NEET 2019, Chemistry Q38: Group 14 Elements: The Carbon Family
NEET2019Paper 2019Chemistry
Learn this concept: Group 14 Elements: The Carbon Family →
Q.
Which of the following species is not stable?
- A
[SiF6 ]2–
- B
[GeCl6 ]2
- C
[Sn(OH)6 ]2
- D
[SiCl6 ]2–
Solution
Given
- Four hexa-coordinate anions of group 14 elements: , , and .
IdeaThe central atom must use vacant d orbitals to expand to six bonds, and it must be large enough to hold six ligands around it without crowding.
Steps
Check the fluoro ion of Si
: Si has vacant 3d orbitals, and F is very small, so six F atoms fit around Si. This ion is stable.
Check the chloro ion of Ge
: Ge is a larger atom with vacant 4d orbitals, so six Cl atoms can be arranged around it. This ion is stable.
Check the hydroxo ion of Sn
: Sn is larger still, so six OH groups fit easily. This ion is stable and forms when dissolves in alkali.
Check the chloro ion of Si
: the lone pairs of Cl repel one another strongly. The interaction of the Cl lone pairs with the Si orbitals is also weak. This ion is therefore not stable.
Key stepSi is small and each Cl is large. Six Cl atoms cannot be packed around Si.
AnswerOption D:
TrapStudents recall that the d-block contraction makes Ge barely larger than Si, conclude that six Cl atoms cannot fit around Ge either, and choose Option B. In fact Ge is large enough, and is a known stable ion.
Concept behind this question
Group 14 Elements: The Carbon FamilyNotes, formulas and examples →More previous year questions on Group 14 Elements: The Carbon Family
Practice more Chemistry
Concept-wise practice with instant solutions on Fundamenthol.
Start practicing →