Mechanism of Some Important Reactions
The mechanism of some important reactions of alcohols and ethers comes down to four moves: protonating an oxygen, losing water to a carbocation, attack by a nucleophile, and losing a proton. Hydration of alkenes and dehydration of alcohols run through carbocations, so they follow Markovnikov and Saytzeff rules and can rearrange; ether formation, PBr and SOCl reactions are S2, so the skeleton is kept. Knowing the mechanism of some important reactions lets you predict products instead of memorising them, for JEE Main, JEE Advanced and NEET.
- ★ Must learnHydration: C=C + carbocation ROH (Markovnikov; 3 steps)
- ★ Must learnDehydration: ROH + (slow) alkene; ease 3° 2° 1°
- Ether formation (413 K): ROH + ROR (S2, 1° alcohols)
- ★ Must learnROH + HX: 3°, 2° by S1 (carbocation); , 1° by S2
- ★ Must learn, : O-P or O-S bond first, no carbocation, so no rearrangement (: S2 at the carbon)
- Epoxide + Nu: acid at the more substituted C, base at the less hindered C
Beyond the JEE Main and NEET syllabus - Carbocation shifts: H or moves to give the more stable (3°) cation
1. Four Moves Behind Every Mechanism
The reactions of alcohols and ethers look numerous, but their mechanisms use the same four steps in different orders: (1) an oxygen lone pair takes a proton, which turns OH into , a good leaving group; (2) water leaves, giving a carbocation, if that cation is stable enough; (3) a nucleophile attacks carbon, either the carbocation or, from the back, the carbon still bonded to the leaving group; (4) a proton is lost, from oxygen or from a -carbon.
| Reaction | Mechanism | Page where it is used |
|---|---|---|
| Acid hydration of alkenes | carbocation (reverse of E1) | Preparation of Alcohol |
| Dehydration of alcohols to alkenes | E1 (2°, 3°) | Properties of Alcohol |
| Dehydration of 1° alcohols to ethers | S2 | Preparation of Ether |
| Alcohols with HX, Lucas test | S1 or S2 | Properties of Alcohol |
| Williamson synthesis | S2 | Preparation of Ether |
| Cleavage of ethers by HI | S2 or S1 | Properties of Ether |
2. Acid-Catalysed Hydration of Alkenes
Alkenes add water in the presence of an acid in three steps. The electrons take a proton from to form the more stable carbocation (slow step, which fixes the Markovnikov orientation). Water attacks the carbocation to give an oxonium ion, and a second water molecule removes a proton, regenerating the acid.
3. Dehydration of Alcohols
Heated with concentrated sulphuric acid (or phosphoric acid, or passed over hot alumina) alcohols lose water to give alkenes. The mechanism drawn for ethanol has three steps: protonation of the OH, slow loss of water to give a carbocation, and removal of a -hydrogen by a base.
Because step 2 forms a carbocation, dehydration becomes easier as the cation becomes more stable: tertiary alcohols dehydrate with 20% at 358 K, primary ones need concentrated acid at 443 K. The same carbocation can rearrange by a 1,2-hydride or methyl shift before losing a proton, and the more substituted alkene (Saytzeff) is the major product. Exam answers use the same E1 picture for primary alcohols: with butan-1-ol, a hydride shift turns the 1° cation into a 2° cation, so but-2-ene is the major product.
"Cation? Check the neighbour." Whenever a carbocation forms, look at the next carbon: if moving an H or from it turns a 2° cation into a 3° one, the shift happens first.
A free primary carbocation is very unstable, so for a primary alcohol the real path is probably concerted: the loss of water and the removal of the -hydrogen happen together (E2-like on the protonated alcohol). Exam answers draw the E1 picture of Figure 3, and the product is the same. The key point for both is that protonation must come first because is a poor leaving group while is a good one.
Rate-determining step of alcohol dehydration?
Ease of dehydration: 1°, 2°, 3°?
Major product from 3,3-dimethylbutan-2-ol with acid?
4. Dehydration to Ethers
At 413 K with excess of a primary alcohol, the protonated alcohol is attacked by a second alcohol molecule in an S2 step before it can lose water to a carbocation. The protonated ether then loses a proton. The full three-step drawing is on the Preparation of Ether page; the essential equations are:
5. Alcohols with Hydrogen Halides; the Lucas Reagent
The alcohol is first protonated. A tertiary (or secondary) protonated alcohol loses water to a carbocation, which the halide captures (S1). Methanol and primary alcohols cannot form stable cations, so the halide attacks the protonated alcohol from the back (S2). One exception: when the next carbon has no H (the 2,2-dimethylpropan-1-ol type), a moves to the carbon as water leaves, so the skeleton changes: with HBr it gives 2-bromo-2-methylbutane. Reactivity is 3° 2° 1° for the S1 group, with methanol faster than other primary alcohols (least hindered), and HI HBr HCl.
Chloride is a weak nucleophile, so HCl needs anhydrous zinc chloride with 1° and 2° alcohols. , a Lewis acid, binds the OH oxygen and makes a far better leaving group. The time taken for the insoluble alkyl chloride to cloud the solution is the Lucas test.
rearrangement possible
rate depends on ] only
no rearrangement, inversion
rate depends on [] too
6. Phosphorus Halides and Thionyl Chloride
, and convert 1° and 2° alcohols to alkyl halides without strong acid. The oxygen first bonds to phosphorus (or sulphur), displacing a halide ion. With and the halide then attacks the carbon from the back (S2) and pushes out the phosphorus group. With the alkyl chlorosulphite formed first breaks down to the alkyl chloride and . No carbocation forms in either case, so there is no rearrangement.
Because bromide attacks from the side opposite the group, inverts a chiral carbon: the ends up on the side opposite to where the was (Solved Example 6).
"No cation, no surprise." and keep the carbon skeleton; HX with 2° or 3° alcohols can rearrange it. Choose when the question warns about rearrangement.
7. Ring Opening of Epoxides
The strained three-membered ring opens under milder conditions than ordinary ethers. In acid the oxygen is protonated; the C-O bond to the more substituted carbon is longer and weaker and that carbon carries more positive charge, so the nucleophile attacks it (S1-like). In base a strong nucleophile attacks the less hindered carbon in a clean S2 step. In both cases attack is from the side opposite the oxygen, so cyclic epoxides give trans products.
Beyond the JEE Main and NEET syllabus
Methyloxirane + /: which carbon is attacked?
Methyloxirane + : which carbon?
Why do epoxides open with nucleophiles that ordinary ethers ignore?
8. Which Mechanism?
The flowchart asks one question in several forms: does a carbocation form? If yes, expect Markovnikov or Saytzeff selectivity and possible shifts; if no, expect S2 with the skeleton unchanged. The mind map places every mechanism of the chapter on one screen.
9. Solved Examples
Methanol and primary alcohols react by S2 (the methyl cation is far too unstable for S1). In S2 the rate falls with crowding at the carbon; the methyl carbon has only hydrogens around it, so backside attack is easiest and methanol reacts fastest.
(A)
(B)
(C) both equally
(D) none
Answer: (B). The protonated 2° alcohol loses water to a 2° carbocation; a methyl shifts from the neighbouring quaternary carbon to give a 3° cation, which bromide captures: 2-bromo-2,3-dimethylbutane.
(A) methylenecyclobutane
(B) cyclopentene
(C) cyclopentane
(D) 1-methylcyclobutene
Answer: (B). Loss of water would leave a primary cation next to the ring. Instead a ring C-C bond moves to that carbon (ring expansion), which turns the strained four-membered ring into a five-membered one and gives a 2° cyclopentyl cation; loss of gives cyclopentene. (C) has no double bond, and (A) and (D) keep the strained ring.
(A) butan-1-ol
(B) butan-2-ol
(C) 2-methylbutan-2-ol
(D) 2,2-dimethylpropan-1-ol
Answer: (C). It is the only tertiary alcohol, so it reacts by S1 through the stable 3° cation . (B) is secondary and slower; (A) and (D) are primary, and (D), crowded next to the reacting carbon, is the slowest.
The 3° cation can lose H from a (giving 2-methylbut-1-ene) or from the (giving 2-methylbut-2-ene). The more substituted, trisubstituted alkene is major: 2-methylbut-2-ene (Saytzeff).
JEE Advanced
Inverted. Bromide attacks the carbon from the side opposite the group (S2), so the other three groups turn inside out like an umbrella and ends up on the side opposite to where was. With aqueous HBr a 2° alcohol partly racemises through the carbocation.
(1) The electrons take a proton from ; the proton goes to the ring CH carbon, so the positive charge sits on the carbon carrying the methyl group, a 3° cation (Markovnikov). (2) Water attacks that cation, giving an oxonium ion. (3) A second water molecule removes a proton. The product is 1-methylcyclopentan-1-ol, with on the more substituted carbon.
Beyond the JEE Main and NEET syllabus
(a) Acid: attack at the more substituted carbon, 2-methoxypropan-1-ol, . (b) Base: attack at the carbon, 1-methoxypropan-2-ol, .
The equilibrium . Dilute acid and a large excess of water (low temperature) favour the alcohol; concentrated acid, high temperature and removal of the volatile alkene favour dehydration (Le Chatelier). Both directions pass through the same carbocation.
- Give the mechanism type of ethanol → diethyl ether at 413 K.Answer: S2 on the protonated alcohol.
- Which step is rate-determining in acid hydration of propene?Answer: protonation of the alkene to the carbocation.
- Product of 3-methylbutan-2-ol with HBr (major)?Answer: 2-bromo-2-methylbutane (after a hydride shift).
- Why does help HCl react with 1° and 2° alcohols?Answer: it binds the OH oxygen and makes a better leaving group.
- Name the gaseous by-products of ROH + .Answer: and HCl.
- Suggest a mechanism for 2,2-dimethylpropan-1-ol + HBr giving 2-bromo-2-methylbutane.Answer: protonation of the OH; loss of water with a 1,2-methyl shift, giving the 3° cation ; capture by bromide.
- Beyond the JEE Main and NEET syllabus Which carbon of 2,2-dimethyloxirane does attack in acid?Answer: the tertiary carbon.
Common Mistakes to Avoid
- Forgetting the protonation step. is a poor leaving group; the alcohol must be protonated first.
- Writing a primary carbocation freely. Primary alcohols react with HX, and form ethers, by S2. (For dehydration, exam answers do draw the E1 picture with the 1° cation, as in Figure 3.)
- Ignoring rearrangement in HX or reactions of 2° alcohols. Check for a hydride or methyl shift.
- Expecting rearrangement with or . No carbocation forms, so the skeleton is kept.
- Writing the less substituted alkene as major. Dehydration gives the Saytzeff (more substituted) alkene.
- Swapping acid and base regiochemistry for epoxides. Acid: more substituted C; base: less hindered C. (Epoxide ring opening is beyond the JEE Main and NEET syllabus.)
- Treating hydration as irreversible. It is the exact reverse of dehydration; conditions decide the direction.
- Putting the slow step of dehydration at protonation. The slow step is loss of water to the carbocation.
Frequently Asked Questions
What is the mechanism of acid-catalysed hydration of alkenes?
It has three steps. The alkene takes a proton from the hydronium ion to form the more stable carbocation, water attacks the carbocation to form an oxonium ion, and a second water molecule removes a proton to give the alcohol and regenerate the acid. The first step decides the Markovnikov orientation.
What is the mechanism of dehydration of ethanol?
Ethanol is protonated by sulphuric acid, the protonated alcohol loses water to form a carbocation in the slow step, and a base removes a hydrogen from the neighbouring carbon to form ethene. It is the reverse of acid catalysed hydration.
Why do tertiary alcohols dehydrate most easily?
The slow step of dehydration is the loss of water to form a carbocation. Tertiary carbocations are the most stable because three alkyl groups donate electron density, so the order of ease of dehydration is tertiary greater than secondary greater than primary.
How is diethyl ether formed from ethanol mechanistically?
At 413 K with excess ethanol, one ethanol molecule is protonated and a second ethanol molecule attacks its carbon from the back in an SN2 step, pushing out water. The protonated ether then loses a proton to give diethyl ether.
Why do PBr3 and SOCl2 not cause rearrangement?
They first convert the OH group into an excellent leaving group bonded to phosphorus or sulphur. With PBr3 the bromide then displaces it from the back in an SN2 step; with SOCl2 the alkyl chlorosulphite breaks down to the alkyl chloride and sulphur dioxide. No free carbocation forms, so there is nothing to rearrange.
Why does an epoxide open at different carbons in acid and base?
In acid the protonated epoxide has more positive charge on the more substituted carbon, so the nucleophile goes there. In base there is no charge, and a strong nucleophile attacks the less hindered carbon by SN2. Both attacks come from the side opposite the oxygen. Epoxide ring opening is beyond the JEE Main and NEET syllabus.
Which mechanisms of alcohols are asked in NEET?
NEET follows NCERT: the three-step mechanisms of acid hydration of alkenes, dehydration of ethanol to ethene and formation of diethyl ether, plus the order of reactivity of alcohols with HX. Knowing which step forms the carbocation answers most questions.
How does JEE test carbocation rearrangements in alcohols?
JEE Main and Advanced give a secondary alcohol next to a quaternary or tertiary carbon, or a cyclic carbinol, and ask for the product with HBr or hot acid. A hydride, methyl or ring-bond shift to the more stable cation comes first, then capture or Saytzeff elimination.