FundamentholLog inStart lesson 1 freeBack to app

NEET 2024, Chemistry Q3: Resonance & Mesomeric Effect

NEET2024Chemistry

Learn this concept: Resonance & Mesomeric Effect →

Q.

The most stable carbocation among the following is:

  1. A

    1

  2. B

    2

  3. C

    3

  4. D

    4

Solution
Given
  • Option A: cyclopentyl
  • Option B: 1-methylcyclohexyl cation
  • Option C:
  • Option D:
IdeaNone of these cations has resonance with a system, so stability depends only on hyperconjugation and the +I effect of alkyl groups. Stability follows the order tertiary > secondary > primary.

Steps

  1. Option A is primary

    Option A: the positive carbon is a attached to one ring carbon, so the cation is primary. It has only 1 -H (the ring CH) and one alkyl group donating by +I. It is the least stable.

  2. Option C is secondary

    Option C: the positive carbon carries an ethyl group and an isopropyl group, so the cation is secondary. The number of -H atoms is:

  3. Option D is secondary

    Option D: the positive carbon carries a methyl group and an isobutyl group, so the cation is secondary. The number of -H atoms is:

  4. Option B is tertiary

    Option B: the positive ring carbon carries a methyl group and two ring groups, so the cation is tertiary. It has three alkyl groups donating by +I. The number of -H atoms is:

  5. Compare the four cations

    Comparing the four cations gives the order of stability.

    Key stepOption B has the largest number of -H atoms and the most alkyl groups on the positive carbon.
AnswerOption B: the 1-methylcyclohexyl cation (tertiary)
TrapA student who believes larger, branched alkyl groups give a stronger +I effect sees ethyl and isopropyl on the cationic carbon of Option C and picks Option C. That cation is only secondary with 3 -H, while Option B is tertiary with 7 -H.

Concept behind this question

Resonance & Mesomeric EffectNotes, formulas and examples →

Practice more Chemistry

Concept-wise practice with instant solutions on Fundamenthol.

Start practicing →