.
- (iv) (4-methylphenyl)methanamine: on the ring, a 1° aralkyl amine: positive.
(A) dissolves in the alkali, because each nitrogen keeps one acidic N-H
(B) does not dissolve in the alkali, because no N-H is left
(C) is a quaternary ammonium salt
(D) does not form, because a diamine does not react
Answer: (A). Each group is a primary amino group, so each one gives a sulphonamide group, .
Each nitrogen still carries one H next to the sulphonyl group. That H is acidic, so KOH removes it. The product dissolves as its potassium salt, like the sulphonamide of any 1° amine.
Shake the mixture with benzenesulphonyl chloride and aqueous KOH (Figure 8).
- 4-Methylaniline (1°) gives N-(4-methylphenyl)benzenesulphonamide. Its N-H is acidic, so it dissolves in the KOH as its potassium salt.
- N-Methylaniline (2°) gives N-methyl-N-phenylbenzenesulphonamide. It has no N-H, so it stays as an insoluble solid, which is filtered off.
- N,N-Dimethylaniline (3°) does not react. It forms a separate liquid layer, which a separating funnel parts from the alkaline solution.
Acidifying the alkaline solution brings back the 1° sulphonamide as a solid. Boiling each sulphonamide with conc. HCl gives the amine as its salt, and NaOH then sets the amine free.
(A) 4-methylaniline
(B) cyclohexanamine
(C) N-methylcyclohexanamine
(D) N,N-dimethylaniline
Answer: (B). A 1° aliphatic amine gives an unstable diazonium salt, which gives the alcohol and at once. Cyclohexanamine is the only 1° aliphatic amine here.
(A) is a 1° aromatic amine: in the cold it gives a diazonium salt that stays in solution, with no gas. (C) is 2° and (D) is 3°: neither has an group, so neither gives a diazonium ion or .
(A) and a 1° amine
(B) and a 1° amine
(C) and a 3° amine
(D) and a 1° amine
Answer: (A). KOH removes the H of chloroform, and the anion loses to give dichlorocarbene. The 1° amine converts it into the isocyanide (Figure 3).
(B) has no H to remove, so it gives no dichlorocarbene. (C) A 3° amine has no N-H bonds, and the reaction uses up two. (D) only alkylates the amine.
(C) does not dissolve in alkali, so it has no N-H: (B) is a secondary amine. Without the group, has left, which is . A solution acidic to litmus that gives the amine with NaOH is its hydrochloride.
- (A) = dimethylammonium chloride,
- (B) = N-methylmethanamine,
- (C) = N,N-dimethylbenzenesulphonamide,
(B) gives the azo dye, so it is a 1° aromatic amine, . So (A) is an amide, , which acid splits into the amine salt and . Within this fits N-phenylethanamide (from aniline and ethanoic acid) and the three N-(methylphenyl)methanamides (from a methylaniline and methanoic acid). Methanoic acid reduces Tollens' reagent; ethanoic acid does not. So (C) is ethanoic acid.
- (A) = N-phenylethanamide (acetanilide),
- (B) = aniline,
- (C) = ethanoic acid,
(B) is basic and gives the carbylamine test, so it is a primary amine, . Acetylation gives (D), . Without , has left, so (B) is ethanamine. (A) is an amide of ethanamine. Without , has left: the propanoyl group, .
- (A) = N-ethylpropanamide,
- (B) = ethanamine,
- (C) = sodium propanoate,
- (D) = N-ethylethanamide,
Both are primary amines, so both give a positive carbylamine test. Use the azo dye test: diazotise each with /HCl at 273-278 K and pour the solution into alkaline -naphthol.
- Aniline gives a diazonium salt, stable only in the cold, which couples to an orange-red dye.
- Benzylamine is aliphatic: its diazonium ion decomposes at once with brisk , and no dye forms.
The carbylamine test makes (A) primary; the effervescence and the absence of a dye make it aliphatic rather than aromatic. The only primary amine of formula whose nitrogen is not on the ring is benzylamine, .
Shake each with benzenesulphonyl chloride and aqueous KOH (the Hinsberg test).
- The one that dissolves and gives a precipitate on acidifying is ethylamine (1°).
- The one that gives an insoluble solid at once is diethylamine (2°).
- The one that does not react, and dissolves only when the mixture is acidified, is triethylamine (3°).
Confirm if needed: ethylamine alone gives the carbylamine smell.
(b) An amine (X) with a benzene ring contains C 78.5%, H 8.4% and N 13.1% by mass. Its molar mass is 107 g mol-1. (X) gives a sulphonamide that does not dissolve in aqueous KOH. Find the molecular formula of (X) and identify it.
(C 12, H 1, N 14, O 16, S 32)
(a) The formula is . Its molar mass is g mol-1.
(b) Divide each percentage by the atomic mass: C , H , N . Divide each by the smallest, 0.936: C 6.99, H 8.98, N 1. The empirical formula is , with mass . This equals the molar mass, so the molecular formula is .
The sulphonamide does not dissolve in alkali, so (X) is a 2° amine. The only 2° amine with a benzene ring is N-methylaniline, .
The Qualitative and Quantitative Analysis page shows how these percentages are measured.
- Which of these dissolves in aqueous KOH: (a) , (b) , (c) , (d) ?Answer: (a); its N-H, next to the electron-withdrawing sulphonyl group, is acidic, so KOH turns it into a soluble salt. (b) has no N-H, and (c) and (d) are bases
- How would you distinguish (a) methylamine from dimethylamine and (b) aniline from N-methylaniline?Answer: (a) carbylamine test: only methylamine gives the foul-smelling isocyanide; (b) carbylamine test: only aniline, the 1° amine, gives the isocyanide; or the azo dye test: only aniline gives the orange-red dye
- Why does a tertiary amine give no reaction in the carbylamine test?Answer: the reaction needs two N-H bonds, which are lost as two molecules of HCl; a 3° amine has none
- Name Hinsberg's reagent and give the product with a 1°, a 2° and a 3° amine.Answer: benzenesulphonyl chloride; (soluble in KOH), (insoluble) and no product
- Write the reactions of ethylamine with followed by . (Beyond the JEE Main and NEET syllabus.)Answer: gives , and with this gives , the mustard oil smell
- A mixture of aniline and N,N-dimethylaniline is shaken with and aqueous KOH. What happens to each?Answer: aniline dissolves as the potassium salt of its sulphonamide; acidifying and boiling with conc. HCl give anilinium chloride, and NaOH then frees aniline; N,N-dimethylaniline is 3° and stays as an unreacted layer
- Describe the Liebermann nitroso reaction and say which class gives it. (Beyond the JEE Main and NEET syllabus.)Answer: a 2° amine gives a nitrosamine with ; warming this with phenol and conc. gives a brown-red colour that turns blue then green, red on dilution and greenish blue with alkali
- An unknown amine gives a base-insoluble solid in the Hinsberg test. What class is it, and what will it give with ? (Beyond the JEE Main and NEET syllabus.)Answer: a secondary amine; with it gives a yellow oily N-nitrosamine
- Complete: aniline with /HCl at 273-278 K, then alkaline -naphthol.Answer: benzenediazonium chloride couples at C-1 of the naphthol to give the orange-red dye 1-phenylazo-2-naphthol
- How do you tell an aliphatic primary amine from an aromatic primary amine?Answer: treat with in the cold: the aliphatic amine gives brisk and an alcohol, while the aromatic amine gives a diazonium salt, stable only in the cold, that couples with -naphthol to a dye
- Calculate the percentage of nitrogen in ethane-1,2-diamine, (C 12, H 1, N 14).Answer: 46.7%; has a molar mass of 60, and % N = 28/60 × 100 = 46.7
Common Mistakes to Avoid
- Naming benzoyl chloride as Hinsberg's reagent. The reagent is benzenesulphonyl chloride, .
- Expecting a 2° or 3° amine to give the carbylamine test. Two N-H bonds are needed, so only 1° amines respond.
- Saying the carbylamine test works only for aliphatic amines. Aromatic primary amines such as aniline also give it.
- Reading a yellow oil in the nitrous acid test as a 1° amine. The oily nitrosamine means a 2° amine (beyond the JEE Main and NEET syllabus).
- Reporting a 3° amine as 'no reaction' in the Hinsberg test without adding that it dissolves when the mixture is acidified.
- Getting the Hinsberg solubilities the wrong way round. The 1° sulphonamide keeps an acidic N-H and dissolves in KOH; the 2° one has none and stays solid.
- Thinking the Hinsberg separation uses up the amines. Boiling each sulphonamide with conc. HCl gives the 1° or 2° amine salt, and NaOH frees the amine.
- Using the azo dye test on an aliphatic primary amine. Its diazonium salt decomposes at once, so no dye can form.
- Forgetting that the class of an amine is set by the groups on nitrogen. 2,4-Dimethylaniline is a primary amine, because both methyl groups are on the ring.
Frequently Asked Questions
What is the Hinsberg test?
The Hinsberg test uses benzenesulphonyl chloride with aqueous potassium hydroxide. A primary amine gives a sulphonamide that dissolves in the alkali, a secondary amine gives an insoluble sulphonamide, and a tertiary amine does not react and dissolves only when the mixture is acidified.
Why is the sulphonamide of a primary amine soluble in alkali?
The product still has one hydrogen on nitrogen. The two sulphonyl oxygen atoms withdraw electron density, so this hydrogen is acidic and the alkali removes it, giving a water-soluble potassium salt. Acidifying the solution returns the sulphonamide as a precipitate.
What is the carbylamine test and which amines give it?
An amine warmed with chloroform and alcoholic potassium hydroxide gives an isocyanide with a very unpleasant smell. Only primary amines give it, aliphatic and aromatic alike, because the reaction uses up two N-H bonds. Secondary and tertiary amines give no reaction.
Which amines give an azo dye test?
Only aromatic primary amines. Their diazonium salts are stable only in the cold, below about 278 K, so they survive long enough to couple with alkaline beta-naphthol and give an orange-red dye. Aliphatic primary amines lose nitrogen at once, so they give no dye.
How can primary, secondary and tertiary amines be told apart in one experiment?
Use the Hinsberg test. The primary amine dissolves in the alkaline mixture and precipitates on acidifying, the secondary amine gives an insoluble solid straight away, and the tertiary amine does not react but dissolves when acid is added. The carbylamine test can then confirm the primary amine.
How is a mixture of amines separated by Hofmann's method?
This is beyond the 2026 syllabus (JEE Main, JEE Advanced and NEET). The mixture is warmed with diethyl oxalate. The primary amine gives a solid oxamide, the secondary amine gives a liquid oxamic ester and the tertiary amine does not react.
What is the Liebermann nitroso reaction used for?
This is beyond the JEE Main and NEET syllabus. It confirms a secondary amine. The nitrosamine formed with nitrous acid is warmed with phenol and concentrated sulphuric acid, giving a colour that runs from brown and red to blue and green, turns red on dilution with water and greenish blue or violet with alkali.
Which tests on amines are asked in NEET?
NEET follows NCERT: the carbylamine test identifies primary amines, and the Hinsberg test tells the three classes apart. NEET has asked for the foul-smelling product of the carbylamine reaction. It has also asked which amine gives an alkali-insoluble product with Hinsberg's reagent.
What does JEE Main ask about the analysis of amines?
JEE Main asks which amines react with Hinsberg's reagent or give an alkali-insoluble sulphonamide. It also asks which amines give the carbylamine test. Some questions give a formula and observations, such as solubility in dilute acid, and ask for the amine. Others ask for the percentage of nitrogen in a product, or for a formula from percentage composition.