FundamentholLog inStart lesson 1 freeBack to app

JEE Main 2026 Jan 23 Shift 2, Chemistry Q10: Mechanism of Some Important Reactions of Alkenes

JEE Main2026Jan 23, Shift 2Chemistry

Learn this concept: Mechanism of Some Important Reactions of Alkenes →

Q.

Identify (P)

  1. A

    1

  2. B

    2

  3. C

    3

  4. D

    4

Solution
Given
  • Cyclopentane with Br on two adjacent ring carbons
  • The ring carbon next to one C–Br bears a methyl group, and the ring carbon next to the other C–Br bears an ethyl group
  • Reagents: (i) Zn, heat; (ii) HBr
IdeaZn removes the two vicinal Br atoms and forms a C=C bond. HBr then adds through a carbocation, which rearranges by a 1,2-H shift to the most stable tertiary cation. Hyperconjugation, which grows with the number of α-H atoms, decides which tertiary cation forms.

Steps

  1. Debromination gives the alkene

    takes both Br atoms and a double bond forms between the two carbons that carried them. Numbering C1 and C2 for the alkene carbons, this gives 3-ethyl-5-methylcyclopent-1-ene. C5 carries the methyl group (next to C1) and C3 carries the ethyl group (next to C2).

  2. Protonation gives secondary cations

    can add to either alkene carbon. Both choices give a secondary cation with the same number of α-H atoms (three), so neither route is favoured at this stage. One cation sits next to the CH bearing the methyl group. The other sits next to the CH bearing the ethyl group.

  3. 1,2-H shift to tertiary cations

    Each secondary cation takes the hydride from the neighbouring substituted CH. This gives a tertiary cation either at the methyl-bearing carbon or at the ethyl-bearing carbon.

  4. Compare the tertiary cations

    At the methyl-bearing carbon there are (from ) (two ring ) α-H. At the ethyl-bearing carbon there are (from the of ethyl) α-H. The major path goes through the methyl-bearing tertiary cation.

    α-H
    Key stepMore hyperconjugation makes the methyl-bearing tertiary cation more stable.
  5. Bromide captures the cation

    attacks this tertiary carbon. The product has Br and on the same ring carbon, with the ethyl group 1,3 to it. This is 1-bromo-3-ethyl-1-methylcyclopentane.

    Mechanism: debromination, protonation, 1,2-H shift, bromide capture giving the tertiary bromide
  6. Why the other options fail

    Option A is the unrearranged secondary bromide. Option C comes from the less stable tertiary cation (6 α-H). Option D puts Br on the ring between the two substituted carbons, and no cation in this mechanism forms there.

AnswerOption B: 1-bromo-3-ethyl-1-methylcyclopentane
TrapBelieving that ethyl's stronger +I effect makes the ethyl-bearing tertiary cation more stable puts Br on the ethyl carbon, giving Option C. Hyperconjugation actually favours the methyl-bearing cation, with 7 α-H against 6.

Concept behind this question

Mechanism of Some Important Reactions of AlkenesNotes, formulas and examples →

More previous year questions on Mechanism of Some Important Reactions of Alkenes

Practice more Chemistry

Concept-wise practice with instant solutions on Fundamenthol.

Start practicing →