FundamentholLog inStart lesson 1 freeBack to app

NEET 2018, Chemistry Q2: Group 17 Elements: The Halogen Family

NEET2018Paper 2018Chemistry

Learn this concept: Group 17 Elements: The Halogen Family →

Q.

Which of the following statements is not true for halogens?

  1. A

    All form monobasic oxyacids

  2. B

    All but fluorine show positive oxidation states

  3. C

    All are oxidizing agents

  4. D

    Chlorine has the highest electron-gain enthalpy

Solution
Given
  • Four statements about the halogens (F, Cl, Br, I)
  • Exactly one is to be chosen as not true
IdeaTest each statement against known halogen chemistry. Three hold without doubt, so the remaining one is the choice. That choice depends on how the oxidation state of F in HOF is treated.

Steps

  1. Check Option A

    Every halogen forms at least one monobasic oxyacid: HOF, HOCl, HOBr, HOI, as well as and . True.

  2. Check Option C

    Every halogen has a strong tendency to gain an electron. The oxidising power falls from to , but all four are oxidising agents. True.

  3. Check Option D

    Fluorine is very small, so an added electron meets strong repulsion from its compact 2p shell. Chlorine therefore has the most negative electron gain enthalpy, about against about for F. True.

  4. Check Option B

    Cl, Br and I show oxidation states of +1, +3, +5 and +7 in their oxyacids and interhalogens. In HOF, F is more electronegative than O, which gives F as , O as and H as . The question treats this statement as the false one because HOF is named fluoric(I) acid, a name that implies F in the +1 state.

    Key stepFluorine is the most electronegative element, so it shows only .
  5. Pick the false statement

    Options A, C and D are correct statements, so Option B is the one to mark.

AnswerOption B
TrapStudents who equate electronegativity with electron gain enthalpy believe fluorine, the most electronegative halogen, must have the highest electron gain enthalpy, so they mark Option D as the false statement. In fact the repulsion within fluorine's compact 2p shell makes chlorine's value (about ) more negative than fluorine's.

Concept behind this question

Group 17 Elements: The Halogen FamilyNotes, formulas and examples →

More previous year questions on Group 17 Elements: The Halogen Family

Practice more Chemistry

Concept-wise practice with instant solutions on Fundamenthol.

Start practicing →